Game Day Round 17 vs. Essendon, MCG, 7:40pm Friday 05/07

[Apex36]

I'm not sure we need to replace him with an "elite" key defender in order to get a net positive out of the switch. He'd also be a more than handy chop out ruckman you'd think.
I would back him to bounce back next year as a key defender and be much better than this year. But even so I think he could be more valuable to the team as a forward ruck.
Battle is better than most people think.

Battle is fine, but he can’t replace Moore. You’re losing a good 10cm height in defence doing that. He’d be the ideal Howe replacement as a 3rd tall intercept defender.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Read the Bombers thread if you want/need some optimism for Friday nights game.

 

[danielnajdek]

Their forward line worries me. Especially Wright.

 

[Bianconeri]

Yeah Moore will never be a midfielder. But I've seen enough this year to know we need to seriously consider moving him out of defence and using him in a different role. He should be a weapon for us, not a weakness!!!

If we can get a reliable key defender like Battle in the off season and Eyre and Dean come on; then we could use Moore as a replacement for Cox as a forward/ruck.
It would be a neat solution to the issues we are seeing with both Moore as a defender and Cox as a forward. I'd back Moore to be way more impactful as a forward than Cox and way more impactful than any of our other options as a second ruck.

Moore would be up there with the best fwd/rucks of the comp. But I don’t see the switch ever happening.

 

[Horaceg]

Moore would be up there with the best fwd/rucks of the comp. But I don’t see the switch ever happening.

We had one of those Moore things you speak of, has a couple of Brownlow medals also. More of a ruck/fwd but same, same

 

[Jen2310]

 

[jmac70]

Their forward line worries me. Especially Wright.

I think our back six will respond strongly on Friday night after the roasting they have received.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

 

[TW Sherrin]

Long will be a chance to play

 

[domus]

I like Teakle and think we should have signed him over Bytel. But he won a total of 4 hit outs that game.

You’re massively overrating his impact that game and are massively overstating Kreuger’s inability to ruck.

He was terrible in the Gold Coast game too. So you rate him as a back up, ruckman?

 

[Bianconeri]

He was terrible in the Gold Coast game too. So you rate him as a back up, ruckman?

He won 9 hit outs, more than Gold Coast’s second rucks combined.

I prefer Cox but I don’t see the point of whining about Kreuger’s ruckwork every week the former is injured and the latter is on par with most key forwards when they go to the ruck.

 

[danielnajdek]

Yay back to getting injuries and no one coming back in.

 

[Jen2310]

Yay back to getting injuries and no one coming back in.

Schultz should be back, surely.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Yay back to getting injuries and no one coming back in.

Shoota & Dean can come straight back in.

 

[Jen2310]

Shoota & Dean can come straight back in.

Unless you push WHE back and Reef forward
Dean not exactly a like for like for noble and WHE has more run.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Unless you push WHE back and Reef forward
Dean not exactly a like for like for noble and WHE has more run.

I'm not saying he's a like for anyone. Just responding to the poster who said we had no one to come back in. Dean was carry over emergency for Saturday, so had IQ not got up, Dean would have come in. And in hindsight, that may have been a good thing..

 

[danielnajdek]

Shoota & Dean can come straight back in.

Dean wasn't injured though.

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Interesting article from CD regarding our defence, just 19 days ago...

Why Champion Data analyst considers Collingwood as the second-best team in the competition

“It's perfectly placed at the moment to actually launch.”

www.sen.com.au

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

Dean wasn't injured though.

I know he's not. Even better, hey? And he can come straight back in.

 

[danielnajdek]

I know he's not. Even better, hey? And he can come straight back in.

But you brought up someone who wasn't out due to injury. I said we have no one coming back from injury which is true. Lachie was sick.

 

[anshell]

No mention of Maynard there,which is good news.And Ralph says no stars coming back.Doesn’t he consider Schultz to be a star?

 

[Jen2310]

No mention of Maynard there,which is good news.And Ralph says no stars coming back.Doesn’t he consider Schultz to be a star?

I dont think anyone would lol
But maybe he just means from injury? Schultz was just illness

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

But you brought up someone who wasn't out due to injury. I said we have no one coming back from injury which is true. Lachie was sick.

You actually didn't mention coming back from injury in your post. Hence why I brought up Shoota.

The cupboard isn't bare. We have available players to replace Beau & JFN. But if you prefer going down the doom & gloom road, you're welcome to it

 

[ElliottsMaggies]

No mention of Maynard there,which is good news.And Ralph says no stars coming back.Doesn’t he consider Schultz to be a star?

Yeah, bit rude ignoring Shoota. I'd say he was sorely missed on Saturday.

 

[cfc19902010]

Schultz in for Mcreery
Reef in for noble


WHE goes back to half back as running link to replace JFN
Reef in as third tall