- Sep 8, 2007
- 1,162
- 580
- AFL Club
- West Coast
That I could understand
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Mega Thread Delist/Trade/Draft Supermegaultrathread - Trade Period Edition
- Thread starter Miguel Sanchez
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Yamumluvsbigcox
Cancelled
- Oct 22, 2012
- 8,714
- 14,107
- AFL Club
- West Coast
So who do we want at 43 ? Maybe Jansen , like the look of Riley Knight as a project player !
Small Moves
Premiership Player
So how many list spots do we need to officially free up now?
Willing to give Vozzo the benefit of the doubt until now...wtf is he doing?!?!
Why would we trade for another pick in this draft, meaning we need to turn over an extra player when we have a new senior coach coming in?!?
Totally miffed...
We have plenty of players that we know will not be in the mix under Simpson as they can't kick for shit. Some will go this year, more will go next year no doubt. I can't wait till we get a team where most players can hit some freaking targets.
If it was up to me, at the end of next year we should trade Priddis and Rosa while they have value to get a whole lot of sub 30 picks in a strong draft.
Depends how many picks we want to use. If we go to 49, then 3. If we only go to 43, then 2.
Keys
Looking for a cloud to yell at
- Moderator
- #7,183
We've basically moved on 5 blokes who's bodies had nothing more to give plus Hams who I think wasn't keen on playing for East Perth.
Upgrading Tunbridge and Bennell was premature as it robbed us of a bit of flexibility with our list management (particularly as the decision was made before Simpson's appointment) because we currently only have one list spot available after the acquisition of Xellis and Yeo.
Means we are going to have to delist at least two and possibly three players if we are to use any of 31,43 or 49. The fact that we traded next years 3rd rounder to Gold Coast means that we obviously want to use 43.
Next year Glass and Cox will be considering retirement and a heap of others will be trying to prove they deserve a new contract
Maybe if Garlett's still there at 49 we'll pick him, like a pseudo-rookie pick
I hear you, was still thinking Simpson would give it a year to suss everything out. Especially considering we've already had six retirements as such.
Ah well...bring on the draft.
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,506
- 28,840
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I'm not saying we should, I'm just not sure who else we could delist in addition to Newman and Dalziell, and we'll need to delist three to use pick 49. I read somewhere that we offered Dalziell a year so that's why I didn't suggest him. I'm not sure who else is not contracted.
This is from the contracts thread:
Contracted until the end of 2013 (3):
Blayne Wilson - Believed to have signed a 1 year contract (2013) in October 2012.
Brad Dalziell - Believed to have signed a 1 year contract (2013) in October 2012.
Cale Morton - Contracted for 2013.
Unknown Contracts (12):
Matt Rosa – Signed a contract in May 2012.
Josh Hill - Signed a contract in September 2012.
Jamie Cripps -
Brant Colledge - Probably signed for 2 years (2013, 2014) when drafted (No source)
Adam Carter - Probably signed for 2 years (2013, 2014) when drafted (No source)
Mark Hutchings - Probably signed for 2 years (2013, 2014) when drafted (No source)
Fraser McInnes - Probably signed for 2 years (2012, 2013) when drafted (No source)
Murray Newman - Probably signed for 2 years (2012, 2013) when drafted (No source)
Matt Priddis – Signed a contract in June 2013.
Jeremy McGovern -
Simon Tunbridge -
Jamie Bennell -
IMO more likely that he's seen somebody out there that he wants to get in
I honestly think Morton is gone and Newman will become a rookie.
The hardest one then is the third.
The hardest one then is the third.
I am actually reasonably happy with our trade period. I really like Yeo, we should get Sheed/Acres with 11 and still have a couple of picks for sliders as well as hopefully DG.
I will be very disappointed if we chop Wilson though, I reckon he has some really big upside..
I will be very disappointed if we chop Wilson though, I reckon he has some really big upside..
So we have one live pick.
Need to delist at least 2.
Morton, Newman? Who else?
Need to delist at least 2.
Morton, Newman? Who else?
exactly.
dalziell is depth at best. And if he is in the team I suspect we have plenty of injury concerns and the year can be called a write off. May as well get time into youngsters.
Morton is just meh, took more then half the season to find form in the wafl and even then he wasn't world beater. What's worse is he seemingly has no role in the team so we are just wasting our time.
also wouldn't lose sleep if wilson got cut. he is too slow and I would much rather pump games into Carter.
I'm quite happy to take 4 picks in the ND.
I want to keep Morton to see if he can reach his potential...but where is he really going to end up playing though? i agree with keeping Wilson.
Looks like Morton's gone.
And I really hope we don't get rid of Wilson!
Could Dalziell get the chop? Would be very unlucky considering the year he had but its not entirely out of the question as we saw his best this year and its hardly irreplaceable. Especially considering the acquisitions of Yeo and Ellis.
And I really hope we don't get rid of Wilson!
Could Dalziell get the chop? Would be very unlucky considering the year he had but its not entirely out of the question as we saw his best this year and its hardly irreplaceable. Especially considering the acquisitions of Yeo and Ellis.
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
We will have to agree to disagree.
Carlton really wanted Docherty, yet they held firm on 33 and not 32 (only 1 spot!).
You see it as narrow sighted, I see it as the club displaying that they are willing to compromise and it sets a precedent for not just this draft but potentially for drafts to come.
Neither of us know if we really wanted pick 10 and when collingwood said no we just said ummmm ok. While I hope it doesn't happen imagine Collingwood and Brisbane picking up Sheed and Acres just before 11. Before you say there are many other options that will be left.. I question whether a) we will miss out on a slider to #6 and b) now we miss out who we really want at 11.
As I said before I am happy with where we're at but to think we couldn't have done better and to believe that every move out club has made is the right move is naive.
Agree. Even as a mature age rookie selection. There's some talent around in the state leagues. A project ruckman to develop for the period post Dean Cox would be nice to
Starting to warm more to Acres at pick 11 if he is available or Sheed just to prove Terry Wallace is a dead set spanner head again.
Would love one of Cripps, Jansen or Tsitas with a second round pick
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
- Locked
- Poll
- Locked
