Review Good/Bad/Ugly vs Richmond, R5 2022

[jimvic]

I don't agree with what Cotch did and should have got a week but Tex has no right to talk about shoe being on the other foot. If a member of the crowd yelled out what tex did they get their membership stripped and banned from the stadium?

Pretty much irrelevant comment - Cotchin is a sniper from way back that everyone other than Richmond supporters will admit, and Tex has just called out his protected species status

 

[jimvic]

There have been plenty of cases of recent history of "fans" being banned for years for racism, Tex got off lightly very lightly. Media manager should keep him away from the microphone very poor choice of words considering.

again totally irrelevant to a sniper act by Cotchin

 

[BRL121]

He's not really complaining about the umpires though, is he? He's complaining about the staggering incompetence & bias of the MRO, which is not protected the way the umpires are.

Of course: that's why I put quotes around "umpires".

 

[Mr_Moogle]

This argument that Tex is not allowed to have opinions about footy on account of the racism scandal is pretty hilarious. Somebody should tell Eddie McGuire before he cashes another pay cheque.

 

[MRB37]

It's McClure, so who knows, but would fit with the recent maniacal authoritarian angle the AFL is taking lately

 

[BACCS]

This might have something to do with the fact that almost none of our F50 entries hit the target.

Right… must be why we have kicked 15 goals in 3 consecutive weeks for the first time since 2017 then. Tex, Berg and Gollant are marking the ball well in contested situations and on the lead, Murphy and Laird in particular with some great kicks to leads in the Richmond game.

 

[Scorpus]

It's McClure, so who knows, but would fit with the recent maniacal authoritarian angle the AFL is taking lately

If they sanction him he should double down

 

[hey shorty]

If they sanction him he should double down

"I told you so"

 

[BACCS]

I’m glad the AFL are focusing on the big issues this week like players waving their arms in the air and a player being annoyed at a player kicking him in the leg and getting off with a small fine.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

"I told you so"

Exactly - if the VAFL sanction Walker, it confirms his thoughts are correct.

 

[thebirdman 24]

It's McClure, so who knows, but would fit with the recent maniacal authoritarian angle the AFL is taking lately

Ridiculous. The AFL can't handle criticism.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Ridiculous. The AFL can't handle criticism.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

They just want to be unaccountable.

Thank goodness Gil the dill is gone as qe couldn't possibly have a more disconnected dumbarse CEO.

Really hope someone from club land like Gale gets the gig & returns the game back in the right direction... as well as clearing out some of these useless AFL lackies.

 

[George Kramer]

If Tex goes for this after appearing on a segment hosted by a board director, he needs to stop going on MMM and doing media. Tex says it how he sees it, he doesn’t have a filter and will continue to cop it.

 

[adelaidecrows]

If Tex goes for this after appearing on a segment hosted by a board director, he needs to stop going on MMM and doing media. Tex says it how he sees it, he doesn’t have a filter and will continue to cop it.

They wont suspend him, but he will get a fine. The AFL should acknowledge his frustration though. Especially the kick by Cotchin and the Nank head hit on Cook can be added to the long line of evidence the Tigers get away with a lot.

 

[Jinglebells32]

I don't agree with what Cotch did and should have got a week but Tex has no right to talk about shoe being on the other foot. If a member of the crowd yelled out what tex did they get their membership stripped and banned from the stadium?

Tex didn't yell anything out. He made a wrong comment in the huddle at 3 quarter time that one of the crows staff reported to the AFL

 

[cleanhands]

I don't agree with what Cotch did and should have got a week but Tex has no right to talk about shoe being on the other foot. If a member of the crowd yelled out what tex did they get their membership stripped and banned from the stadium?

I think you need to get all the facts before you post on here

 

[Grenville]

Thank you for your ever so interesting thoughts. No really, they are illuminating and I’m sure once we’ve fully digested them you can expect a statute erected in your honour.

A rare honour indeed...

 

[missionpossible]

Well played Port.

I am happy to have him back as long as you take Marshall

 

[feenix67]

How many contested marks do you think he should be taking?

You missed the point. The poster pointed to his 9 marks as proof that he was not an aerial liability. I merely pointed out they were 9 uncontested marks, hardly a good indicator.

 

[Sanders]

A rare honour indeed...

Bloody autocorrect

 

[Sanders]

You missed the point. The poster pointed to his 9 marks as proof that he was not an aerial liability. I merely pointed out they were 9 uncontested marks, hardly a good indicator.

So if he had 1 more contested mark?

 

[baldandbroke]

So if he had 1 more contested mark?

Really want to see him spoiling more than taking contested marks!!

Who is the benchmark here? McGovern? I'd guess he takes a couple of contested marks a week and way more spoils ... could be wrong

 

[skam85]

It's McClure, so who knows, but would fit with the recent maniacal authoritarian angle the AFL is taking lately

"It's my understanding" = the voices in his head

 

[LeftyLuke]

They wont suspend him, but he will get a fine. The AFL should acknowledge his frustration though. Especially the kick by Cotchin and the Nank head hit on Cook can be added to the long line of evidence the Tigers get away with a lot.

I dont think they will suspend him but Brad Xi is out of control lately. Why would you employ this failed coach as your operations manager is beyond me. His ridiculous policy of players not putting their hands out is embarrassing. In saying that Walker should have just let it go after we knew they were not going to do anything against their golden child Cotchin. Look what he did against gws in the 2017 prelim. If Walker did the same he would have been given 4 weeks.

 

[pjcrows]

Why would you employ this failed coach as your operations manager is beyond me.

Read The Boys Club by Mick Warner.