Review Good, Acceptable, and Putrid vs Kitty Kats

[Scorpus]

Remember those draft picks we coughed up thanks to Trigg?

That’s what we’re missing.

Not even close to the biggest issue right now

 

[Gets!]

Fogarty, Greenwood and Gallucci in.

Seeds, Mackay, Jenkins out.

 

[Infra Ted]

Seedsman going down just put the cherry on top of the crap sundae. Really nearly done with this season and it's only round 3

 

[Crowboto]

Our premiership window has closed. Back to another couple of decades of 6th to 10th finishes.

Woohoo the life of a Crows fsn.

 

[ManInTheArena]

Good:

Brad Crouch. It's easy to forget he's only a 60 game player that missed a whole season of football. Elite AFL player. Just imagine if he had 150 under his belt like he should have.
Sloane
Keath
ROB. Not sure why people are hacking on him, it was his first game of AFL in two years. Started rusty as you'd expect but thought he worked his way into it and probably ended up on par with Stanley.
Third quarter.

Bad:
Gibbs disposal for an elite player was really disappointing. He looked nonchalant.

Ugly:
Kelly. He's not AFL standard.
Walker's game. I'm starting to lose a little faith in the big man.
Seeds knee.
Our forward entries.

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

How can you not have Kelly listed as putrid?

It’s probably easier to work back from who should get a game next week. Sloane, Smith, Millera, Brouch, Mrouch. Maybe Lynch? Everyone else can GAGF.

 

[Crows I Am]

I know ROB's skills aren't great but at least he provides a contest and his 2nd efforts when the ball hits the ground were great. Reminds me a bit of Maric, never going to be a star but always gives everything he has.

 

[WAG]

Also.. ROB is a salt and sugar free Sauce. Scary given we have no other out. Take the Carlton pick and get a decent ruck ffs.

 

[Anzacpaul]

But Jones has never been dropped in his life.

Just meant it's always the low hanging fruit that goes out, and never a big name to make a statement.

 

[Scorpus]

We have three first round draft picks running around in the SANFL plus a CLEAR best 22 player in Greenwood.

Why the **** aren't we doing everything to play these blokes when this is the sort of footy we dish up without them?

 

[CrowBloke]

Anybody else notice that JJ's default positioning/stance when close to the ball on the ground is that of a basketballer?
Knees bent, slight crouch-leaning-forward, hands out wide as if he's guarding space and ... WAITING.
Waiting for someone else to do something. Waiting for the oppo to grab the ball. Waiting before he does anything.

Josh, dive in, or crash the pack, throw your weight around, punch the ground ball out of their hands (or from between their legs) to a teammate and ffs, MAKE A CONTEST willya???

 

[Scorpus]

Suspected ACL for Seedsman:

https://www.afc.com.au/news/2019-04-04/injury-update-paul-seedsman

 

[GameofSloanes]

Good:
Brad Crouch
Chayce Jones

Bad:
Everyone else

Ugly:
Forward line
Coaching staff

Chayce jones? Yeah he did like 2 things all match and shows signs but was probably in our worst 4

 

[1970crow]

Coaching our forwards and they are an absolute rabble. He is a terrible, terrible coach

It wasn’t popular but even during our halcyon 2017 I posted that our forward group is a downhill skier. Hart might be shit, but they’ve not changed. They’ve been worked out and they still only want the easy goals. Playing in front and making your opponent work to get around you remains a foreign concept.

 

[Anzacpaul]

Fogarty, Greenwood and Gallucci in.

Seeds, Mackay, Jenkins out.

Mackay ain't getting dropped now Seed is out. Team structure and all that. Charlie Bucket 'till the end.

 

[marvin]

We looked like a team that had never taken a kick in before.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Simmo28]

Disgraceful. Haven't been so angry at our performance since the Sando era.

If heads don't roll after this... well what can you do?

When have heads rolled except when Blight arrived and oh shit guess what happened????


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Iron]

Great: brad crouch still out there and fit. Just get through the season friendo.

 

[GameofSloanes]

Putrid
Kelly
Mackay
Atkins.. serious question.. was he even out there in that second half?
Mackay
Gibbs
Umpiring
Lynch’s field passing
Mackay
Our centre bounce work
ROB’s goal set shot
Laird
Mackay

Barely a pass mark
Eddie
Jenkins
Tex
Seedsman quiet and please tell me he isnt out for the rest of the season

Good
**** all

Seed and Tex were awful. Why seed was playing fwd pocket I'll never know. Gibbs was ok without being great lynch was good but made a few bad mistakes

 

[Viva la Mattner]

Other than Kelly and Hartigan being trash

Here is what sums us up
A bunch of yes men in the box lead by a soft head coach


How can you just laugh at that?
Clarkson, Hardwick, Lyon would tear them a new one
Not good ‘ol Don

“We’ll review that”

 

[Bernie L]

A lot of dumb decisions out there tonight.

Gibbs, Lynch, Kelly, Atkins, McKay, Murphy, Seedsman all very ordinary. Gibbs was a turnover merchant.

Tex treid hard, but do you think anyone could kick it to him. Forward entries were woeful.

Keath very good again. Crouch's as usual, Sloane excellent. You could see Rory was fuming on the ground after the game.

ROB held his own.

 

[Infra Ted]

Good:

Brad Crouch. It's easy to forget he's only a 60 game player that missed a whole season of football. Elite AFL player. Just imagine if he had 150 under his belt like he should have.
Sloane
Keath
ROB. Not sure why people are hacking on him, it was his first game of AFL in two years. Started rusty as you'd expect but thought he worked his way into it and probably ended up on par with Stanley.
Third quarter.

Bad:
Gibbs disposal for an elite player was really disappointing. He looked nonchalant.

Ugly:
Kelly. He's not AFL standard.
Walker's game. I'm starting to lose a little faith in the big man.
Seeds knee.
Our forward entries.

Agree with ROB. Thought he wasn't too bad. Would rather play him than Sauce. At least he has upside.

 

[Eagleboy2011]

Mackay ain't getting dropped now Seed is out. Team structure and all that. Charlie Bucket 'till the end.

I didn't think McKay was in the side tonight.

 

[Simmo28]

Players seem to be missing some spark and energy.

Starting to think we should have been more cautious about believing the happy clappy video clips from pre season.

CM camp coming up


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Firewalker]

Kelly absolutely putrid.

He’s just shit, but you have to go back to our drafting and trading for why this guy is playing, they drafted 1 med/small defender from 2013-2017 - McPherson and he can’t get on the park, so when Brown went down they literally only have Kelly in their minds as a defender