Gotcha. Makes sense.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. Welcome Liam Duggan Pick 11 2014 Draft
- Thread starter larrikin
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Gotcha. Makes sense.
You came to that conclusion simply from this?
“I’d heard a few rumours that West Coast were interested,” Duggan said from the Gold Coast Convention Centre
I'd hardly say he knew. The next quote is him saying he "hoped" we'd call his name out.
Carbine Chaos
See My Chess
- Apr 1, 2009
- 65,365
- 99,269
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
Impossible to say whether or not he was our first choice and it's not as if the club is going to come out and say gee we wish Cockatoo was an Eagle.
pantskyle
Angry Ape
- Oct 1, 2007
- 128,657
- 134,524
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Storm-Man Utd-Heart-Luton-Patriots
Not at all.
It's mainly my own opinion based on a few things I've heard, the above being one.
I did say it earlier on in the week that we aren't taking Cockatoo.
Get a load of captain hindsight over here. You've been hosing down talks of Cockatoo for a while though Pants, i think maybe you just hoped we didn't
pantskyle
Angry Ape
- Oct 1, 2007
- 128,657
- 134,524
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Storm-Man Utd-Heart-Luton-Patriots
Get a load of captain hindsight over here. You've been hosing talks down of Cockatoo for a while though Pants, i think maybe you just hoped we didn't
I think my track record speaks for itself.
Exactly,being able to play footy is also important or you end up with the Ash Smiths of this world.
Clint Beastwood
Club Legend
Skip to 0:48, this is all I have been thinking since last night.
Impressive highlights as well, all the better that the majority of the other guys in the draft have a year on him.
Impressive highlights as well, all the better that the majority of the other guys in the draft have a year on him.
I though we actually looked fairly quick in the later part of the season when Schuey and Gaff started having more impact. Ball movement was more an issue than leg speed
- Jun 2, 2006
- 4,519
- 2,959
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Charlton FC
Really nice highlight package. Great kick, good mark, good vision, chooses right options. Whilst not super quick, he appears quick enough. Seems to have time and space. Was on his own a lot. Team mates look for him to dish off to. Some nice reading of the play and taps. Gets forward and kicks goals. Something we really need.
Overall I'm excited with this pick.
Thought I'd repost my brief analysis of highlights from Western Jets games in here:
"I just discovered that the Western Jets have highlights of basically every game they played this year.
These are interesting highlights to watch in regards to our pick because Laverde (#9), Duggan (#4) and Manadue (#15) all play for the Western Jets.
Having watched these highlights my preference would be Liam Duggan for our selection.
Here's why:
@ 1:18 Liam does his best to mimic Sam Mitchell around the contest. His sidestep is important and his handball executions are timed perfectly.
@ 1:34 Liam shrugs and accelerates at the same time creating space to kick a goal.
@ 2:44 Liam kept his feet at the important time, controlled the bouncing ball, accelerated from congestion and steadied to kick the goal.
@ 1:03 Liam keeps the ball in front of himself and controls the tackle put on him so he can hit his teammate with the handpass.
@ 2:25 Liam receives a handball with incoming pressure but shrugs the player while only observing him in his peripheral vision.
@ 1:30 Liam contests on the ground and picks the ball up cleanly and steps through two opposition players, feints slightly to wrong-foot another and then shoots at goal.
@ 2:24 Liam is confronted by a much larger opposition player but executes a great tackle that earns him a HTB decision.
@ 1:30 Liam goes to ground to retrieve the ball in a contest. Flicking a handball inside he then follows up to create a goal for the Jets.
@ 1:47 Liam reads the centre clearance contest to perfection.
There are numerous other examples of his clearance work and goals but I think some people are misunderstanding his role. He is not a back flanker, he's a midfielder and could do wonders for a team who need a good decision maker in traffic."
"I just discovered that the Western Jets have highlights of basically every game they played this year.
These are interesting highlights to watch in regards to our pick because Laverde (#9), Duggan (#4) and Manadue (#15) all play for the Western Jets.
Having watched these highlights my preference would be Liam Duggan for our selection.
Here's why:
@ 1:18 Liam does his best to mimic Sam Mitchell around the contest. His sidestep is important and his handball executions are timed perfectly.
@ 1:34 Liam shrugs and accelerates at the same time creating space to kick a goal.
@ 2:44 Liam kept his feet at the important time, controlled the bouncing ball, accelerated from congestion and steadied to kick the goal.
@ 1:03 Liam keeps the ball in front of himself and controls the tackle put on him so he can hit his teammate with the handpass.
@ 2:25 Liam receives a handball with incoming pressure but shrugs the player while only observing him in his peripheral vision.
@ 1:30 Liam contests on the ground and picks the ball up cleanly and steps through two opposition players, feints slightly to wrong-foot another and then shoots at goal.
@ 2:24 Liam is confronted by a much larger opposition player but executes a great tackle that earns him a HTB decision.
@ 1:30 Liam goes to ground to retrieve the ball in a contest. Flicking a handball inside he then follows up to create a goal for the Jets.
@ 1:47 Liam reads the centre clearance contest to perfection.
There are numerous other examples of his clearance work and goals but I think some people are misunderstanding his role. He is not a back flanker, he's a midfielder and could do wonders for a team who need a good decision maker in traffic."
Are you talking to me? A link to what?
I was, but it's cool the vids have appeared.
They needed a refresh to work it seems.
Nah, I had to relink them because they didn't copy properly.
Wow - third video at 1:30 - that was pure class.
I think his development will surprise us all next year.
Definitely is footy smart, has a tonne of class, composure and elite skills.
I'm not sure how i feel after watching all of those.
Laverde does some ridiculous things and Rainbow is outstanding in some passages of play.
Also the first time i've had a good look at Menadue, Richmond have got to be happy about getting him.
Laverde does some ridiculous things and Rainbow is outstanding in some passages of play.
Also the first time i've had a good look at Menadue, Richmond have got to be happy about getting him.
Didn't someone say we didn't expect Cockatoo to be available and would be taken before our pick?
Duggan might have always been Plan B?
pantskyle
Angry Ape
- Oct 1, 2007
- 128,657
- 134,524
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Storm-Man Utd-Heart-Luton-Patriots
The Cockatoo to Geelong thing happened last minute. He simply bolted.
Hey guys sorry for the intrusion. Know Duggan personally and can tell you he's a great bloke and will be a very good player (stands up in big moments) and although I'm bias I believe he can be a top five player out of this draft as he has the potential to have a very strong inside game to go with his elite skills. By drafting Lamb, Nielson and less noticeably Cavka you shouldn't need to worry about any potential home sickness issues seeing as they already know each other and get along from their time in the AIS program and should enjoy their time in the west.
Last edited:
Welcome aboard Liam Duggan. Like others have said it seems a Simpsonesque pick. The kid is real captaincy material but
Great post! Much appreciated
Good to see your excited about something
Read the Lamb thread, you turnip. I'm a big fan of that pick.
I posted this before reading your review on Lamb, my apologies for not researching every post you have ever written for fear of slitting my wrists at the continuously positive posts I have read from you over the years (bar the one on lamb).
That's okay, you made a mistake and i forgive you.
