Why do you hate Collingwood?

[ShirtFronter]

With crap players like Prestigiacombo, Thomas, Anthony, Cloke, Maxwell.
How could you like them.
And now your midfield coaches are O'Bree and Caracella - I can't stop laughing

Maybe you should bring in Romano Negri as your ruck coach too

 

[King_Brogan]

hey! presti is a club legend! didnt he play full back in the 90' premiership team

 

[ShirtFronter]

hey! presti is a club legend! didnt he play full back in the 90' premiership team

He must be on the pension now surely.
If he wasn't there in 90, then he is surely the greatest player ever to miss a premiership.

 

[sherb]

I am almost ashamed to say I don't hate Collingwood.

 

[Donakebab]

Because it's Collingwood.

 

[King_Brogan]

He must be on the pension now surely.
If he wasn't there in 90, then he is surely the greatest player ever to miss a premiership.

he is doing well for a bloke with no leg speed, poor overhead, being unable to read the play at all and a poor kick to boot..... he either gives eddie head or is related to mick malthouse....... hang on who is the father of christie malthouse's baby? Im looking straight at you presti

 

[THATSGOLD]

thats why Mark Williams wanted presti at port!

 

[invinciBlues]

One thing I don't understand is people who like to cut off history when they see fit. I like history, and the past, and the way people thought and acted. History as far back as a few years. And I don't understand why history becomes redundant. It's almost like saying, right, we only count flags from the past 50-years, so, in 2009, the 1959 GF is the start of the process, and next year, it is cut from relevance.

Bang on the money

 

[THATSGOLD]

You can't label club culture.. Every individual player is different every supporter is different! Ie. Leigh Montanga!

 

[ShirtFronter]

thats why Mark Williams wanted presti at port!

Lucky they didn't. Otherwise they wouldn't have won a premiership

 

[THATSGOLD]

Yeh your right what a burden he would of been you clairvoyant

 

[ShirtFronter]

I could just imagine Presti standing on Lynch in the 2004 GF
Lynch would've kicked about 15 goals

 

[King_Brogan]

 

[THATSGOLD]

15 hey... bigfooty has so much credibility

 

[crownie]

It's more the fans... they really claim Collingwood as being great, but one premiership in 50+ years says otherwise.

agree, the greatest club in Australia mentality and all the players get media recognition and treated like superstars when they are just average players eg. Dale Thomas

 

[ShirtFronter]

Presti

 

[King_Brogan]

contact Goal Defence

 

[crownie]

Jealousy.

of???

 

[crownie]

14 premierships - third on the all time list.

1400 wins - more than any other side, ever.

More finals series than any other side.

I'd say that's more successful than almost every other side. Don't give me this 1in50 stuff, yes, it's true, and it's not good, we can't shy away from that, BUT, over the journey, it's still more than nearly every other side. It's as many as StK have won, ever, and WB have won since 1925.

back when the comp was not a even playing field and you had the most money, thats a disgrace.

 

[unstable punt]

A simple question, but the answers it evokes may not be simple. It's just always intriguing to hear from supporters of every club, every week 'we hate your mob', and to hear it with such passion and vigour means it ain't just a throw away line. Would just be interesting to hear. Hopefully it's not as basic as 'your fans are feral' - what makes us feral? Any experiences, or just going on popular opinion?

One for sides such as the Crows/Dockers/Eagles (though we have some recent finals history with the Eagles), if you hate us, why? It's not like we have any real history with you - how can you hate what you don't have much history with? Enlighten me.

SOME of their supporters are toerags

 

[my name was taken]

The supporters is why. You can see a few of them on here right now.

A question posted by a collingwood supporter on the main board, and the others respond by trolling the other clubs that are answering. They are giving answers to the question asked, they arn't trolling your club. This superiority complex is why I hate them, actually change that to some of them because I know not all are bad as I also know not all Saints fans are good. Plus the fact that most their supporters ride the coattails of success from an era that they were not even alive for.

And yes before you answer, Im well aware of St Kildas history....

 

[Rioli magic]

I don't hate Collingwood the team, it's just all the other bullshit that comes with it. The false bravado, the supiorority complex, media beat ups, eddie everywhere etc. Half of it is not your fault it's just an easy and popular thing to hate collingwood. I only hate you when you play us like every other team. I hate other clubs more than Collingwood.

 

[The Exorcist]

One thing I don't understand is people who like to cut off history when they see fit. I like history, and the past, and the way people thought and acted. History as far back as a few years. And I don't understand why history becomes redundant. It's almost like saying, right, we only count flags from the past 50-years, so, in 2009, the 1959 GF is the start of the process, and next year, it is cut from relevance.

Yes, you've won 14 flags, congratulations.

13 of those came pre-1959, and one of those has come since then.

Now, let me tell you about Carlton:

16 flags, 7 since 1969, 3 of which have been against the Pies - to me the Pies rock!

 

[Truetiger]

While i was at the Western Bulldogs vs Collingwood in round 22 this year. I was making general comments about some Collingwood players and how they can improve etc. Then i had this Collingwood female bimbo in front of me start bagging the crap out of me for no reason. Thats fine her big muscle husband that was sitting next to me did not give a damn that she was giving it to me verbally. But as soon as i said to her shut up bitch. Then yeah he acted. He went on and say i challenge you to say it again so i did and another 2-3 times. Seriously Collingwood fans some have a very low iq and a very low knowledge of the game. If you cant go to the footy and hear people say bad things about ur side then dont go if you need to act and act big over it. we were fighting for the full 2nd term lol

 

[krisholio14]

I actually don't hate Collingwood at all.