I think we have players that clubs would want, But there to important for us to trade away.
-
LIVE: Sydney Swans vs GWS Giants - 3:20PM Sat - 1st QF
Squiggle tips Swans at 63% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
LIVE: Brisbane Lions vs Carlton - 7:30PM Sat - 1st EF
Squiggle tips Lions at 73% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 2 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Who would you trade for the Eagles 1st Round pick?
- Thread starter silver_and_sand
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I think we have players that clubs would want, But there to important for us to trade away.
- Banned
- #28
Agreed.
Who said that his top 5 or 6 rated players are the ones that are going to go top 5 or 6.
100% of the time he has been drafting for Crows - they haven't.
And yes, Jacky for pick 6. Done.
The only problem I see is that we're getting a bit short changed. You'd imagine they'd have to chuck in possibly a 3rd.Agreed.
Who said that his top 5 or 6 rated players are the ones that are going to go top 5 or 6.
100% of the time he has been drafting for Crows - they haven't.
And yes, Jacky for pick 6. Done.
A promising young Western Australian forward with glowing coaches reviews about to hit his straps for pick 6 in a weak draft?! You're having a lend, right? Not as though we're going to get a better player with pick 6. They'd have to at least throw in one of their young players or a pick to sweeten the deal.
That might offer might go close...
Maybe Josh Kennedy? Considering he's already been asked to leave one club, surely he'd be happy to be forced to leave another for the greater good of the club?
My final offer:
Jacky for Kennedy + pick 6
lol, I missed the previous page where this turned into sarcasm and thought Stabby lost it.
I'd do Jacky and 10 for 6, solves our problem with delistments come years end.
I'd do Jacky and 10 for 6, solves our problem with delistments come years end.
Na deffinately looking for a small forward, Lynch was our FF during our grand final years in 05 and 06. We have Brown, Wilson, Kennedy and Notte as developing tall FF/CHF's. We have two very good to decent medium forwards in McKinley and LeCras and Wirra is also a gun medium forward who has at least another year left.
Lynch is also hanging around for another couple of years and can obviously go forward, Naita and Cox can rest forward as well. If anything we have too many tall forwards! what we dont have at all is any small forwards, literally dont have one.
NTRabbit
Brownlow Medallist
Our best crumbing forward is a potential AA back pocket, so no, we don't have anything the Eagles want to trade for.
They're not going to get Rioli either, especially since he tanked his draft interviews to ensure he wouldn't have to leave Melbourne.
Yarran... do the Eagles really want to deal with Carlton again?
They're not going to get Rioli either, especially since he tanked his draft interviews to ensure he wouldn't have to leave Melbourne.
Yarran... do the Eagles really want to deal with Carlton again?
Why wouldnt we??? we got Kennedy, Masten and Notte out of the Judd deal and all of those three are going to range from good to great players int he future. Kennedy is 100% better then he was at Carlton, Masten is fantastic and Notte has a fair amount of potential.
Without the Judd deal we would end up being a middle range team making finals but never in contention to actually challenge for a flag for the next 5 years.
No one from the WC coaching staff have actually mentioned anyone currently on a list, the Rioli/Yarran was purely BF.
Without the Judd deal we would end up being a middle range team making finals but never in contention to actually challenge for a flag for the next 5 years.
No one from the WC coaching staff have actually mentioned anyone currently on a list, the Rioli/Yarran was purely BF.
NTRabbit
Brownlow Medallist
I momentarily confused the Western teams opinions of Carlton at the trade table, my bad.
It's all media hyperbole anyway, they're really hard up for a juicy trade story given that most of the GC targets have resisted the temptation and extended their current deals.
It's all media hyperbole anyway, they're really hard up for a juicy trade story given that most of the GC targets have resisted the temptation and extended their current deals.
replace Waters with Hurn and its done!
Haha silly season is starting early
The standard, 'throw away our trash to receive treasure' trades begin
Take away Waters and West Coast are stil getting robbed
I would consider doing that, but not this year in such a weak draft. Maybe last year when it could have got us Rich.
Josh Kennedy, Brown, Wilson, Notte ?? Plus Lynch and Natainui can go forward. Tony Notte will be a gun marking forward.
The coaching staff believe that Le Cras is good enough to play midfield so it is a crumbing small forward that we are after, and preferably a homesick West Aussie. Yarran looms as the obvious candidate - some of the stuff he and Natainui combined with for Swan Districts last year in the WAFL was pretty amazing so would be glad to get him.
I'd forgotten about a few of them. Most of them are still fairly young and still establishing themselves. Are you telling me that you wouldn't jump at the opportunity to nab a star KPP if you had the chance? Who wouldn't?
That said, the common consensus seems to be that you're chasing a small forward and that my original thoughts were in error.
That said, the common consensus seems to be that you're chasing a small forward and that my original thoughts were in error.
None.
The only player I would consider is Griffin and they dont need a ruck.
Maybe Griff to Freo, if Sandilands goes to Victoria and we get Freo's pick???
The only player I would consider is Griffin and they dont need a ruck.
Maybe Griff to Freo, if Sandilands goes to Victoria and we get Freo's pick???
this may have been covered off but the newspaper has us interested in Mark Seaby.... WTF?
Similar threads
