Only 6 changes? Do better.Something different.
FB: Ryan Hamling Logue
HB: Walker Pearce Aish
C: Clark Young Chapman
HF: Frederick Cox Erasmus
FF: Lobb Treacy Switkowski
R: Darcy Brayshaw Tucker
I: Serong Fyfe Mundy Schultz
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Only 6 changes? Do better.Something different.
FB: Ryan Hamling Logue
HB: Walker Pearce Aish
C: Clark Young Chapman
HF: Frederick Cox Erasmus
FF: Lobb Treacy Switkowski
R: Darcy Brayshaw Tucker
I: Serong Fyfe Mundy Schultz
Chapman just played on a 6 goal small forward. I liked the post where Rachelle's goals were looked at, and I don't hold Chapman responsible, but I'm also not convinced he is the best option.
Unfortunately it almost cost us the game, and then miraculously won it for us. 4 very handy points in the bank.Yeh I noticed that, pretty sure Rachelles match up was Chapman.
Lockdown on small forwards typically has been Logue.
Some lessons for Chappo , but assume his first job was rebound, rather than lock down, with rebound where appropriate.
Back line is a work in process as is the Mid as is the FWD component of the team
Still a bit of work to do from my view!
Wow I thought he was a lot taller than that.192 cm in the SANFL, 193cm on Footywire and 194cm on St Kildas AFL profile.
"Clark said he preferred to play across half-back but was also open to a wing role and Fremantle have identified a need for speed in both positions."Clark has said he wants to play back not on the wing. Leave him there. Young, Chapman or to a lesser extent walker need to develop into the wing role.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Our goal is long term success which requires us to develop playeds accordingly. I don't see us being a flag threat until all three of our draftees are best 22. I'm all for cutting deadweight.The end result of what you are saying is that we are in development mode not contention mode. That would be a major disappointment.
It should immediately end Walters career too as he has been carried for quite a while and we should be developing other options.
Henry played wing towards the end of last season. Aish has shown he is a better option right now. Colyer too. Blakeley even. Crowden. O'Driscoll.
The only justification for playing Meek is if Darcy is not available. It significantly reduces our chances of winning.
Yeah. More of a concept team than my actual thoughts.Only 6 changes? Do better.
To be fair, he didn’t say Johnson was likely to pass his fitness test.Fremantle vs. St Kilda, Optus Stadium, 6:20pm (AEST)
Team news: The Dockers should welcome back skipper Nat Fyfe. The 2015 Brownlow Medal winner missed Round 1 with a shoulder injury. The club has earmarked Round 3 for Matt Taberner's (hamstring) first game. Both Nathan Wilson (shoulder) and Matthew Johnson (foot) will undergo fitness tests. For the Saints, Paddy Ryder, Jack Billings, Jarryn Geary and Dan Hannebery are all set to undergo fitness tests of their own.
ESPN tip: Dockers by 11 points.
Wow, ESPN's chief writers must live in an alternate dimension, where Matthew Johnson didn't just recently undergo surgery on his foot! Hahahaha
ZeroO’Driscoll any chance ?
O'Driscoll and Walker are draftees too. I'm not suggesting don't develop draftees. I feel as confident in those two equalling the production we have been getting out of Henry.Our goal is long term success which requires us to develop playeds accordingly. I don't see us being a flag threat until all three of our draftees are best 22. I'm all for cutting deadweight.
I agree that how things work.We never ever make wholesale changes after a win under any circumstances. Agreed there's no way Walters, Henry and Banfield can survive in the same side.
Aish, Colyer and Walker deserve to be in that line up ahead of a few others.
I wish Walters play like Duffy in the girls team.Been keeping a close eye on Walters while watching the replay. The stats don't show the impact he had. First quarter, he was directly responsible for two goals: one from a sublime, pinpoint kick inside 50 to a Lobb lead; the second from a tackle that allowed Schultz to pounce on the spilled ball and goal. Second quarter, he fared less well against the basic indicators, but there were a number of occasions where he contested the ball and "went to ground" or came up empty handed, but in the course of doing so pushed the ball to the clear advantage of a teammate or drawn two (three on at least one occasion) opposition players, leaving unopposed Freo players to go on the offensive. Excellent crumb off marking contest with quick-fire handball to Mundy for a high kick to space at the top of the square, perfect for Treacy but unfortunately spoiled by Banfield who had his own eyes on the prize. Did give away a free when he smacked his mouth against a Crow head as he threw himself into a pack.
Am only up to half-time so far. I personally think "passenger" is way harsh. He's in it much more than the headline stats suggest. If there were a stat for possession-assist or halving a contest to advantage, so to speak three-quartering a contest?), he'd rate pretty highly, I reckon.
He broke a bone, they decided not to go for surgery, it was always going to be a slow recovery but probably didn’t want him to have a plate in his foot before he has played a single gameWtf is wrong with Johnsons foot?
Will be interesting to see how Benning goes, Seems very important due to his height and skill set.Our goal is long term success which requires us to develop playeds accordingly. I don't see us being a flag threat until all three of our draftees are best 22. I'm all for cutting deadweight.
Huddo and Paps are good. Pavlich is terrible commentating.Just seen we have Huddo, Papalia and Pavlich on commentary for the game. ******* great lineup.
They did surgery in the end. Waited a few weeks initially and with minimal recovery pushed ahead with surgery.He broke a bone, they decided not to go for surgery, it was always going to be a slow recovery but probably didn’t want him to have a plate in his foot before he has played a single game
Out of curiosity where has the idea of Walker as a lock-down defender come from?He's not, our backline is too tall. If Young/Clark are the rebounders we need a lock-down small defender which I think should be Walker. That leaves Ryan/Cox/Pearce/Logue. Obviously one starts on the bench.
Not sure if you can have a player like Hamling unable to get a game as well as Cox a capable forward and Logue and Chapman playing on smalls and still be claiming we lack substantial key position depth. We lack flexibility in how we use them.Will be interesting to see how Benning goes, Seems very important due to his height and skill set.
For all the Lobb concerns without him we look too small.
Same for Pearce, we really lack key position depth.
Interesting that both Bazzo, Williams with the so called WC injury crisis, Dixon is the one playing.
Patience is the key. but I'd suggest its not 3 but 5.
He's not so bad. Reckon he often says insightful interesting things. Just struggles to articulate himself quickly. Think he's getting better at it.Huddo and Paps are good. Pavlich is terrible commentating.
Loved him as a player, absolutely hate him in the media.