Chris Judd was a bit different as he wanted to return to Melbourne for family reasons rather than money.
Saints supporters don't hold a grudge against Cripps for returning to Perth for family reasons, Goddard going to Essendon for more money isn't viewed as favourably although personally I don't begrudge him taking a better offer, I still don't like seeing him playing for another club though.
Your original statement was "from a supporter point of view it sucks seeing your favourite players running around for another team." Chris Judd fit the category of favourite players.