DRAFT PICK 43 1997 vs DRAFT PICK 14 1997

[Tasroo]

Individually Goodes has already passed Black.
Forget the awards and even the flags for a second - I love Black and don't think he has peaked, but Goodes is an absolute freak.

If you could see into the future in 1997 - I am sure every club would draft Goodes.

Big call!

 

[CharlieG]

Aesthetically, Goodes might be better. He might be more important to Sydney. But a very big call IMO to say he's the "one that got away" compared to Black, at least until both their careers are over.

Take it to the Polls board for me - if I post it, the fact I'm a Swans fan might prejudice the vote (such is the pettiness of some on BF). I suspect it would be close, but it'd be interesting to see who came out ahead.