Round 12 Trades

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Wallis, Lynch or wait a week for JJK?

Lynch

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Is Sandi out ?

Yes.
Plus next week is his bye.

 

[banana&2kiwis]

Could Marchbank do well against GWS ?

 

[LukasTheGreat]

Mccarthy > Cousins
Taranto > Kreuzer.

 

[keithrichards]

Any ideas on Luke Ryan JS?

My guess is rubbish...?

 

[pincrusher]

Could Marchbank do well against GWS ?

If he takes a lot of marks, has lots of possessions and disposes of the ball effectively, yes.

 

[mattdb]

Thoughts? Have got 90k and thinking Sandi might need to go but not sure about anything else.

 

[Papa Caz]

I saw him, but he's on thee extended bench isn't he?

If not, would you recommend him?

named on ground mate and i have only heard good things about him but beech might be a good choice also, only thing with beech is he is playing for Adelaide and Adelaide are trying to push for finals so may get dropped but its worth the risk.

never actually heard of cox to be honest so have no opinion on him

 

[Danog]

Pickett > Cousins
EVW > Hibberd

Taranto, WHE, and Myers to go next week.

 

[Walshy_The_Goat]

Myers > Cousins
Otten > Hibberd

DEF now complete, along with the MIDs, whilst RUC and FWD one upgrade off.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Chopped and changed trade plans, due to impact on Rnd13 .....but finally decided to look at the bigger picture, rather than one week

Stewart to Scharenberg
Myers to Cousins
SPP to Rocky ......that completes my Mids

However, in a moment of stupidity, i'm considering for next week (which will complete my defense)

Fyfe to S.Selwood (projected for another $50K increase & averaging same as Fyfe)
Scharenberg to Lloyd ........yes you've read correctly, a one week rookie

Drastic times call for drastic decisions

Mate I love the Fyfe > S.Selwood option for next week.

Might even do it myself!

 

[Goats]

Is Sandi out ?

He ain't in.

 

[qarocks]

If only Buddy would kick straight tonight, could hit 150

 

[WaynesWorld19]

If only Buddy would kick straight tonight, could hit 150

Boy can't mark ......Boy can't kick ......but he goes ok

 

[Embleberry]

I saw him, but he's on thee extended bench isn't he?

If not, would you recommend him?

Bucks told him at training that he'd be debuting against Melbourne

 

[toxic]

Mate I love the Fyfe > S.Selwood option for next week.

Might even do it myself!

Prestia

 

[Longbombswans]

Anybody else bringing Rocky in? Seem to recall him returning from injury last year and scoring a cool 200

 

[Judd_Magic]

Anybody else bringing Rocky in? Seem to recall him returning from injury last year and scoring a cool 200

I wanted to but played it safe by getting JPK in the end.

Might get Rocky in closer to finals if he hasn't re-injured himself by then.

Just the shoulder has me a bit worried for the short term.

I would have hated to trade him in this week only for his shoulder to get injured again.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Prestia

What's your reasoning behind Prestia mate?

Looked at his scores and only one 100 in the last 8 games.

 

[Jcpdragonx]

I wanted to but played it safe by getting JPK in the end.

Might get Rocky in closer to finals if he hasn't re-injured himself by then.

Just the shoulder has me a bit worried for the short term.

I would have hated to trade him in this week only for his shoulder to get injured again.

I'm not sold on Rocky, I'd see how his shoulder is because it should affect his tackling.

 

[toxic]

What's your reasoning behind Prestia mate?

Looked at his scores and only one 100 in the last 8 games.

Purely food for thought.

Crazy low price v capability

 

[Red Syrah]

His average is only 80 and 5 round ave is 76 - do you think he is going to dramatically improve?

Prestia

 

[toxic]

His average is only 80 and 5 round ave is 76 - do you think he is going to dramatically improve?

I think he's worth looking at if cash strapped

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Anybody else bringing Rocky in? Seem to recall him returning from injury last year and scoring a cool 200

Puts hand up ......desperate times call for desperate action .....also have the (C) on his on a sun drench Gabba green

Now if he injures himself in the first qtr .....please don't speak to me

 

[Longbombswans]

Puts hand up ......desperate times call for desperate action .....also have the (C) on his on a sun drench Gabba green

Now if he injures himself in the first qtr .....please don't speak to me

I think he is definitely worth the risk
He has a massive ceiling especially in a team which completely relies on him, Zorko and Beams to be somewhat competitive