- May 29, 2009
- 29,823
- 14,883
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Pies/Swans/Blues 3 way for Fev and Jolley
- Thread starter fogdog
- Start date
- Tagged users None
We dont need Burger.
Fev to Sydney is my tip.
LOL 
When you are you guys going to get it through your heads that Sydney WILL NOT be trading it's pick 6 for Fevola or anybody else for that matter.
We are also highly unlikely to even trade pick 14 if we end up with it, unless it was for a proven ruckman but there aint one on the market besides Jolly who is leaving us.
We have a developing full forward in White, a dual Brownlow Medalist in Goodes who will play forward from now on and our first pick last year in the draft was for a key foward in Johnston from SA. Not to mention our chronic need for a couple of young midfielders in this years draft.
Nothing, I tell you nothing points to us wanting or needing Fev for a first round draft pick.
DST
When you are you guys going to get it through your heads that Sydney WILL NOT be trading it's pick 6 for Fevola or anybody else for that matter.
We are also highly unlikely to even trade pick 14 if we end up with it, unless it was for a proven ruckman but there aint one on the market besides Jolly who is leaving us.
We have a developing full forward in White, a dual Brownlow Medalist in Goodes who will play forward from now on and our first pick last year in the draft was for a key foward in Johnston from SA. Not to mention our chronic need for a couple of young midfielders in this years draft.
Nothing, I tell you nothing points to us wanting or needing Fev for a first round draft pick.
DST
- Banned
- #80
What do you want on that?
Do you have any proof?
You do realise, we're getting screwed in that deal, right?
Sydney's into Mumford as well that could make things even more interesting.
- Banned
- #82
Fevola will go where he's sent.
He has no power after what he reportedly did at the Brownlow.
The Heatley Stand from here and a Carlton forum has been posting the same thing.
Swann will tell Fevola where he can go.
Fev needs to get out of Melbourne and away from his so called mates who work in the media.
Swans fans won't care if he's kicking goals.
Fevola has another five years left if he stays fit.
We might have to trade pick 27 to Sydney to get that deal across the line.
I don't doubt that this might have been trade put forward, but it's too generous to be true.
This would have taken up five minutes of their time to come up with it.
And another five minutes for it be to scrapped by the Swans.
From a purely football perspective at 29 Fevola is too old for the Swans if they are serious about rebuilding. He won't be around when they next challenge for a flag. They should hold on to the current first rounder and the one they will most likely get for Jolly and use it and continue the process of adding exciting young talent to the list.
And thats without considering his off field issues. Its the off field issues where the only real justification for the Swans to recruit Fevola fall down - marketing - falls down. Make no mistake. Anti AFL Pro Rugby League journalists in Sydney would like nothing more than for Fevola to be recruited by the Swans then have one of his infamous alcohol fueled melt downs. They are furious that RL has got a bad reputation from players' off field incidents and that the AFL has a better reputation. They would be sitting in wait and history tells us that Fevola would eventually oblige.
The Swannies should not be the easy answer for the Navy Blue with White CFC monogrammed problem that is Brendan Fevola. Reports of what went down on Brownlow Night tell us how difficult a problem he is for the Blues to resolve. At 29, with a huge contract to fulfill and his boorish and beyond Browlow indiscretions known to all other clubs his trade value should be minimal.
And thats without considering his off field issues. Its the off field issues where the only real justification for the Swans to recruit Fevola fall down - marketing - falls down. Make no mistake. Anti AFL Pro Rugby League journalists in Sydney would like nothing more than for Fevola to be recruited by the Swans then have one of his infamous alcohol fueled melt downs. They are furious that RL has got a bad reputation from players' off field incidents and that the AFL has a better reputation. They would be sitting in wait and history tells us that Fevola would eventually oblige.
The Swannies should not be the easy answer for the Navy Blue with White CFC monogrammed problem that is Brendan Fevola. Reports of what went down on Brownlow Night tell us how difficult a problem he is for the Blues to resolve. At 29, with a huge contract to fulfill and his boorish and beyond Browlow indiscretions known to all other clubs his trade value should be minimal.
TomBolt
Rookie
Swans
Gain: Fevola pick 27, pick 46
Lose: pick 6, Jolley
Collingwood
Gain: Jolley
Lose: pick 14, pick 46
Carlton
Gain: Pick 6, pick 14
Lose: Fevola, pick 27
That balances it up a bit.
Will Fev go to Sydney? I reckon he'll be happy with anyone who is kind enough to want him.
Will Roosy give up pick 6? Roosy might be thinking, hey, I'm replacing Hall with someone younger & better (Fev), plus now I have 2 draft picks not one. Remember its Roosy's last season & Fev will take him further than any draftee. Also, didn't Roosy say Sydney can't afford to bottom out, as they'll lose a lot of their fan base.
kensington
Debutant
From Adam(?) White 927 twitter:
TRADE WEEK: Brendan Fevola could head to Sydney as part of three-club deal which will see Darren Jolly to Collingwood
Don't if he is sure. The fact he says 'could' leads me to believe he just read BF.
TRADE WEEK: Brendan Fevola could head to Sydney as part of three-club deal which will see Darren Jolly to Collingwood
Don't if he is sure. The fact he says 'could' leads me to believe he just read BF.
Sydney also can't afford Fev to stuff up again neither with the West Sydney team coming in.Time will tell though.
I think this post might be off the mark. For all the high moral stance the AFL are taking over off-field issues, and while I admire the way Sydney has handled the Hall scenario, some of the money people in the AFL and the Swans will have noticed that Rugby League in Sydney is growing despite - or perhaps because of? - the off-field disgraces. With Hall going and West Sydney coming in perhaps Fev is just what they think they need. Disgrace though he is, he probably won't cost them fines and suspensions - only off-field noteriety.
PooMonkey
Tie dye biatch!!!
- Sep 23, 2009
- 3,409
- 519
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Manchester Utd, SF 49ers, Rovers.
Funny how the clubs aren't at Etihad today and won't be again until Friday
HBF
Flying Scotsman
- Sep 24, 2002
- 156,232
- 101,343
- AFL Club
- Carlton
PooMonkey
Tie dye biatch!!!
- Sep 23, 2009
- 3,409
- 519
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Manchester Utd, SF 49ers, Rovers.
PooMonkey
Tie dye biatch!!!
- Sep 23, 2009
- 3,409
- 519
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Manchester Utd, SF 49ers, Rovers.
- Sep 25, 2006
- 18,365
- 14,636
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- FC Barcelona, Liverpool, FC Bayern
So we pay a first + 3rd round selection for a 28 yr old ruckman and also facilitate a trade for Fev to Sydney?
I don't think that's going to happen.
We would be expecting a little more comp from either end IMO.
Also, Sydney would be getting creamed.
They would not be putting 6 and 14 on the table.
If they did, it would be a stupid move.
I don't think that's going to happen.
We would be expecting a little more comp from either end IMO.
Also, Sydney would be getting creamed.
They would not be putting 6 and 14 on the table.
If they did, it would be a stupid move.
- Banned
- #95
Alex would be elated Brendon is moving closer to Lara.
PooMonkey
Tie dye biatch!!!
- Sep 23, 2009
- 3,409
- 519
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Manchester Utd, SF 49ers, Rovers.
Syd have already said to Coll that 14 was not enough for Jolly.
you will also find you will get pick 7 from WCE for Davis
Can't say the same about your education.
Since when do marketing departments decide on trades?
I will spell this out for all of you again slowely.
SYDNEY WILL NOT BE TRADING OUR FIRST PICK IN THE 2009 NATIONAL DRAFT TO ANYONE, LEAST OF ALL CARLTON FOR FEV!
The make-up of our current list and what we need draft day means we are not in a position to do this deal.
If Carlton are serious and desperate and will accept a late 2nd rounder or third rounder for Fev with the Swans paying his enrire salary then the deal might get done, but that is about as likely as me seeing snow in Mt Buller in February!
DST
I will spell this out for all of you again slowely.
SYDNEY WILL NOT BE TRADING OUR FIRST PICK IN THE 2009 NATIONAL DRAFT TO ANYONE, LEAST OF ALL CARLTON FOR FEV!
The make-up of our current list and what we need draft day means we are not in a position to do this deal.
If Carlton are serious and desperate and will accept a late 2nd rounder or third rounder for Fev with the Swans paying his enrire salary then the deal might get done, but that is about as likely as me seeing snow in Mt Buller in February!
DST
The Exorcist
Club Legend
So would Mich Clarke
Must say if it got down to fister cuffs Fev would hold it over Mich, but at least Mich can hold his alcohol
