MVP Votes v Hawthorn

[brucetiki]

Haven't seen a thread for this yet, so I may as well start with my votes.

I assume we're sticking with the same format (5-4-3-2-1 for Player of the Year, 3-2-1 for Best Team Man, 3-2-1 for Rookie of the Year)

Player of the Year (POTY)
5 - Sloane
4 - Dangerfield
3 - Davis
2 - Vince
1 - Johncock

Best Team Man (BTM)
3 - Dangerfield
2 - Vince
1 - Tambling

Rookie of the Year (ROTY)
3 - Smith
2 - McKernan
1 - N/A

 

[Slippery Pete]

5 - Dangerfield
4 - Davis
3 - Sloane
2- Walker
1- Tambling

 

[WAG]

(POTY)
5 - Dangerfield
4 - Sloane
3 - Vince
2 - Davis
1 - Tambling


(ROTY)
3 - Mckernan
2 - Smith

 

[Ravenous Crow]

5 - Dangerfield
4 - Davis
3 - Tambling
2 - Sloane
1 - McKernan

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

POTY:
5. Dangerfield
4. Davis
3. Sloane
2. Tambling
1. Walker

BTM:
3. Tambling
2. Dangerfield
1. Vince

ROTY:
2. McKernan
1. Smith

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

Player of the Year (POTY)
5 - Radar, I thought was our best 4 qtr player
4 - Davis, great job on buddy
3 - Sloane, another to have a solid 4 qtr effort
2 - Dangerfield, 2 touches in the 1st hafl however match winner in 2nd half
1 - Tambling, another to have a solid 4 qtr effort

Best Team Man (BTM)
3 - VB, good Captain's game
2 - Truck, did the job on Roughy and provided Davis great support
1 - Tambling, I loved his 1%er's

Rookie of the Year (ROTY)
3 - Smack
2 - Smith
1 - N/A

 

[Bicks]

POTY
5 Reilly
4 Davis
3 Tambling
2 Dangerfield
1 Stevens

BTM
3 Rutten
2 Vince
1 Sloane

ROTY
3 McKernan
2 Smith

 

[NSWCROW]

POTY

5 - Davis
3 - Sloanedog
3 - Mr Tambling man
2 - Radar
1 - Smack


BTM

3 - Davis
2 - Truck
1 - VB


ROTY

2 - Smack

 

[ManInTheArena]

POTY
5 - Dangerfield
4 - Davis
3 - Reilly
2 - McKernan
1 - Tambling

BTM
3 - Dangerfield
2 - Van Berlo
1 - Davis

ROTY
3 - McKernan
2 - N/A
1 - Smith

 

[Dewy006]

POTY:

5: Dangerfield
4: Reilly
3: Sloane
2: Davis
1: Vince

BTM

3: VB
2: Davis
1: Truck

ROTY:

2: Smith
1: Smack

 

[Damp Squarie]

POTY

5 Sloan
4 Davis
3 Walker
2 Tambling
1 McKernan

BTM

3 Van Berlo
2 McKernan
1 Reilly

ROTY

3 McKernan
2 Pass
1 Smith

 

[sydney_crow]

POTY
5. Reilly
4. Davis
3. Tambling
2. Sloane
1. McKernan

BTM
3. Sloane
2. Rutten
1. VB

ROTY
3. McKernan
2. Smith

 

[SebastianVettel]

POTY
5 - Dangerfield
4 - Davis
3 - Reilly
2 - McKernan
1 - Walker

BTM
3 - Davis
2 - Sloane
1 - Tambling

ROTY
3 - McKernan
2 - Smith

 

[Allefgib]

POTY
5 - Davis
4 - Danger
3 - Walker
2 - sloane
1 - reilly

BTM
3 - Davis
2 - tambling
1 - rutten

ROTY
3 - McKernan
2 - Smith[/QUOTE]

 

[cammo84]

POTY
5 Dangerfield
4 Rielly
3 Davis
2 Walker
1 Tambling

BTM
3 Davis
2 Rielly
1 Van Berlo

ROTY
3 McKernan
2 Smith

 

[Crow-mo]

POTY
5 - Tambling
4 - Danger
3 - Stevens
2 - Reilly
1 - McKernan

BTM
3 - Sloane
2 - Rutten
1 - davis



ROTY
3 - McKernan
2 -
1 - Smith

 

[chigwidden]

POTY
5 - Davis
4 - Reilly
3 - Sloane
2 - Tambling
1 - McKernan

BTM
3 - Rutten
2 - Vince
1 - VB

ROTY
3 - McKernan
2 - Smith

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Player of the Year
5 - Brent Reilly
4 - Richard Tambling
3 - Shaun McKernan
2 - Patrick Dangerfield
1 - Bernie Vince

Best Team Man
3 - Phil Davis
2 - Rory Sloane
1 - Scott Stevens

Rookie of the Year
3 - Shaun McKernan
2 - Brodie Smith
1 - -

 

[WALL-e]

Player of the Year
5 - Phil Davis
4 - Brent Reilly
3 - Patrick Dangerfield
2 - Ricard Tambling
1 - Rory Sloane

Best Team Man
3 - Phil Davis
2 - Richard Tambling
1 - Brent Reilly

Rookie of the Year
3 - Shaun McKernan
2 - Brodie Smith
1 - -

 

[Vader]

POTY
5. Reilly
4. Tambling
3. Stevens
2. Rutten
1. VB

BTM
3. Sloane - playing out the game with a broken thumb and broken jaw!
2. Stevens - so many saving marks
1. Davis - ditto

ROTY
3. McKernan
2. Smith

 

[croweater 41]

POTY:
5: Sloane
4: Davis
3: Dangerfield
2: Tambling
1: Smack

BTM:
3:VB
2: Davis
1: Stevens
ROTY:
3: Smack
2: Smith

 

[adelaide_40]

POTY:
5 - Sloane
4 - Davis
3 - Tambling
2 - Dangerfield
1 - Mckernan

BTM:
3 - Davis
2 - Sloane
1 - Scott stevens

ROTY:
2 - Mckernan
1 - Smith

 

[DREAM TEAM BUFF]

POTY
5 Dangerfield
4 Davis
3 Sloane
2 Tambling
1 Walker

BTM
3 Van Berlo
2 McKernan
1 Reilly

ROTY
3 - McKernan
2 - Smith

 

[Vader]

There's an incredible spread of votes here, with almost nothing uniform about it at all (other than the ROTY voting). This is a really good sign, as it indicates just how much of a "team performance" it was, rather than being reliant on 2 or 3 shooting stars.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

There's an incredible spread of votes here, with almost nothing uniform about it at all (other than the ROTY voting). This is a really good sign, as it indicates just how much of a "team performance" it was, rather than being reliant on 2 or 3 shooting stars.

I also found it hard due to the contrasting nature of our performance. The terrible first half, the fantastic second half. How do you rate a Dangerfield, Walker or Stevens who were terrible in the first half but very good in the second versus a Reilly who was decent throughout?