List Mgmt. Trade & Free Agency talk Pt 5

[Infamy]

we cant trade our 1st pick

We absolutely can, you just can't trade out of both the 1st & 2nd rounds in the next draft
We have 2 x 2nd rounders, so we can trade our 1st pick, especially if we take 2 x 1st rounders this year

Though even if you were right, it would be pretty easy to get a future 4th round back as part of the deal

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

We absolutely can, you just can't trade out of both the 1st & 2nd rounds in the next draft
We have 2 x 2nd rounders, so we can trade our 1st pick, especially if we take 2 x 1st rounders this year

Though even if you were right, it would be pretty easy to get a future 4th round back as part of the deal

I cant seem to find it but it was talked about on the drafts board that if you trade out 2 picks in 2 different rounds you couldnt and if you traded out 1st you needed to have the other 3 rounds in place (not original picks but a spot in these rounds)

I could be wrong but thats what stuck in my head from that

 

[Infamy]

I cant seem to find it but it was talked about on the drafts board that if you trade out 2 picks in 2 different rounds you couldnt and if you traded out 1st you needed to have the other 3 rounds in place (not original picks but a spot in these rounds)

I could be wrong but thats what stuck in my head from that

I think what was meant is you can't trade out of both the first 2 rounds of the next draft, they don't care about later rounds as long as you take the 3 players each year

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

I think what was meant is you can't trade out of both the first 2 rounds of the next draft, they don't care about later rounds as long as you take the 3 players each year

cool i must have misunderstood or the post i was reading was wrong . my bad

 

[Mr Magic]

Has trading for picks stopped until the start of the draft??

If it has how many draft picks can RFC have for this year?

 

[DoItForCaptBlood]

Has trading for picks stopped until the start of the draft??

If it has how many draft picks can RFC have for this year?

Finished Monday I think. We can have 38 main list and 6 rookies, but we have Colina, so 5 rookies.
We had 9 come off the list of 44, so 35. Then one came in, 36. Two more to be rerookied, so 38. We can go to 43 ( only one cat B).
So I calculate we can only take our 5 picks we have.
But I am sure someone will find an error there somewhere... If anyone can understand the explanation anyway...

 

[Rich o man]

Pick 7 - Rin Tin Tin
Pick 15 - Lassie
Pick 26 - Snoopy
Pick 27 - Toto
Pick 28 - Red Dog

Snoopy way too high. I wouldn’t use a 2nd rounder on such a lazy dog. Rookie chance at best.

 

[Rich o man]

Hugh Greenwood delisted.
I wouldn't mind him as a stop gap DFA....
Bit crazy for them to delist him imo

Now we have proof that North Melbourne recruiters read the Richmond board on big footy

 

[David C]

Lets not speak too soon !!

I can easily see St Kilda taking Biggy from under our noses as he was their academy kid and we took him , Looks like gentlemans agreements no longer hold water with some sh!t Stain Clubs.

Hope clubs go all out on Norf's kids now

You don't remember Richmond picking up Todd Banfield on the rookie list a few years back?? After Brisbane had committed to re-rookie him. All clubs do it.

 

[David C]

Someone else on another thread in another forum said maybe Gold Coast will want a pick now, like one of our second rounders, because they where planning on picking up Greenwood in the draft but now can't. They have a few futures Gold Coast at the moment I believe

I find it interesting. I suspect Gold Coast might have thought this was going to happen because its a good way to get further salary cap off their list. Makes they trade of Brodie away giving up a better pick kinda stupid I think unless Brodie had a few years left on his contract

Touk has now resigned for 5 years. Expect a few more to follow. It does look like they put Greenwood in the shop window.

 

[fargothegreat]

Lets not speak too soon !!

I can easily see St Kilda taking Biggy from under our noses as he was their academy kid and we took him , Looks like gentlemans agreements no longer hold water with some sh!t Stain Clubs.

Hope clubs go all out on Norf's kids now

I think any sort of gentleman's agreement went out the window when Gold Coast started taking the piss and delisted a bloke who finished fourth in their best and fairest.

I think the situation reflects more poorly on Gold Coast and Greenwood himself than it does on Norf.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

I think any sort of gentleman's agreement went out the window when Gold Coast started taking the piss and delisted a bloke who finished fourth in their best and fairest.

I think the situation reflects more poorly on Gold Coast and Greenwood himself than it does on Norf.

Yet the suns will keep getting help from the afl despite some pretty piss poor decisions that you could say has kept them being a bottom 4 side year in year out.

 

[Profop]

Touk has now resigned for 5 years. Expect a few more to follow. It does look like they put Greenwood in the shop window.

If they wanted Greenwood gone why wouldn’t they have just traded him?

Doesn’t make any sense to lose him for nothing

 

[David C]

If they wanted Greenwood gone why wouldn’t they have just traded him?

Doesn’t make any sense to lose him for nothing

Also doesn't make sense to delist him when they had plenty of other options on their main list. Someone could still pick up Thompson as well even though he has been injured the last few years. They could do with that pick 19 now and/or Brodie.

 

[TJTIGER]

Jon Snow is back...

Can't really get too excited.....he knows nothing...

 

[T4P]

I think any sort of gentleman's agreement went out the window when Gold Coast started taking the piss and delisted a bloke who finished fourth in their best and fairest.

I think the situation reflects more poorly on Gold Coast and Greenwood himself than it does on Norf.

Bit harsh on Greenwood, this is all on GC - they took a risk, it backfired. Greenwood made a rational decision to go for more security.

 

[Infamy]

You don't remember Richmond picking up Todd Banfield on the rookie list a few years back?? After Brisbane had committed to re-rookie him. All clubs do it.

Apparently the "agreement" is that if the original club overlooks that player with an earlier pick in the rookie draft then they become fair game.
Brisbane took Isaac Conway with Pick 6 in the rookie draft, so once they overlooked him, we grabbed him with Pick 11

 

[beema limapep]

As posted on the other thread, excellently comprehensive yet relatively unknown draft resource with a write up on each player. If you have an interest in a player or 3, you might learn something more here:-

2021 AFL Draft Profiles

The 2021 AFL Draft Profiles page will feature all 90 National AFL Draft Combine invites profiled thanks to Rookie Me Central.

central.rookieme.com

Tomorrow their draft order is released.

 

[THE THIN MAN]

John Snow is back...

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

You don't remember Richmond picking up Todd Banfield on the rookie list a few years back?? After Brisbane had committed to re-rookie him. All clubs do it.

Very interesting point you bring up with banfield as it was slightly different for a few reasons
1st Is that He was drafted in the rookie draft and i believe was out of contract but lets let that go as its not the important part.

I remember years ago SOS and another recruiter was asked abut this and they pretty much explained the selecting of 'other clubs players who get promised to be recruited back' and what is acceptable and what is frowned upon and not done.

Basically what they said was its not the right thing to do if the clubs wants to redraft the player and another club takes him unless the club doesnt select him with their 1st pick in the rookie draft and after that 1st pick its open slather and his reasoning was that club had the chance and was given the chance to take the player but had selected another player.

But they did say that its not the right thing to do.

 

[tigs2010]

Very interesting point you bring up with banfield as it was slightly different for a few reasons
1st Is that He was drafted in the rookie draft and i believe was out of contract but lets let that go as its not the important part.

I remember years ago SOS and another recruiter was asked abut this and they pretty much explained the selecting of 'other clubs players who get promised to be recruited back' and what is acceptable and what is frowned upon and not done.

Basically what they said was its not the right thing to do if the clubs wants to redraft the player and another club takes him unless the club doesnt dselect him with their 1st pick in the rookie draft and after that 1st pick its open slather and his reasoning was that club had the chance and was given the chance to take the player but had selected another player.

But they did say that its not the right thing to do.

Sure it was SOS? Sounds too coherent

 

[BruceTempany14]

Says alot about Norf & Greenwood

Norf we all know are the sh!t stain club that only exists to ramp up player salaries and can never get a decent player unless they pay way over market rate
Cj - $450k x 4 for a 10 game player
Polec $750k for a seagull with only 1 wing
Greenwood $500k for a mercenary coming of a doggy knee averaging 17 touches game

Greenwood has form for jumping at every chance for cash

And Norf have form for treating high priced recruits like crap mid contract ( Polec pittard ).
So assuming behaviour repeats Greenwood and CCJ are fkd !

Norf , how they havnt been shunted off to Port Moresby or somewhere else is astounding. A veritable waste of space .


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[RJKTiger]

If they wanted Greenwood gone why wouldn’t they have just traded him?

Doesn’t make any sense to lose him for nothing

Gold Coast are a ****ing rabble

Consider this for a second

In: Lachie Weller, Future 2nd, Future 4th.

Out: Will Brodie, Hugh Greenwood, Pick 2, Pick 19, Pick 61, Pick 69.

That is the direct result of 3 list decisions they have made in the last couple of years. They are legit destroying promising kids careers left, right & centre. They should just close them up and be done with it. No culture, no supporters.

 

[tigs2010]

Gold Coast are a ******* rabble

Consider this for a second

In: Lachie Weller, Future 2nd, Future 4th.

Out: Will Brodie, Hugh Greenwood, Pick 2, Pick 19, Pick 61, Pick 69.

That is the direct result of 3 list decisions they have made in the last couple of years. They are legit destroying promising kids careers left, right & centre. They should just close them up and be done with it. No culture, no supporters.

Craig ‘Helmut’ Cameron doing some of his finest work. Coxy_ ’s mate

 

[Rioli2Rioli]

We really need to save Elijah Hollands