Preview Rnd 10 Carlton v Adelaide Sunday May 25 4.40 pm @ MCG - Team post *686

[Just Kreuzing]

Last I heard white has no case to answer but it is on going.

Carrazzo for Mitch could be a straight swap. Weather could make the choice on who is out for Waite.

I wouldn't let the weather choose for us HD, they never get it right...

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

So when you are at a game you done ever boo an opposition player that is about to take a shot at goal?

No.

 

[happydude]

If he is back it would have to be for Ellard, but can we have both Ellard and Garlett out of the side ??

Do we have enough small forwards to play that role if both are out, Is Menzel & Yarran enough ??

Yarran is mainly back I wouldn't calculate him in any small forward talk don't want to rob our back lines run.

We could let one of Garlett or Ellard slip but not both.

 

[GROTTO]

Just imagine the crowds that this bloke will attract.

How long will Judd last? I saw an interview where he said he punished his body at the Eagles which basically has led to him not being in the peak of his health now.

In an ideal world he looks to me the kind of guy that could have easily played into his 30s comfortably. I personally dont see a player like Danger for example lasting long in his 30s as well.

 

[happydude]

Booing for me is circumstantial.

I'll make noise etc when an opposition player is having a shot even when they run out. Creates atmosphere and if it's an interstate club makes them feel unwelcome creates more of a home advantage that way.


I don't boo ex Carlton players that don't deserve it or champions of the game just coz.

Like cheering is and expression so is Booing. Better than abusing players etc.

 

[HARKER]

Booing for me is circumstantial.

I'll make noise etc when an opposition player is having a shot even when they run out. Creates atmosphere and if it's an interstate club makes them feel unwelcome creates more of a home advantage that way.


I don't boo ex Carlton players that don't deserve it or champions of the game just coz.

Like cheering is and expression so is Booing. Better than abusing players etc.

I'll have to try it then............maybe not.

Have you seen what people look like when they boo? Something like a constipated giraffe.......................fugly stuff.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Yarran is mainly back I wouldn't calculate him in any small forward talk don't want to rob our back lines run.

We could let one of Garlett or Ellard slip but not both.

I agree that either 1 of Garlett and Ellard have to play, will be interesting, might see Daisy playing small forward again or maybe Carrazzo doesn't get back ??

2 things I dont want to see is Armfield dropped, think he has a role this week and Menzel as the bloody sub !!

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

Booing for me is circumstantial.

I'll make noise etc when an opposition player is having a shot even when they run out. Creates atmosphere and if it's an interstate club makes them feel unwelcome creates more of a home advantage that way.


I don't boo ex Carlton players that don't deserve it or champions of the game just coz.

Like cheering is and expression so is Booing. Better than abusing players etc.

Each to their own. I just find it a bit tacky.

 

[HARKER]

Really hope that the CFC and Garlett himself have the confidence in him getting back to business as usual.

Somewhat concerned that he may be selected tomorrow but dropped for the final 22.

 

[happydude]

I'll have to try it then............maybe not.

Have you seen what people look like when they boo? Something like a constipated giraffe.......................fugly stuff.

It's not for everyone but I see no issue is the instances I posted above, also after a poor umpiring decision.

Wellingham's hit on Simpson

West Coast booing jobe was the right thing to do as well. It wasn't just him it was the whole fiasco, he put his face on it and copped the displeasure from footy fans.

Can create atmosphere but when used in appropriately can be horrible. Example: injured player

 

[jimsta10]

I'll have to try it then............maybe not.

Have you seen what people look like when they boo? Something like a constipated giraffe.......................fugly stuff.

I thought booing is part of footy? All in good spirits you would think. My wife reckons l look and sound like an absolute idiot...who cares.

 

[JamisonRun40]

My partner is a mad Carlton fan. Win or lose, I am screwed this weekend!

If Carlton win you might get lucky, just sayin.... If they lose you might be doing the dishes...

 

[happydude]

I thought booing is part of footy? All in good spirits you would think. My wife reckons l look and sound like an absolute idiot...who cares.

This. Plus I don't go to the footy to look top notch in a tux.

 

[jimsta10]

My partner is a mad Carlton fan. Win or lose, I am screwed this weekend!

Either way you WIN

 

[Tony Lynn 15]

Maybe it's just me, but I don't get how booing is fun.

Apparently it releases a certain type of endorphin that just can't help but make you feel happy MEB.

 

[thylacine60]

So when you are at a game you done ever boo an opposition player that is about to take a shot at goal?

That's hilarious. What on earth for, to make him miss? What are you, 8?

 

[etsal1]

So the CFC are announcing that Judd may just come back through the VFL.

Good thinking..

Seems we might have finally learnt something

 

[Tony Lynn 15]

That's hilarious. What on earth for, to make him miss? What are you, 8?

I always draw the line at chewy on your boot!

 

[Just Kreuzing]

I used to cop, "your mother wears pink army socks", never put me off....

 

[HBF]

I agree that either 1 of Garlett and Ellard have to play, will be interesting, might see Daisy playing small forward again or maybe Carrazzo doesn't get back ??

2 things I dont want to see is Armfield dropped, think he has a role this week and Menzel as the bloody sub !!

Based on current form and output it has to be Ellard.
Jeffy just isn't the player he was from a couple of years ago.

 

[NavyBlue5]

So the CFC are announcing that Judd may just come back through the VFL.

Good thinking..

Imagine the media circus if that were to happen.

Link?

Really hope that the CFC and Garlett himself have the confidence in him getting back to business as usual.

Somewhat concerned that he may be selected tomorrow but dropped for the final 22.

Garlett is really worrying me. Doesn't look like he wants to be out there at all.

 

[Tony Lynn 15]

I used to cop, "your mother wears pink army socks", never put me off....

I always disliked the 'your mother loves french toast for breakfast'!

 

[thylacine60]

Well she does...

 

[happydude]

I tried the old 'you're adopted and your mum doesn't love you'


Never accidentally got and adopted kid though

 

[HBF]

Well she does...

Not cool dude.......not cool.