Prediction Changes v Brizzy in Brizzy (sigh)

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh yeah I watched him too and he wasn’t great. I just like new blood it’s fun.
I agree, but if he gets selected following that performance, I don’t want to hear anyone from the selection committee bleating on about integrity in the selection process.
 
Draper debut looking more and more likely. It can't be for Pearce, no way we'd throw him to the Lions (pardon the pun) on someone like Daniher first up.

Also, clearly he has been next in iine for a few weeks - he was travelling emergency. So his relatively uninspiring game for Peel is somewhat irrelevant, if the selection committee already believed he was next in line.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

When is Jlo going to give Jordan Clark a run on the wing? He can take a contested mark. Lay a tackle. Runs both ways. Can pinpoint a leading target. Loves to hoof a goal on the run, and has a tank. Seems a perfect wingman. What am I missing here?
 
When is Jlo going to give Jordan Clark a run on the wing? He can take a contested mark. Lay a tackle. Runs both ways. Can pinpoint a leading target. Loves to hoof a goal on the run, and has a tank. Seems a perfect wingman. What am I missing here?
He’s not defensive enough to play a JL wing role, it’s okay in the backline but being a responsible winger is a harder job mentally
 
He’s not defensive enough to play a JL wing role, it’s okay in the backline but being a responsible winger is a harder job mentally

It's not like Aish was keeping his opponent in check. Let him kick 3 goals. Both wingers repeatedly left their opponents hanging free outside congestion in the Bulldogs forward line, while Aish and Hughes went into the stoppage to increase numbers around the ball. Woeful tactics and if that's what JL wants from his wings, then he has no idea.

Clark is used to playing in the backline and could be far more accountable (if necessary) than the likes of Hill and Daicos. Having said that, I wouldn't even bother too much with defense and just let him off the leash like those other guys. I believe he has the tools to be an AA level attacking wingman.

I find it so frustrating playing high end creative talent in Young, Clark and Chapman all in defense at once. Maybe rotate 1 or 2 there, but I'd be giving all of them considerable time in the midfield.
 
I agree. I think he is too nervous at the moment down back. Confidence shattered in the Pies final and still struggling.

He is a decent size too at 186cm. Can compete in the air.

Put Walker forward and if he shows something, then maybe look at a Luke Teal for example as a lockdown small defender in the MSD (yes, I know we need forwards/mids, but putting that aside and looking at the issues with Wilson/Walker/Wagner).
if only there was a person just like Walker but had skills at HHF.
 
It's not like Aish was keeping his opponent in check. Let him kick 3 goals. Both wingers repeatedly left their opponents hanging free outside congestion in the Bulldogs forward line, while Aish and Hughes went into the stoppage to increase numbers around the ball. Woeful tactics and if that's what JL wants from his wings, then he has no idea.

Clark is used to playing in the backline and could be far more accountable (if necessary) than the likes of Hill and Daicos. Having said that, I wouldn't even bother too much with defense and just let him off the leash like those other guys. I believe he has the tools to be an AA level attacking wingman.

I find it so frustrating playing high end creative talent in Young, Clark and Chapman all in defense at once. Maybe rotate 1 or 2 there, but I'd be giving all of them considerable time in the midfield.
Oh I agree, I was just trying to explain what I think is Justin’s POV on the issue, Aish is one of his favourites too, he’s been down all season with impunity
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

It's not like Aish was keeping his opponent in check. Let him kick 3 goals. Both wingers repeatedly left their opponents hanging free outside congestion in the Bulldogs forward line, while Aish and Hughes went into the stoppage to increase numbers around the ball. Woeful tactics and if that's what JL wants from his wings, then he has no idea.

Clark is used to playing in the backline and could be far more accountable (if necessary) than the likes of Hill and Daicos. Having said that, I wouldn't even bother too much with defense and just let him off the leash like those other guys. I believe he has the tools to be an AA level attacking wingman.

I find it so frustrating playing high end creative talent in Young, Clark and Chapman all in defense at once. Maybe rotate 1 or 2 there, but I'd be giving all of them considerable time in the midfield.
Young should get CBA's in my opinion. He's hard at it, strong over the contest and the most damaging kick on our list. Too often we "win" clearance with dicky kicks to HFF or a wing. From the same spot Young could be driving us 30m out and giving our forwards a real decent go at it.

On SM-N975F using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
When is Jlo going to give Jordan Clark a run on the wing? He can take a contested mark. Lay a tackle. Runs both ways. Can pinpoint a leading target. Loves to hoof a goal on the run, and has a tank. Seems a perfect wingman. What am I missing here?
Yeah don’t mind that at all. Problem is, he is probably too valuable for JL down back at the minute.
 
is draper a forward or back? I know nothing

He can and basically has played everywhere (196cm athletic type with good skills - played everything from ruck down to wingman) since Colts, but of recent times he has mainly been training and playing this year as a third tall defender in a similar vein to Chapman. With Chapman out I think they have been looking at him for that kind of role, but he also suits as a sub where he can literally pinch hit in any position as required.
 
Yeah I feel bad for the dude if Draper has to debut as a defender against Bris in Bris. Talk about a brutal initiation, my first thought is Anthony Rocca and Zac Dawson. Would be setting him up for serious PTSD.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top