Traded Sam Petrevski-Seton [Traded to West Coast as part of three way trade for Pick 52]

[FreeAgent1]

 

[Dockers26]

Pay him appropriately then. Not 1 year on minimum money.

Pick in 50s is appropriate for that. No one else would give more.

Basis the offer of pick 52 that would suggest WC are only offering 1yr on minimum money then??

 

[philthy05]

Reckon blues should ask for a future 3rd.

Don’t think sps is worth a second.. uncontracted and pretty much hasn’t worked out at Carlton. Pick 52 may not be much value to Carlton even tho it might come in a bit after bids. Or 52 plus future 4th would be a win for blues

I don’t think young costs anything. Should be traded for pick 102.

Maybe blues just upgrade one of the dogs late picks a few spots.

 

[ghostbat12]

Basis the offer of pick 52 that would suggest WC are only offering 1yr on minimum money then??

To be honest, we probably are! We are strapped.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Reckon its the steal of the year if he goes for 52, supremely talented but just simply too soft in the contest. One good pre season with a good team and fitness staff and im positive he will end up a serious player. Id rather let him walk to PSD purely to show our disdain for the offer, but either way he's off to WCE so it doesnt really matter too much. Good luck to young Sam

 

[ghostbat12]

Who said he'd been offered a one-year deal on minimum money?

Who says he wasn’t?

 

[kaiserchief13]

Cats think a mid-2nd rounder isn't enough for Clark (granted, he's contracted) but SPS who's shown a great deal more is worth 52?

Yeah, nah.

We have a few years on the table for him and should be pushing for a top 30 pick at least. Even then, that's a bitter pill to swallow given the kid's talent. Damn shame it hasn't worked out.

Geelong is a joke to trade with though. They'd ask for pick 30 for a rookie listed player who hasn't played a game

 

[HurleyHepsHird]

WCE offering pick 52 for SPS, slightly overs from them but worth a gamble if they can de-carltonise him.

Worried he's going to ve a complete bust, maybe even fade out of the WAFL.

 

[manang magoos]

For Carlton

Doesn’t take a lot for Carlton to be pissed.

You feel we should give you extra draft picks due to your inability to not be arrogant?

Stats stats stats. Offer him a 5 year deal on $700k if you feel he is worth as much as cerra.

You never offered a first round pick for Martin and he was on Big big money. You offered a bunch of junk draft picks that “equate” to a first rounder.

That equates to a first rounder that the Suns and there stubborn chairman rejected and ended up with zip nada zilch nothing

 

[Suma Magic]

The Age reporting that the Blues haven’t offered him a contract.

Like with Brander, that really kills any trade value.

 

[Foucault1989]

Send him to the draft.

Would rather than that a rubbish pick. Not copping this.

 

[Skull Face]

Where is pick 52 coming from? Doesn't West Coast have 49 + 65 ?

I'd have done SPS + 25 + 61 for 29 + 35 + 65, Values him at pick 44.

Would probably free us up to maybe do a 3 way trade with freo and the cats.

Geelong
Out: Clark + 52
In: 27 + 35

Carlton
Out: 6 + 35
In: Cerra + 52

Freo
Out: Cerra + 27
In: Clark + 6

 

[Suma Magic]

Where is pick 52 coming from? Doesn't West Coast have 49 + 65 ?

I'd have done SPS + 25 + 61 for 29 + 35 + 65, Values him at pick 44.

Would probably free us up to maybe do a 3 way trade with freo and the cats.

Geelong
Out: Clark + 52
In: 27 + 35

Carlton
Out: 6 + 35
In: Cerra + 52

Freo
Out: Cerra + 27
In: Clark + 6

There have been three compo picks.

 

[Suma Magic]

Send him to the draft.

Would rather than that a rubbish pick. Not copping this.

He just becomes a delisted free agent. Unless you offer him a contract before the relevant deadline.

 

[Skull Face]

There have been three compo picks.

AFL needs to keep their indicative draft order updated daily to avoid these errors!

 

[Foucault1989]

He just becomes a delisted free agent. Unless you offer him a contract before the relevant deadline.

Would rather nothing for him than a token pick. Sends a bad message we are pushovers.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

AFL needs to keep their indicative draft order updated daily to avoid these errors!

Lore ‘s threads are the best for keeping up to date.

 

[Suma Magic]

Would rather nothing for him than a token pick. Sends a bad message we are pushovers.

Much harder to send that message when you don’t offer a contract.

 

[Foucault1989]

Much harder to send that message when you don’t offer a contract.

How do you know we haven't?

 

[amazingjoshy]

Where is pick 52 coming from? Doesn't West Coast have 49 + 65 ?

I'd have done SPS + 25 + 61 for 29 + 35 + 65, Values him at pick 44.

52 will likely become around 40-45 after teams pay points for their father/son/academy picks

 

[Skull Face]

52 will likely become around 40-45 after teams pay points for their father/son/academy picks

I don't care for your guessing game on how many picks will be used up before it, pick 52 is pick 52

 

[Madblue]

Unfortunately the way SPS has played and his lack of competitiveness and effort to improve has made him virtually worthless

 

[ghostbat12]

That equates to a first rounder that the Suns and there stubborn chairman rejected and ended up with zip nada zilch nothing

Ohhhh it “equates” does it.

No it does not equate because multiple picks = multiple spots on list you have to make room for. And if they are crap picks, then has no value because then club can’t use all of its own picks anyway.

 

[amazingjoshy]

I don't care for your guessing game on how many picks will be used up before it, pick 52 is pick 52

Might have to suck it up then

Even though you're likely to get a pick at almost exactly what you yourself valued him at

 

[ghostbat12]

How do you know we haven't?

Have you?

 

[Foucault1989]

Have you?

I don't know. Probably not....