Rumour GFC 2024 Player Trading, Drafting FA, Rumours and Wish lists Pt 3

[Turbocat]

They have zero need to trade for Baker or Owies:

• Baker can be picked up via the PSD; it's not like Richmond is going to select him with pick 1 in that
• Owies will be a DFA very shortly as Carlton didn't offer him a contract

They are doing the nice thing by trading for them, but it's also a very very stupid thing when it involves moving on pick 3

I would have got 14 from Carlton for Barrass . Then get Baker…keep 3. Haw had totally played West Coast here

alt..

Off P26 or … do what Geelong is doing and threaten to put Baker in the draft.. and get nothing Rich…. Perhaps add something..


owies … we will have a look at all the dfa before we sign you..


The only logic I can see is they really want Bo Allen … and 3 is too early to call his name.

 

[cats_09]

And we have our first confirmed player involved trade in over a week

 

[PzBlinky]

Compo for losing a bunch of players to a new team IIRC.
Can't remember the players, Hamilton I think was one, nor remember the expansion team, bears maybe?

Lions weren't around til mid-late 90s, they were still the Bad News Bears then. But that could've been the reason.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

You know the draft this year is so flat I can't rightly say for sure that FOS is better than Harvey Langford at the draft, though Langford would probably go at pick 10. Maybe in that context pick 3 for the two Blues teens picks isn't terrible.

It's the losing picks for Baker and Owies part that kills me. Baker is a good player but a second round pick is his value.

Owies hit the scoreboard a bit but it's clearly system over talent there with the strong midfield sending it to the KPFs. If Curnow/McKay are bringing to ground instead of marking then the backline is doing it's job. Owies is going to be awful at West coast.

 

[Mad_Hatter]

WCE, not content with being bent over by the Cats a few years ago, decide for the devils threesome and get bent over by 2 clubs in the same trade!
Fair effort.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

And we have our first confirmed player involved trade in over a week

I honestly didn't believe it wouod happen until I saw this.

My god

 

[Mad_Hatter]

Lions weren't around til mid-late 90s, they were still the Bad News Bears then. But that could've been the reason.

Yup edited for that reason, I just default to calling them the lions for some reason.

 

[cats_09]

You know how slow this past week has gone when Trade Radio is even taking the piss out of the situation

 

[MisterMarcus]

Only thing I can possibly think of is that most of this year's top draftees are mummy's boys who have told WCE they don't want to go to Perth.

So WCE have traded down to the range of a player they believe wants to come - or a local WA boy, and traded for Baker who at least wants to be there.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I can’t wait for my lunch break to read the WCE board

Just say your going to the toilet fake break..

 

[Zouz Kitty]

Who could blame Harley for asking to be traded to Geelong in a couple years?

This editing of quotes is fun

 

[Kitcat]

A reason for the delay in the Smith trade is that Bulldogs are not trading to bring another player in so there is no rush for them. They are going to the draft but ultimately need a first round pick. Ours.

 

[My Tilly]

Wouldn't it be comical if Carlton now offered us their pick 3 for De Koning

 

[SkittleCats]

Only thing I can possibly think of is that most of this year's top draftees are mummy's boys who have told WCE they don't want to go to Perth.

So WCE have traded down to the range of a player they believe wants to come - or a local WA boy, and traded for Baker who at least wants to be there.

There's a thread on the AFL subreddit basically arguing this. WCE know that nobody they might get for pick 3 will stay, so trade down to get a local kid or someone who has indicated he doesn't mind making the move. Plus they get a player who wants to be there in Baker.

The conspiracy theory part of that post is that this is happening a lot behind closed doors as a way to prevent the draft from being challenged in court, as it probably doesnt align with Aus labour laws, and the AFL don't want the magnifying glass placed over it. Which if true could extend to the Bailey Smith issue as well.

 

[petrolium]

Only thing I can possibly think of is that most of this year's top draftees are mummy's boys who have told WCE they don't want to go to Perth.

So WCE have traded down to the range of a player they believe wants to come - or a local WA boy, and traded for Baker who at least wants to be there.

This 100%. Unfortunately the kids of today are different to those of yesteryear. Even considering this, it is still an unbelievably bad trade for WC. Surely there must be something else missing/yet to be announced.. even some sort of handshake agreement of favourable future trading. Whilst WC are feeling generous, it would be remiss of us to not ask for Harley Reid for a future R3.

 

[Grimoz]

Smith deal between Cats and Dogs farfetched apparently!!

The "emotional toll" on Bailey Smith if he's sent to the National Draft

Bailey Smith could join a rare club as a deal between Geelong and the Western Bulldogs looks farfetched.

www.zerohanger.com

 

[cats_09]

Brisbane loading up on picks for matching bids

 

[Grimoz]

Wouldn't it be comical if Carlton now offered us their pick 3 for De Koning

No it would be bloody wonderful!!!

 

[calder_daddy]

Wouldn't it be comical if Carlton now offered us their pick 3 for De Koning

It would only be comical if we didn’t say yes to that

 

[#6 Thorp #7 Selwood LOL]

5 year deal for Baker and 3 for Owies. Lol.

 

[Turbocat]

You know how slow this past week has gone when Trade Radio is even taking the piss out of the situation

This would have to be the most constipated trade period ever ….. and a lot is becuse of the way the draft is rated. No one is giving picks for players. As much as I hate it … maybe the fal should have changed the futures to. plus 2 years ahead thsi year instead of waiting...

 

[rocker_oz33]

What other silly ness we going to see before the day is over.

 

[Cursed Cat]

Compo for losing a bunch of players to a new team IIRC.
Can't remember the players, Hamilton I think was one, nor remember the expansion team, bears maybe?

Stephen Reynoldson might have been another

 

[Turbocat]

Stephen Reynoldson might have been another

Cameron I think was the other ..

Edit ..

Renoldyson, OKeeffee Evans …start up …. then Cameron Hamilton to get P1

1990 Trade for David Cameron and Shane Hamilton​

See Other Trades in 1990

Geelong
What Geelong Gave	What Geelong Got
	David Cameron	15 games		23 XG
	Shane Hamilton	47 games		16 XG
					Pick 1	Stephen Hooper	21 games	3000 points	218 XG
0 picks	2 players	62 games	0 points	39 XG	1 pick	0 players	21 games	3000 points	218 XG
Brisbane
What Brisbane Gave	What Brisbane Got
						David Cameron	15 games		23 XG
						Shane Hamilton	47 games		16 XG
Pick 1	Stephen Hooper	21 games	3000 points	218 XG
1 pick	0 players	21 games	3000 points	218 XG	0 picks	2 players	62 games	0 points	39 XG

 

[calder_daddy]

What other silly ness we going to see before the day is over.

CO with his full contract