Rumour GFC 2022 Player Trading, Drafting FA, Rumours and Wish lists PT2

[catempire]

Not sure if Hawks need Clark if they think Worpel will get back to his best and that Cooper S will be a long term player for them?

 

[catempire]

I'm not too wedded Clark, I'm perfectly fine with trading 7 to get something useable for next years draft, if only just to give us some more capital to trade in more mature players next year.

Yup.

 

[Drunkcat]

We would be mad not to take Humphreys if the Hawks did that

would be mad to take him, i have seen players with 1 arm kick a footy better than him, and you can not fix it now

 

[Sky]

Just get the deal done with the Crows. Pick 7 for their future first which on points may seem like a rort but isn’t next years draft supposed to be better? I’m also not sure if they even own a F1

 

[Vdubs]

Interesting and nostalgic for me. 13 Premiership Players IIRC.

 

[Warhorse]

would be mad to take him, i have seen players with 1 arm kick a footy better than him, and you can not fix it now

I wouldnt have a problem with him. Just not at pick 7

 

[strauchnyy]

Has Geelong made any sort of commitment to take Clark if available or is this all Bigfooty and media driven?

98% ‘he’s a falcon so means we’re selecting him’ driven

 

[strauchnyy]

I have a feeling Tsatas may slide on draft day. If that happens I could see saints trying to trade for our pick to get him given they’ve said they’re after run and speed…

Something like 7 and our future first for 9 + saints future first + a future third or something.

We’d still have good players available at 9 that imo are superior to Clark

 

[CatsDoItBetter]

There was a decent mature KPD in the VFL racking up big stats... What's his name again? and what draft selection is he likely to go at?

Probably not a priority considering we kept Sav.

Ethan Phillips

 

[Boxhead_31]

I have a feeling Tsatas may slide on draft day. If that happens I could see saints trying to trade for our pick to get him given they’ve said they’re after run and speed…

Something like 7 and our future first for 9 + saints future first + a future third or something.

We’d still have good players available at 9 that imo are superior to Clark

We can't trade our future first

 

[Stokey]

We can't trade our future first

Even if it's replaced?

 

[Boxhead_31]

Even if it's replaced?

Don't think that is allowed, but that could be wrong

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Based on nothing but gut feel, Hawks take Clark and Cats trade out 7.

I reckon if they do that (ie humphrey and clark 5 and 6) we take either buss or mackenzie at 7 but a trade out is possible.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Closhesy hasn't played football for three years?
Cause that is the only way he can be Cat B isn't it? NGA's are Primary list or Cat A aren't they?

No with nga players if they get bid main draft you have to take them on the primary list but if they get through the main draft with no bid you can auto add them as a cat b rookie.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

There was a decent mature KPD in the VFL racking up big stats... What's his name again? and what draft selection is he likely to go at?

Probably not a priority considering we kept Sav.

Ethan phillips.

 

[Sky]

I have a feeling Tsatas may slide on draft day. If that happens I could see saints trying to trade for our pick to get him given they’ve said they’re after run and speed…

Something like 7 and our future first for 9 + saints future first + a future third or something.

We’d still have good players available at 9 that imo are superior to Clark

I thought Ross Lyon preferred slow list cloggers.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Interesting and nostalgic for me. 13 Premiership Players IIRC.

View attachment 1543143

Not one of Stephen Wells’ fav hunting grounds?

 

[Vdubs]

Not one of Stephen Wells’ fav hunting grounds?

Not when we have the Falcons wanting to come to us so readily.
We have had a few over the years
Jason Snell
Tim Finocchiaro
James Parsons
And Flynn Kroeger

 

[D BRIDGE]

I have a feeling Tsatas may slide on draft day. If that happens I could see saints trying to trade for our pick to get him given they’ve said they’re after run and speed…

Something like 7 and our future first for 9 + saints future first + a future third or something.

We’d still have good players available at 9 that imo are superior to Clark

Surely we take Tsatas if available... Gotta be long odds though to still be on the board at pick #8.

If it happens, yeah I could see teams very keen to try to get our pick.

 

[BigCat1]

Tsastis would be the perfect fit for us. He’s a different height to Bruhn and co and he’s got the athletic makeup which I think is just a given now days esp with the way we play. You need speed. He has it.

I like Clark but he’s very average speed and a small. What will the game look like in 5 years. He’ll play 200 games and I’ll be happy with him but Tsastis, Bruhn and Holmes would be a terrific combo. It just seems easier to find 180(ish) mids lower in the draft.

Just not sure why Essendon overlook him. I get how GC and Haw would.

 

[calder_daddy]

We can't trade our future first

Even if it's replaced?

You can trade a FR1 if it’s for another FR1

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

I have a feeling Tsatas may slide on draft day. If that happens I could see saints trying to trade for our pick to get him given they’ve said they’re after run and speed…

Something like 7 and our future first for 9 + saints future first + a future third or something.

We’d still have good players available at 9 that imo are superior to Clark

Clark first and foremost. The kid's a star.

Only trade out 7 if he's taken.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Not when we have the Falcons wanting to come to us so readily.
We have had a few over the years
Jason Snell
Tim Finocchiaro
James Parsons
And Flynn Kroeger

Snell had some talent, just extremely unfortunate.

I remember him and Ronnie Burns debuting in the same game v Melbourne where Snell kicked 3 and I thought we had a very good future forward combo..

 

[Vdubs]

Snell had some talent, just extremely unfortunate.

I remember him and Ronnie Burns debuting in the same game v Melbourne where Snell kicked 3 and I thought we had a very good future forward combo..

Add Paul Lynch around that time too, give or take

 

[Sire of Claude]

I was at the G when Snell copped a dreadful injury. He was a good player - kicked 5 goals in the last quarter once.