Roast St Kilda in no mans land

[Red Bull]

I see you have moved on from the Hawthorn thread onto the St Kilda one

Stay on topic here

 

[sexyhunk]

obviously not great news on max king

12

Max King

Age

24

Ht

202cm

Wt

100kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

7.3

2star

K

4.7

2star

HB

2.6

2star

M

2.7

3star

T

0.7

3star

G

1.4

5star

D

7.3

2star

K

4.7

2star

HB

2.6

2star

M

2.7

3star

T

0.7

1star

G

1.4

5star

D

8.0

2star

K

5.2

2star

HB

2.8

3star

M

2.8

3star

T

0.6

3star

G

1.4

5star

but is not all bad for team going forward. they can now use the last 8 weeks to see how the forwadline can potentially look without king. maybe they get more out of some other players with a more unpredictable setup.

 

[Red Bull]

obviously not great news on max king but is not all bad for team going forward. they can now use the last 8 weeks to see how the forwadline can potentially look without king. maybe they get more out of some other players with a more unpredictable setup.

Membrey??

 

[sexyhunk]

Membrey??

whoever, i am not familiar with the saints list.

 

[Captain Paddy]

Membrey??

Honestly rather see us play someone that hasn't debuted yet like Heath or Keeler instead of Membrey

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

Is it me, or do they always seem to have a horrid injury list?

Seems to have been going on for years.

 

[Jane Doe]

Stay on topic here

Not defending St Kilda at all but your very keen to express your opinion on easy targets. What exactly has your team achieved since the start of the century?

 

[Red Bull]

Not defending St Kilda at all but your very keen to express your opinion on easy targets. What exactly has your team achieved since the start of the century?

St.Kilda thread … stay on topic

 

[projectv]

Honestly rather see us play someone that hasn't debuted yet like Heath or Keeler instead of Membrey

Perhaps Matt Allison who's been rotting away at Sandy until his inevitable delisting could get a run.

Doubt it though.

 

[beside the seaside]

St.Kilda’s in the AFL mate.
It’s all a part of the game.
No discounts from opposition supporters for being shithouse …

Whatever floats your boat I guess.

 

[Captain Paddy]

Perhaps Matt Allison who's been rotting away at Sandy until his inevitable delisting could get a run.

Doubt it though.

One of the worst picks we've seen lol.

I remember the draft coverage didn't actually have a picture of him to use straight away

 

[Lingsface]

Any particular reason why you are suggesting such a trade?

No purely hypothetical, just couldn’t answer it myself. Would I want a proven star for 3 more years or would I take the risk of this guys potential?

 

[Jane Doe]

St.Kilda thread … stay on topic

Yep donuts. Typical

 

[Dangerousfield]

Club was wrong about the list.

Ross is right.

Funnily enough the club being wrong arguably got Ratten needlessly fired to get him the job.

An old adage but absolutely true is that the biggest mistake a club can make is to misjudge where their list is at. Saints guilty of this more than once.

It's so difficult to rebuild from a sinking ship and that's how St.Kilda looks to be right now. A graders don't move to clubs like the Saints no matter how much money you throw at them.

Saints and Richmond the two standout unattractive clubs at present, North seems to be losing some of it's rotting smell.

 

[PJays]

It's worrying how King can't seem to stay on the field.

If you look at the past 7 seasons including his TAC Cup year with Sandringham in 2018, there's only 3 seasons out of 7 where he's managed to play consistently.

2018 - ACL in April, missed most of the Under 18 year
2019 - Played about 5 games in the VFL and had ankle injury
2020 - 2022 he managed to play most of the season
2023 and 2024 there's been multiple major injuries (out for months) and multiple moderate ones (out for a few weeks). By the end of 2024 he will have played 23 of 47 games across 2023 and 2024 (including the one he got injured 20 seconds into the game against Melbourne. So really, 22 games from 47)

This lack of durability is pretty concerning.

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

It's worrying how King can't seem to stay on the field.

If you look at the past 7 seasons including his TAC Cup year with Sandringham in 2018, there's only 3 seasons out of 7 where he's managed to play consistently.

2018 - ACL in April, missed most of the Under 18 year
2019 - Played about 5 games in the VFL and had ankle injury
2020 - 2022 he managed to play most of the season
2023 and 2024 there's been multiple major injuries (out for months) and multiple moderate ones (out for a few weeks). By the end of 2024 he will have played 23 of 47 games across 2023 and 2024 (including the one he got injured 20 seconds into the game against Melbourne. So really, 22 games from 47)

This lack of durability is pretty concerning.

Open question...

How much of that is due to putting a skinny kid in the role of key forward?

And not a Roaming, Up The Ground type key forward - but the Deep F50 one that is expected to crash packs and gets crunched multiple times each game by multiple large mature Key Position Defenders?

I was critical of St Kilda in how they used and developed McCartin, and part of me sees a similar thing happening with King.

They draft these guys because of their prodigious talent and ability - then try to use them as wrecking balls.

Strange.

It's no wonder they break down early.

 

[thistimeforsure]

A disaster?

Why?

If you had to guess who do you think the teams are with a bye Rd 1-4

Guarantee you it won’t be the Collingwood’s , Carlton’s and Sydney’s of the world

The fans of whatever teams they do pick get it spelt out in no uncertain terms what the AFL think of you and that will just add bitterness on top of bitterness


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Kuuz]

Weird question but would you trade Jeremy Cameron for Max King?

Honestly, why would the Saints trade their 23-24 yo key forward for a 31 yo forward, who if you give any credence to his social media posting, is very happy at the Cattery.

Even more odd, as most comments on this thread suggest Saints should bottom out, not go all in. Cameron, in the very low chance he'd want out, would be only wanted by a team going for a cup in the next 1-2 years.

My take

For me - it feels like Saints have already tried the idea of topping up & pushing via trade, but they just didn't have the right cattle to make a concerted finals push. It's probably not a bad idea to top up on the high end of the draft for a few and restock. Good year this year as well for midfielders - which is precisely what they need.

They have some good young talent (despite some patchy form from Pou and Caminiti - but Owens is super exciting), and as long as they keep a few seasoned heads, should avoid the complete ass falling out like North. They just desperately need to rejeuvanate that midfield, it feels very one-dimensional and slow.

Maybe they could look to trade one or two valuable older heads to top up hard - but I'd personally hate to see them lose Sinc or Marshall, as they are fabric of the club players and genuinely compete hard.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Is it me, or do they always seem to have a horrid injury list?

Seems to have been going on for years.

I thought they've been relatively healthy to their core players. Steele, Marshall, Sinclair don't miss much. Yes, King has been injury prone and Coffield / Clark were/are perennial injured but neither were actually Best 22 players given their lack of development through injury. Zak Jones is... Zac Jones. Think they've had a very healthy run at it all things considered.

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

I thought they've been relatively healthy to their core players. Steele, Marshall, Sinclair don't miss much. Yes, King has been injury prone and Coffield / Clark were/are perennial injured but neither were actually Best 22 players given their lack of development through injury. Zak Jones is... Zac Jones. Think they've had a very healthy run at it all things considered.

Yeah, maybe.

I thought they were basically fielding a ressies team for the first half last year.

Didn't Steele do a collarbone last year and miss a chunk? And Sinclair missed the start of this year didn't he?

I thought I remembered Marshall busting his foot recently?

 

[BigFrizz36]

But what does that have to with him having to go through a formal process?

What you just described, if true, happened outside of any formal process.


Not going through a formal process, does not mean that there is no process.

Part of the formal process was that he had to present to and be interviewed by the board.

Prior to that as Sayers mate and, in the belief that the job was his, he was all in. Once he was asked go through the formal process he bailed out.

You can argue as to why he bailed out but there is no argument that his attitude towards the job changed significantly once he was asked to do more than simply being handed the job.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Yeah, maybe.

I thought they were basically fielding a ressies team for the first half last year.

Didn't Steele do a collarbone last year and miss a chunk? And Sinclair missed the start of this year didn't he?

I thought I remembered Marshall busting his foot recently?

Marshall was bruised but didn't miss any games. Sinclair missed round 1 but has played since then. Steele didn't miss a game last year but did have a sore shoulder and stopped tackling for a while.

 

[BrutThough]

Yeah, maybe.

I thought they were basically fielding a ressies team for the first half last year.

Didn't Steele do a collarbone last year and miss a chunk? And Sinclair missed the start of this year didn't he?

I thought I remembered Marshall busting his foot recently?

Steele missed 3 games with the collarbone. Sinclair missed rd1 after calf issues in the preseason. Probably would have played if we didn't have a 5 day turn around into the next game.

Marshall's foot was an issue in 2021 but he's been fine since.

 

[projectv]

Open question...

How much of that is due to putting a skinny kid in the role of key forward?

And not a Roaming, Up The Ground type key forward - but the Deep F50 one that is expected to crash packs and gets crunched multiple times each game by multiple large mature Key Position Defenders?

I was critical of St Kilda in how they used and developed McCartin, and part of me sees a similar thing happening with King.

They draft these guys because of their prodigious talent and ability - then try to use them as wrecking balls.

Strange.

It's no wonder they break down early.

Nick Riewoldt syndrome.

Ever since he left we've been trying to fill the gap. First McCartin, now King.

Watch our forward line improve drastically over the next few weeks. We won't just bomb it into a 1v3 anymore.

 

[Lavender Bushranger]

Part of the formal process was that he had to present to and be interviewed by the board.

Prior to that as Sayers mate and, in the belief that the job was his, he was all in. Once he was asked go through the formal process he bailed out.

You can argue as to why he bailed out but there is no argument that his attitude towards the job changed significantly once he was asked to do more than simply being handed the job.

Why are you telling me this?