Richmond’s next senior coach

Who do you want to be the next senior coach

  • Andrew McQualter

    Votes: 87 37.8%
  • Adem Yze

    Votes: 146 63.5%

  • Total voters
    230

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m going to be honest and say that Adem Yze has a pretty good coaching career as an assistant. All from his Wikipedia article, but:

  • He was Hawthorn’s specialist goalkicking and development coach from January 2012 to November 2014. Hawthorn were elite kicks during this time and he’s credited as one of the reasons for that.
  • From November 2014, he was Hawthorn’s backline coach. Hawthorn then conceded the least amount of points in the following season (2015). They went on to be top 3 in least points conceded in 2018 and 2019 as well. However, they were only ordinary defensively in 2016, 2017, and 2020.
  • He joined Melbourne 2021 as a midfield coach. Melbourne went from having an ineffective and dysfunctional midfield to being one of the best and most organised midfield teams in the competition.

Not only does he have forward line, backline, and midfield experience as a coach - he’s also had success in each of those assistant coaching roles.

I’m not against others, but Yze’s assistant coaching career is quite decorated. Maybe he’d be a good fit for us. Also, maybe he can tell us how we can finally beat Melbourne.
Yes, impressive wonder why he has has been knocked back so many times though is he not a good speaker? man manager when being interviewed? I have no doubt he would tactically sound, but you need be a good manager of people as senior coach these days.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

Yes, impressive wonder why he has has been knocked back so many times though is he not a good speaker man manager when being interviewed? I have no doubt he would tactically sound, but you need be a good manager of people as senior coach these days.
Yeah, a coach can be a good tactician all they want, but if they don’t know how to manage or talk to players then they’re not a good fit. Haven’t heard much about Yze on that front, so I’m not sure
 
Luke Hodge. (if he is interested)

Captain of 3 premiership sides. Played in 4. Coached on the field in the latter part of his career at Hawthorn and then at Brisbane. Media savvy. Unbelievable understanding of the game (as can be seen by his insightful comments). Barracked for Richmond as a kid. Success follows him (like Dimma). Would command the respect of any playing group (very important during lean times).
 
In the last 20 seasons a list of AFL flag winning coaches that had previous senior coaching experience:

2004 Matthews - Yes (Collingwood 1990)
2005 Roos - No
2006 Worsfold - No
2007 Thompson - No
2008 Clarkson - No
2009 Thompson - No
2010 Malthouse - Yes (West Coast 1992 & 1994)
2011 Scott - No
2012 Longmire - No
2013 Clarkson - No
2014 Clarkson - No
2015 Clarkson - No
2016 Beveridge - No
2017 Hardwick - No
2018 Simpson - No
2019 Hardwick - No
2020 Hardwick - No
2021 Goodwin - No
2022 Scott - No
2023 - ?

Leppitsch, Rutten, Teague, Pyke, Buckley, Knights, Alan Richardson, Bolton & Mark Williams can all get in the bin.
What about ....
images (4).jpeg
 
I don’t get why people want Leppitsch and not Buckley ? Buckley got scumwood 45 secs away from a flag and Leppitsch did nothing in fact horrendous record
I don't think Buckley wants to coach again the only reason he coached imo was his love for the Pies. he loves the media & seems a natural in that space always a great speaker.
 
I wonder how Bachar Houli would go at coaching.
‘Reckon he would be decent and worth investing in for the future.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Bucks is an astute commentator and analyst.
Remember he said in the pre-season that Carlton would miss the finals.
Many commentators were too gutless to criticise Carlton at the time, because traditionally they have a relatively large following.
 
A
I don't think Buckley wants to coach again the only reason he coached imo was his love for the Pies. he loves the media & seems a natural in that space always a great speaker.
Ask Sarri, Conte, and Tuchel who were sacked after trophy success within months if not weeks the meaning of failure. Buckley never won anything in 10 years, why on earth would he be considered as coach material now?
 
I’m going to be honest and say that Adem Yze has a pretty good coaching career as an assistant. All from his Wikipedia article, but:

  • He was Hawthorn’s specialist goalkicking and development coach from January 2012 to November 2014. Hawthorn were elite kicks during this time and he’s credited as one of the reasons for that.
  • From November 2014, he was Hawthorn’s backline coach. Hawthorn then conceded the least amount of points in the following season (2015). They went on to be top 3 in least points conceded in 2018 and 2019 as well. However, they were only ordinary defensively in 2016, 2017, and 2020.
  • He joined Melbourne 2021 as a midfield coach. Melbourne went from having an ineffective and dysfunctional midfield to being one of the best and most organised midfield teams in the competition.

Not only does he have forward line, backline, and midfield experience as a coach - he’s also had success in each of those assistant coaching roles.

I’m not against others, but Yze’s assistant coaching career is quite decorated. Maybe he’d be a good fit for us. Also, maybe he can tell us how we can finally beat Melbourne.
-ve is he comes from a strong Clarkson background , which may well see him too similar to Dimma.
 
I think Hinkley. Port treat him woefully. Keep dangling his job but reality is he is an excellent coach of a small club. Surely the prospect of stability, a president that does not shoot their mouth off, the resources and profile of Richmond would be irresistible. Otherwise maybe Grigg. Typically don’t like the idea of a “favourite son” returning but all reports are he is a smart, motivated guy.

Grigg?? Come on mate


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Jump on Bigfooty to see the general consensus on the new coach.... Jesus Christ this thread is a cluster*.

Some of these suggestions are deadset ludicrous.

you gonna give your own suggestion or just complain without adding to the conversation
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top