- Aug 9, 2012
- 10,680
- 8,233
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I also rate Brett's draft work highly, he is usually always fairly spot on. He had us taking Billings, Dunstan and Acres in that order before anyone else caught up (besides our recruiting team).
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread
- Thread starter Hayes4PM
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Mcartin looks like a teenage mumford
Periphery
Cancelled
- Jul 25, 2013
- 6,688
- 9,911
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I would prefer we bring Kosi back than go after Jack.
Kosi wont play for frees or sook about everything that doesn't go his way, and unlike Jack, Kosi will take responsibility for his performance. Jack might be able to kick goals but he is deficient in everything else we want in a player.
He also turns 26 this year so I think that he is too old for where we are. 30 in 2018? No thanks!
PSD Gaff pls
I would be very surprised if GWS didn't win more games than us, so from my perspective it is pick 1 or 2.
barkerdaman
Rookie
- Aug 17, 2009
- 30
- 39
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
De goey is a star, goes to my school may I add
- Jul 11, 2013
- 611
- 592
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Phillies
Pick 5....we go Brayshaw tbqh
Pretty keen on McCartin, would love a good old power forward
Persevering Saint
Brownlow Medallist
Give me Wright, I'd say.
- Aug 9, 2012
- 10,680
- 8,233
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I want some Wright2Wright action.
But i won't be disappointed with a bit of Steven2McCartin or even Dunstan2Steven2Goddard
But i won't be disappointed with a bit of Steven2McCartin or even Dunstan2Steven2Goddard
Persevering Saint
Brownlow Medallist
When two Wrights don't make a wrong.
goodie23
Tragic Saint
Veteran
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2023
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2022
St Kilda - James Frawley Player Sponsor 2021
Saints Pledge Contributor
St Kilda - Doulton Langlands Player Sponsor 2020
St Kilda - Robbie Young Player Sponsor 2019
St Kilda - Nathan Freeman Player Sponsor 2018
Wouldn't mind Gaff, especially if we stick it to Wet Toast at the bargaining table.
GWS's O'Rourke former No 2 draft pick, out of contract at the end of this year..
I'd prefer him over Gaff, & with plenty of room in our cap we'd get him in the PSD for nothing..
- Aug 9, 2012
- 10,680
- 8,233
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I'd like O'Rourke also but he hasn't proved anything at AFL level IMO, Gaff has proved a lot more. But that doesn't mean JOK will be the better player.
Interesting that there are so many Saints' connections in the top 11!
Hugh Goddard - cousin of Brendan
Tom Lamb - grandson of Ian Cooper
Jake Lever - brother of Jay
Lachie Weller - brother of Mav
- Aug 9, 2012
- 10,680
- 8,233
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
110% sure Jake and Jay were never related.
JOK can play inside & out, has copped some injuries in his time at GWS..
Dom Tyson has been a great get, after suffering two years of injuries at GWS has really come on for the Dees with a full pre-season..
O'Rourke's form in the NEAFL has been v good..
Pick 2 in the National draft & a former pick 2 through the PSD would be huge for our re-build..
- Thread starter
- #2,670
OUT: MAISTER (Doesn't offer a lot and adds nothing in the long run), TDL (Not up to it I don't think), FISHER (Hamstring will determine whether he stays on beyond this year but it's not looking likely), MINCHINGTON (Hasn't progressed any further from what I've seen)
MAYBE OUT: JONES (Can no longer have him out there turning over the ball and taking up space of a young mid), SIMPKIN (Either needs a trade or he will just be staying in the VFL behind other defenders), SHENTON (Played ok in his last game but needs to be upgraded this year)
IN LIMBO: MILERA (Can play well but has been soft at times and goes missing. His best is good enough though.), STANLEY (He's had a few years now and is starting to put a few games together, if we can get a decent pick though he would be gone), GWILT (Struggling this year, maybe played out of position a bit but is looking slow and not very mobile, needs to pick up), GILBERT (All dependant on his injury and any trade offer, his best is very good but is a bit injury prone), WHITE (Polarising player on here but just hasn't shown much apart from the occasional flash of brilliance, only 2nd year so will probably get another year but needs to improve), SAVAGE (Really disappointing and down on form, not worth trading as this year has been bad, gets another year on the list), MARKWORTH (His career has been defined by his ACL injury, gets another year), PIERCE (Injured this year and the addition of Longer and Holmes is trouble for Pierce. Gets another year but beyond that things aren't looking optimistic for him at the Saints), SIPOSS (He's talented but goes missing and has been lazy, he gets another year in my books but needs some consistency), DUNELL (Will get a run this year at some stage with his form and his future depends on that)
PROBABLY KEEP: ROSS (Tearing it up in the VFL, really good signs for Seb, would only trade if there was a reasonable offer), ROBERTON (Not a great year but has had some injuries, showed enough last year with his rebounding play), WELLER (A cut above VFL just like TC; tagged out opposition best mids and got the ball himself, now just needs to settle at AFL level), LEE (Not a great year for Tom Lee, injury interrupted and hasn't kicked that many goals in the VFL but showed his ability last year), ARMITAGE (He's only in this category as he could be a good trade option), MURDOCH (Struggling to break into the AFL team but it's only his 2nd year, needs a decent chance), SAUNDERS (Was good earlier this year and a chance to hold down the small forward role in the future), RAY (Good in a lot of areas but has brainfades and bad I50's sometimes, if a 2nd rounder was offered by someone take it and run), GEARY (Would trade him if there was a decent offer)
DEFINITELY KEEP: DUNSTAN (Nuff said, taken to AFL like a duck to water, will dominate clearances for us for years to come), BILLINGS (Gun, great kick and strong mark, could be the next Chad Wingard), ACRES (His best is very good and finds time and space when he gets it), TEMPLETON (Season might be over for him but he's shown enough, will be cutting defenders to ribbons in the future), RIEWOLDT (Key pillar of our club; captain, gun and shining light up forward.), DEMPSTER (Unsung hero, almost always beats his man and is a great mark for us), HICKEY (He's arrived this year, developing his forward game as well), LONGER (Showing more and more at the moment after getting a run, really good tapwork, lays tackles, strong presence), STEVEN (Gun mid, excellent kick, great turn of speed and just keeps on going), MONTAGNA (Gun player and a crucial mentor for younger guys), HOLMES (Was always a project player, give him at least another year), NEWNES (Another one who's finally arrived, probably our best in the last game), WEBSTER (Gun, great speed, pressure, second efforts and dat left foot), DELANEY (Been a rock in defence, his work against teams big forwards has been excellent), SCHNEIDER (His best is really good, also think he has a bit to offer Billings/Templeton/Saunders as to the small forward role), WRIGHT (Has shown enough despite a few annoying injuries)
BRUCE (Big fan of Josh, tall and very agile big guy who has done really well so far this year), HAYES (Along with Roo is untouchable, if he wants to stay then he stays), CURREN (TC is a solid AFL level midfielder now).
Tl;dr:
Maister, Fisher, Dennis-Lane, Minchington and probably Jones are all gone at the end of this year IMO.
MAYBE OUT: JONES (Can no longer have him out there turning over the ball and taking up space of a young mid), SIMPKIN (Either needs a trade or he will just be staying in the VFL behind other defenders), SHENTON (Played ok in his last game but needs to be upgraded this year)
IN LIMBO: MILERA (Can play well but has been soft at times and goes missing. His best is good enough though.), STANLEY (He's had a few years now and is starting to put a few games together, if we can get a decent pick though he would be gone), GWILT (Struggling this year, maybe played out of position a bit but is looking slow and not very mobile, needs to pick up), GILBERT (All dependant on his injury and any trade offer, his best is very good but is a bit injury prone), WHITE (Polarising player on here but just hasn't shown much apart from the occasional flash of brilliance, only 2nd year so will probably get another year but needs to improve), SAVAGE (Really disappointing and down on form, not worth trading as this year has been bad, gets another year on the list), MARKWORTH (His career has been defined by his ACL injury, gets another year), PIERCE (Injured this year and the addition of Longer and Holmes is trouble for Pierce. Gets another year but beyond that things aren't looking optimistic for him at the Saints), SIPOSS (He's talented but goes missing and has been lazy, he gets another year in my books but needs some consistency), DUNELL (Will get a run this year at some stage with his form and his future depends on that)
PROBABLY KEEP: ROSS (Tearing it up in the VFL, really good signs for Seb, would only trade if there was a reasonable offer), ROBERTON (Not a great year but has had some injuries, showed enough last year with his rebounding play), WELLER (A cut above VFL just like TC; tagged out opposition best mids and got the ball himself, now just needs to settle at AFL level), LEE (Not a great year for Tom Lee, injury interrupted and hasn't kicked that many goals in the VFL but showed his ability last year), ARMITAGE (He's only in this category as he could be a good trade option), MURDOCH (Struggling to break into the AFL team but it's only his 2nd year, needs a decent chance), SAUNDERS (Was good earlier this year and a chance to hold down the small forward role in the future), RAY (Good in a lot of areas but has brainfades and bad I50's sometimes, if a 2nd rounder was offered by someone take it and run), GEARY (Would trade him if there was a decent offer)
DEFINITELY KEEP: DUNSTAN (Nuff said, taken to AFL like a duck to water, will dominate clearances for us for years to come), BILLINGS (Gun, great kick and strong mark, could be the next Chad Wingard), ACRES (His best is very good and finds time and space when he gets it), TEMPLETON (Season might be over for him but he's shown enough, will be cutting defenders to ribbons in the future), RIEWOLDT (Key pillar of our club; captain, gun and shining light up forward.), DEMPSTER (Unsung hero, almost always beats his man and is a great mark for us), HICKEY (He's arrived this year, developing his forward game as well), LONGER (Showing more and more at the moment after getting a run, really good tapwork, lays tackles, strong presence), STEVEN (Gun mid, excellent kick, great turn of speed and just keeps on going), MONTAGNA (Gun player and a crucial mentor for younger guys), HOLMES (Was always a project player, give him at least another year), NEWNES (Another one who's finally arrived, probably our best in the last game), WEBSTER (Gun, great speed, pressure, second efforts and dat left foot), DELANEY (Been a rock in defence, his work against teams big forwards has been excellent), SCHNEIDER (His best is really good, also think he has a bit to offer Billings/Templeton/Saunders as to the small forward role), WRIGHT (Has shown enough despite a few annoying injuries)
BRUCE (Big fan of Josh, tall and very agile big guy who has done really well so far this year), HAYES (Along with Roo is untouchable, if he wants to stay then he stays), CURREN (TC is a solid AFL level midfielder now).
Tl;dr:
Maister, Fisher, Dennis-Lane, Minchington and probably Jones are all gone at the end of this year IMO.
Highly doubt the club would trade Geary because he is one of the few in the middle age group with leadership potential.
In that case I've found some more...
Peter Wright - identical twin brother of Nathan
and... Clem Smith - youngest of the Smith brothers (Jesse and Alistair)...
I'll get me coat...
- Aug 9, 2012
- 10,680
- 8,233
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
And like Gwilt he is a Free Agent.
goodie23
Tragic Saint
Veteran
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2023
St Kilda - Marcus Windhager Player Sponsor 2022
St Kilda - James Frawley Player Sponsor 2021
Saints Pledge Contributor
St Kilda - Doulton Langlands Player Sponsor 2020
St Kilda - Robbie Young Player Sponsor 2019
St Kilda - Nathan Freeman Player Sponsor 2018
Plus the sad probability that Sir Lenny will retire
- Aug 25, 2012
- 8,098
- 9,629
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Think Jake and Jay are cousins.
- Status
Similar threads
