pantskyle
Angry Ape
- Oct 1, 2007
- 128,438
- 133,570
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Storm-Man Utd-Heart-Luton-Patriots
It's even overs for the initial required overs. For pick 14 I'd pass.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 6 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Mega Thread Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2015 trade period edition
- Thread starter Miguel Sanchez
- Start date
- Tagged users None
It's even overs for the initial required overs. For pick 14 I'd pass.
Perhaps if we got pick 24 back (the Leuenberger comp).
Hopefully that would satisfy Hawthorn.
If we are keen on Jetta, we could do:
17 to Sydney for Jetta + 33 (Sydney's second),
33+37 (Selwood compo) to Brisbane for Redden,
36 to Hawthorn for Anderson.
The fact that Colledge asked to be traded indicates that somebody is interested in him - perhaps we could get an early 3rd rounder for him? Sydney would have to find a suitable trade for Sinclair if they want him badly.
17 to Sydney for Jetta + 33 (Sydney's second),
33+37 (Selwood compo) to Brisbane for Redden,
36 to Hawthorn for Anderson.
The fact that Colledge asked to be traded indicates that somebody is interested in him - perhaps we could get an early 3rd rounder for him? Sydney would have to find a suitable trade for Sinclair if they want him badly.
I don't think either Brisbane or Hawthorn would accept those offers for contracted players.
"Just chuck Anderson in for Hill in the pocket......"
Seriously, do people honestly think that literally the final 22 spot is the forward pocket and just anyone can play it or something?
25 goals for Anderson in the VFL, 14 goals for Newman in the WAFL, 5 goals for Minson in the VFL...
If you think any of those players can beat Hills 40 goal effort, you are mistaken. And clearly have never played football.
Seriously, do people honestly think that literally the final 22 spot is the forward pocket and just anyone can play it or something?
25 goals for Anderson in the VFL, 14 goals for Newman in the WAFL, 5 goals for Minson in the VFL...
If you think any of those players can beat Hills 40 goal effort, you are mistaken. And clearly have never played football.
That ain't gonna happen...
pantskyle
Angry Ape
- Oct 1, 2007
- 128,438
- 133,570
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Storm-Man Utd-Heart-Luton-Patriots
I could live with that.
Hill was an inspired, low cost pickup that has paid dividends. But the fact of the matter is he is pretty inconsistent-such is life for a forward pocket I guess. Having a young player put pressure on him to perform can only be a good thing.
Hill may well replicate his 40 goal season, but if he doesn't, he will have to fight for his spot. As he should.
Hill may well replicate his 40 goal season, but if he doesn't, he will have to fight for his spot. As he should.
Had a quick squiz - Anderson had a VFL game of 27 disposals and 6 goals late in the year 
Same can be said of Masten. I miss the days of 2011 where he was actually dropped for his performances and he lifted another gear to come back.
2013 was his career best season, but i think he's regressed slightly in the 2 seasons since while he should have been continuing his development.
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,497
- 28,834
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Vozzo is on Tradio today. Anyone know what time?
That wont get close to satisfying Brisbane or Hawthorn
I agree that pressure on his spot is healthy, but the crap Josh Hill gets on this board is ridiculous. Would people be saying the same thing if his name was Cyril Rioli?
Rioli kicked 42 goals in 24 games this year. Josh Hill kicked 40 in 22 games. Cyril won the Norm Smith. Josh won the Ross Glendenning.
It's about time people looked up and realised Hill is a lock for our best 22.
I just think every now and then he puts in a cringe worthy effort that supporters really hate
20th all time for goals at West Coast. Not bad for 4 seasons work.
Not bad for a trade of pick 49 either.
Meaningless statement.
We used to start games with Judd, Kerr and Stenglein, with Cousins on the HFF and Fletcher on the wing.
Does that mean we rated Stenglein higher than Cousins and Fletcher?
People need to pull their heads in.
As of right now Masten, Schofield and Hill are all in our best 22. Highly likely even if we get Jetta, Redden and Anderson.
Butler, Ellis, Rosa, Hutchings, Sinclair and based on the second half of the year Cripps are all more likely to be out of the team before any of them.
As of right now Masten, Schofield and Hill are all in our best 22. Highly likely even if we get Jetta, Redden and Anderson.
Butler, Ellis, Rosa, Hutchings, Sinclair and based on the second half of the year Cripps are all more likely to be out of the team before any of them.
Not sure if serious.
- Sep 28, 2009
- 23,634
- 33,745
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Reading FC
People seem to hate him because they expect him to be some sort of wrecking ball in the forward pressure department. Lecras never cops anything for poor defensive efforts though.
Agreed. Hill is a lock for 22, we do need someone who can put pressure on his spot.
He always has patches in seasons when he struggles and needs to freshen up. If Hill and Cripps/Lecras go down at the same time our only option is to play Newman and Yeo forward. We need another crumbing small.
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,497
- 28,834
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Hopefully he decides that it's trade time. Good trade time.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll
- Locked
