Chadwiko
The Captain!
- Sep 25, 2004
- 25,367
- 41,750
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Washington Commanders, Boston Celtics
No it wasn't. Essendon paid a fortune for McKay. Even with the CBA stuff it still would have been Band 1.
Opinion North Melbourne Priority Picks Part 2 - 2023/2024
- Thread starter Mofra
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Did anyone expect any better from north this year? They have had a brutal run so far this year against sides with tall forwards who expose their biggest weakness.
The lack of KPPs is a major concern though, as they take longer to come on than mids. They basically need to find a way to get some good 21-22 year old KPPs somehow. Otherwise the list will never marry up with their mids.
The lack of KPPs is a major concern though, as they take longer to come on than mids. They basically need to find a way to get some good 21-22 year old KPPs somehow. Otherwise the list will never marry up with their mids.
It only appears that way because the contract is front-ended, which isn't a consideration for compo.
AFL themselves said they neglected to include the CBA increase when doling out compo, due to a 'quirk'..
Chadwiko
The Captain!
- Sep 25, 2004
- 25,367
- 41,750
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Washington Commanders, Boston Celtics
Link me to this?
Probably end of 1st round, from memory 1st round compensation is supposed to be within the top 5% of contracts, pretty much the top 2 players from each club.
Matt Flynn was the first FA and when late second was announced it was very surprising compensation. Subsequent FA's all seemed to be an overcompensated after that.
And your judgements are based on a detailed analysis of the employment packages of each AFL-listed player, yeah?
Here's a link to an article from the Age referencing it. I think the actual quote I'm referring to was from Dillon on Gettable, or something.
Why clubs can cash in on free agency compensation this year
Here are the elements that make up the free agency compensation formula - and why AFL clubs losing top-tier free agents will cash in like never before this year.
So effectively, clubs losing FA's appear to have been over-compensated due to the AFL putting last year's offers under the old CBA, despite those same players getting contracts under the new one.
No, but on face value it appears that the AFL judgements weren't either.
Engimal v3
Premium Gold
Big name that guy. Someone to really build a defense around.
No surprise he's seeing a fair amount of ball, its in Norths back 50 90% of the game.
North Melbourne players living in defence appear to be feasting on cheap disposals that are junk food of little nutritional value.
Engimal v3
Premium Gold
Didn't know I'd riled up the Ben McKay fan club. Marry him if you love him so much
boncer34
Formerly "Dos23"
Sweet F.A. Reigning Premiers - East Side Hawks Season 38 - SFA
Sweet FA 500 Games Played
The Scales Award for Essendon Poster of the Year
Essendon Player Sponsor 2022 - Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti and Archie Perkins
Essendon Player Sponsor 2024 - Archie Perkins and Nic Martin
Veteran
East Side Hawks - Sweet F.A.
Tasmanian Team
Who's he replace? Wardlaw?
Griffin Logue will be back around the bye, I think. He'll take the best defender.
Comben, although new to defence, has shown he can take a shit-ton of intercept marks, and is strong enough to handle the bigger forwards.
That then pushes Corr to a third defender role, which is more of his go rather than being the number 1, which is what he's been forced into.
You then have Kallan Dawson, Bigoa Nyuon and Toby Pink for depth, and Will Dawson as the first-year player developing in the VFL.
We got stung early this season because of the Logue injury and a small injury to Comben, which meant we ran with Corr, Pink and K Dawson for a couple of weeks - but that was never meant to be permanent.
Fast-forward a couple of years and Logue, Comben and W Dawson is a pretty handy set of KPDs, all of whom are already on the list.
Yeah, it is a weird system. The same thing happened when the last agreement came through in 2017 and Steven Motlop surprisingly got Geelong Band 2 compo. At the time of awarding the compo, the AFL don't have future contracts to compare to so they use the current ones (before the CBA increase). Adelaide and St Kilda were lucky that they had free agents leave this year and got overcompensated. By most accounts, McKay's contract was so big that North would have got Band 1 regardless. Though pick 3 for Ben was a massive incentive for the club to ship him off.Here's a link to an article from the Age referencing it. I think the actual quote I'm referring to was from Dillon on Gettable, or something.
Why clubs can cash in on free agency compensation this year
Here are the elements that make up the free agency compensation formula - and why AFL clubs losing top-tier free agents will cash in like never before this year.www.theage.com.au
So effectively, clubs losing FA's appear to have been over-compensated due to the AFL putting last year's offers under the old CBA, despite those same players getting contracts under the new one.
- Oct 5, 2004
- 13,418
- 14,147
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Richmond
Fantasy points are great for dream team, but key defenders are usually employed to stop their opponents. How many scoring shots did Joe have on Combden that day? Was it eight or nine?
Not sure if he got Cameron last week as well?
He’s got a bit of work to do as a stopper.
Comben had 4 1v1s vs Brisbane and lost one of them. He also had 13 intercept possessions and five tackles.
Blaming goals on the key defence is pretty naive, imo.
No, you're right. A guy in his first two AFL games as a defender, playing in one of the worst teams in history, should totally have beaten two guys who have kicked almost a thousand goals between them. My bad.
Comben was surprisingly good down there and looked quite natural.
Personally, thought he'd pair up with Larkey up forward but if he can hold down a KPD spot down back, once Logue returns things suddenly look a hell of a lot better.
Pink or Corr could then potentially play the third tall intercepting role they'd be far better at and McDonald can be booted from the team.
That just leaves another tall forward to pair with Larkey, as CCJ is pretty pox.
hotchilli
Premium Platinum
- Jun 5, 2021
- 9,940
- 21,584
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Houston Rockets, Houston Astros
Doesn't matter who is playing as key defenders right now for us when you turn it over like we do with zero transition defence from our mids.
- Sep 6, 2011
- 13,852
- 22,406
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- GWS (Kayo) Also AFL Member so all clubs
North don't have to worry about tall defenders this week.... Actually they don't even have to worry about medium defenders either...
Well it was very well planned then to trade out the 2024 priority picks provided last year.
Instead of already holding a bevy of picks this year and looking fine for draft selections it leaves the door open for more.
Any more assistance should be in list spaces, salary cap and the ability to prelist any ex AFL players or those who have been overlooked previously at the draft.
North can go and grab the next Ryley Bonner DFA like the Saints did to shore up their leaking defense. Draft picks and 18 year olds wont change anything for another 2 to 3 years. Go and bring in some role playing defensive mids who run both ways.
Problem is North are in a cycle of pushing out experience and throwing top rated kids in too early. Will they even play experienced role players ahead of fast tracking the gun kids?
- Mar 25, 2019
- 14,400
- 29,472
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I haven't been keeping up... Are North fans back to begging for more priority picks from the AFL already?
Club is a basket case from head to toe just like we were a few years back. Our club finally forked out money for better leadership in admin and at board level and we've seen massive improvements since.
More kids for North will just equate to more talented players leaving for greener pastures like McKay last year and Zurhaar likely this season. They'll become a feeder club like Gold Coast has been for years.
Realistically if ur someone like Paul Curtis why on earth would you want to stay there when you're starved of ball forward of centre and frequently watch your team get belted while you're stuck doing SFA in the forward line? If he goes to a decent team he could be a star with his talent.
Anyway I say all power to them. Sonja is rubbish, list team is a disgrace and some of their players are just straight up lazy $$$ chasers. Sooner the fans begin demanding more from the club as a whole the sooner things will turn. Begging for picks wont do shit all.
Club is a basket case from head to toe just like we were a few years back. Our club finally forked out money for better leadership in admin and at board level and we've seen massive improvements since.
More kids for North will just equate to more talented players leaving for greener pastures like McKay last year and Zurhaar likely this season. They'll become a feeder club like Gold Coast has been for years.
Realistically if ur someone like Paul Curtis why on earth would you want to stay there when you're starved of ball forward of centre and frequently watch your team get belted while you're stuck doing SFA in the forward line? If he goes to a decent team he could be a star with his talent.
Anyway I say all power to them. Sonja is rubbish, list team is a disgrace and some of their players are just straight up lazy $$$ chasers. Sooner the fans begin demanding more from the club as a whole the sooner things will turn. Begging for picks wont do shit all.
Similar threads
