Autopsy Roast and toast vs Brisbane and changes Port Adelaide

Best vs Lions


  • Total voters
    244

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yep, agree with all points here.
Ginni is getting jack now in relation to frees & I'm good with that.
It was obvious this would happen & our club and Jack have to take a large portion of ownership and blame here.
Ginni openly admitted that as a kid he copied his AFL idols and practiced this so called "skill" (read Blight) whilst the likes of Duckwood continues to get away with it over a 350 game career with seemingly no blame apportioned.
The AFL are also to blame as they should have eradicated this disease a decade or more ago, starting by initiating a rule change at under 16's and 18's level first as they have done with other rule changes in the past.
Buckley & McCrae are also to blame & should have intervened & coached this tactic out of him with an emphasis on going hard at the ball instead of encouraging it's continuation.
The kid only needs to look at the likes of Baker as a role model who I openly have a man crush on. He's tough, fair, goes super hard at the ball, works his arse off and never plays for free kicks. He never complains on field & every possie is earnt and as such he rightly has universal respect.
Hey KJpie

With the Pies being linked to so many players during the upcoming trade period, who are the supporters most keen to acquire ?
What order would the pies rank the following in terms of priority ?

McStay
Taranto
Hopper
Hill
Bruhn
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Caesar training report:

Main training today:
Thought I saw Lynch earlier? but nowhere to be seen now and Miller played forward that drill and Balta back.
Bake's started off in rehab then joined the main group but didn't do too much.
Dusty doing a bit more but at no increased intensity which has been his issue that he can't push beyond 50%.
Junior trained all session in what I would call the A team bib.
Samson Ryan back with main after his concussion.
 
wow just saw the main board gameday thread

never seen so many scats fans in one place first sticking the boots in and then melting after we came back

rent free and desperate to have a rivalry with us
 
Grimes Surgery could be it’s all over red rover

Might be an unpopular opinion but his form since he got injured in the St Kilda game has been poor. This could be an opportunity for Balta to step up down back where he plays so much better and then when Grimes comes back deep in finals, he’ll be the icing.
 
Grimes Surgery could be it’s all over red rover
Don't shoot me down but this is a good thing for us.

Balta and Baker have to stay back now (where they are much better used), and maybe Short too.

Dyl is 31 so every chance we'll need to replace him more and more as time goes on, especially if his dodgy hammies are back.

And means we get games into Miller, even if he plays forward/ruck.

Vlastuin Balta Broad
Rioli Tarrant Baker

That's hot.
 
Might be an unpopular opinion but his form since he got injured in the St Kilda game has been poor. This could be an opportunity for Balta to step up down back where he plays so much better and then when Grimes comes back deep in finals, he’ll be the icing.
if we go deep in finals now they wont bring him back . it would mean we are playing well enough without him and bringing back an injured player will upset the synergy

another rance scenario if we make it
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

wow just saw the main board gameday thread

never seen so many scats fans in one place first sticking the boots in and then melting after we came back

rent free and desperate to have a rivalry with us
And then spend pages and pages of bandwidth on other threads trying to convince themselves this isn't them...

fbd8f819-12d3-401e-84c5-d140cbe08d3a-jpeg.1463349
 
Hey KJpie

With the Pies being linked to so many players during the upcoming trade period, who are the supporters most keen to acquire ?
What order would the pies rank the following in terms of priority ?

McStay
Taranto
Hopper
Hill
Bruhn
Sorry Mate, got caught up.
I believe we are committed to Mcstay, so he goes 1, with Roughead gone we believe he will turn into the stay with Defender we desperately need. Moore is run off type who was destroyed by Lynch early in the year.

Taranto @ 2 next as a mid/ forward as we took the reported 4 - 5 year deal off the table for DeGoey. DeGoey can't possibly stay with the 2 year deal on offer and I'm good with that. Him going to Geesook for no compo would cut deep and only provide me with another reason to dislike them. Saints would be preferable.
If we get Taranto (GWS need cap space) then Hopper is not a need or would be to costly.

Bruhn is young, but the games of his I've seen I haven't rated and we need mids with size and height. Tom Green would be nice :)
In fact we need key position players at both ends, must be a focus for us at the draft also.

Hill, didn't like his attitude and BS in trying to get to the Bumbers last year. He tried to hold GWS to ransom who in the end stood firm and made him honour his contract. Has pace & skill, but soft for mine and pea hearted. Believe he is a possibility, I would pass though.
I Would back in the multitude of small HF's we already have on the list.

In summary 1 McStay, 2 Taranto, 3 maybe a ready made ruckman if Grundy goes (hope not) and then hit the draft for talls & genuine mids.
Can't see how we force Grundy out and we may have to trade for McStay with the Brions as they need points for academy/ possible Father Son. That said the Brions will rightfully prefer a compo pick.
The quandy is we won't want to lose a first round compo pick for Degoney by bringing in other free agent/s, although it seems inevitable.
 
Last edited:
Sorry Mate, got caught up.
I believe we are committed to Mcstay, so he goes 1, with Roughead gone we believe he will turn into the stay with Defender we desperately need. Moore is run off type who was destroyed by Lynch early in the year.

Tarranto @ 2 next as a mid/ forward as we took the reported 4 - 5 year deal off the table for DeGoey. DeGoey can't possibly stay with the 2 year deal on offer and I'm good with that. Him going to Geesook for nothing would cut deep and only provide me with another reason to dislike Geesook. Saints would be my preference.
If we get Taranto (GWS need cap space) then Hopper is not a need or would be to costly.

Bruhn is young, but the games of his I've seen I havent rated and we need mids with size and height. Tom Green would be nice :)
In fact we need key position players at both ends, must be a focus for us at the draft also.
Hill, didnt like his attitude and BS in trying to get to the Bumbers last year. He tried to hold GWS to ransom who in the end stood firm and made him honour his contract. Has pace & skill, but soft for mine and pea hearted.
Would back in the multitude of small HF's we already have on the list.
In summary 1 McStay, 2 Tarranto, maybe a ruckman if Grundy goes (hope not) and then hit the draft for talls.
Can't see how we force Grundy out and we may have to trade an early third rounder (we have 3 thirds) for McStay to the Brions as they need points for academy/ possible Father Son.
Plus we won't want to lose a first round compo pick for Degoney by bringing in other free agent/s.
Cheers 4 the comprehensive feedback !!!
 
Yes but if your defense is set up right it flows through. We demolished them in the second half all because of 2 changes down back and that was even after we lost grimes.

I just meant in general this season. Blues, Geelong, saints and Sydney games we collapsed in the midfield and got rolled over.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
wow just saw the main board gameday thread

never seen so many scats fans in one place first sticking the boots in and then melting after we came back

rent free and desperate to have a rivalry with us

They are literally the worst fans, even my Cats mate witnessed it the other week and admitted they are very nuff heavy. I was on a boys trip and forced to go to the flop meth cheats v paper bag worlds longest rebuild cheats match the other week and on the way in find out we'd lost to Norf. Anyway, sitting surrounded by methies and my dickhead Cats mate decides to tell them I'm a Tigers fan and they all start laying into me with the jokes..... fair enough I think but I better throw a barb back so I said 'the only sure thing as a Tigers fan is a final win against your mob' and the fun banter quickly turned from fun, they are easily the worst fans to interact with. Has made it enjoyable at the finals I've been to when we won however.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top