List Mgmt. 2017 Trade & FA Targets Part 1

[cooperrules]

Please tell me nobody else has heard we are looking at acquiring Daisy Thomas?

If we are I seriously question this clubs f'n direction..

Well hes better than dunstan.

 

[Rors]

**** no.

Buckley, maybe, I don't know him well enough but I don't want Harvey anywhere near the coaching of our team. He has left every midfield he has coached in worse shape that when he arrived.

That's way harsh. Pendles, Treloar & Adams have absolutely grown as players & excelled under his watch.

 

[L_W_P]

That's way harsh. Pendles, Treloar & Adams have absolutely grown as players & excelled under his watch.

Pendles and Treloar were stars before Harvey got there. Adams I will give you somewhat but his numbers have gone up due to and increased game time spent at half back, sweeping for the first handball.

Am I overstating Harves impact? Probably. But I am adamant that he is not a good coach and I wouldn't want him at the club in that role. Purely my opinion of course. I'd much rather go after a guy like Ratten or Camporeale if we want another senior assistant.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Well hes better than dunstan.

Thats a lie.

 

[VDS66]

Clubs can get tired of waiting for the center piece to re-sign and end up moving on and re-signing those around him

Walters was contracted next year but they moved to extend him. Mundy is pretty old you can do that when ever

The other thing could be they know what will get fyfe to re-signing and they're shoring up the others now

And?

 

[StCicatriz]

And?

there is no and

 

[Mikka84]

**** no.

Buckley, maybe, I don't know him well enough but I don't want Harvey anywhere near the coaching of our team. He has left every midfield he has coached in worse shape that when he arrived.

Harsh!

 

[bird_man]

And?

Basically what he's trying to say is, it could mean Fyfe is closer to signing, or that Fyfe is further from signing, or it could mean nothing...

 

[Mstr Strokesman]

Are you still writing stuff to prove your lack of footy knowledge. Mate you don't need to do it anymore. It was confirmed long ago.

Harsh Plug.

 

[Glen Buterol]

Harsh Plug.

Harsh plug? Is that like a ribbed butt plug?

 

[VDS66]

there is no and

So?

 

[Smoke_Me_AKipper]

I'm not sure I can wait for 6 months of will he or won't he sign, (insert Fyfe, Martin, Kelly or Hopper here).

I would say if someone hasnt signed by July then they're going, (always exceptions but generally they're gone)

 

[Joffaboy]

Harsh Plug.

But fair and absolutely true.

 

[Persevering Saint]

So?

I know you are, but what am I?

 

[SK_MD_#7]

At least two Victorian clubs are keeping "close tabs" on Sydney youngster Zak Jones, says Mitch Cleary.

The young Swan is out-of-contract at the end of the season and could attract plenty of interest, given his strong start to the year.


"North Melbourne and St Kilda are the two clubs that I've heard are keeping very close tabs on Zak Jones," Cleary said on Sportsday.

"He was of their best in last year's grand final and is averaging 21 touches this year."

http://m.3aw.com.au/news/st-kilda-a...ngster-says-mitch-cleary-20170426-gvt7in.html

 

[STK2020]

Just a thought ....
I reckon if Roo & Joey sign for another year ,
We have landed a big fish .
If no extensions i reckon we will be loading up on kids this draft .

 

[PaddysurDaddy]

Ah yes, Christian Petracca the midfielder

I'm sure I'll cop a ban for this, but its worth it. Cheerio.

be honest.

Petracca or dunstan, who would you prefer?

 

[Tulip]

be honest.

Petracca or dunstan, who would you prefer?

Petracca all day. I didn't mean to make a big thing earlier, but Petracca's a forward. FWIW he hurt himself early on Monday and may not play this week. His knee was strapped heavily and he was parked on half forward - easy to see why people think he was downhill skiing, because he had to stay on after we lost Smith and Spencer. Dunstan is going to play 200 games for you, and will be even more effective if the work load is reduced and you can just stick him at the stoppages and let him go through guys. Can drift forward and take a mark too, just needs to work on converting those chances. I'm a fan.

 

[Masquerade]

Petracca all day. I didn't mean to make a big thing earlier, but Petracca's a forward. FWIW he hurt himself early on Monday and may not play this week. His knee was strapped heavily and he was parked on half forward - easy to see why people think he was downhill skiing, because he had to stay on after we lost Smith and Spencer. Dunstan is going to play 200 games for you, and will be even more effective if the work load is reduced and you can just stick him at the stoppages and let him go through guys. Can drift forward and take a mark too, just needs to work on converting those chances. I'm a fan.

 

[PaddysurDaddy]

Petracca all day. I didn't mean to make a big thing earlier, but Petracca's a forward. FWIW he hurt himself early on Monday and may not play this week. His knee was strapped heavily and he was parked on half forward - easy to see why people think he was downhill skiing, because he had to stay on after we lost Smith and Spencer. Dunstan is going to play 200 games for you, and will be even more effective if the work load is reduced and you can just stick him at the stoppages and let him go through guys. Can drift forward and take a mark too, just needs to work on converting those chances. I'm a fan.

dunstan is barely in the 22 i was trolling

 

[Joffaboy]

I would certainly Prefer Petracca over Dunstan however we didnt have the option.
The only argument would be Petracca over McCartin and the jury will be out in that for a few seasons

 

[STK2020]

I would certainly Prefer Petracca over Dunstan however we didnt have the option.
The only argument would be Petracca over McCartin and the jury will be out in that for a few seasons

 

[burningdwarf]

At least two Victorian clubs are keeping "close tabs" on Sydney youngster Zak Jones, says Mitch Cleary.

The young Swan is out-of-contract at the end of the season and could attract plenty of interest, given his strong start to the year.


"North Melbourne and St Kilda are the two clubs that I've heard are keeping very close tabs on Zak Jones," Cleary said on Sportsday.

"He was of their best in last year's grand final and is averaging 21 touches this year."

http://m.3aw.com.au/news/st-kilda-a...ngster-says-mitch-cleary-20170426-gvt7in.html

Awwwww yis.

 

[Rors]

I would certainly Prefer Petracca over Dunstan however we didnt have the option.
The only argument would be Petracca over McCartin and the jury will be out in that for a few seasons

Pffft. That's not how it works Joff. Paddy is a fail, Billings is a fail, Gresham is a fail.

None of them look to be as good as Chris Judd winning a Brownlow in his 3rd season.

Delist them all

 

[Rors]

At least two Victorian clubs are keeping "close tabs" on Sydney youngster Zak Jones, says Mitch Cleary.

The young Swan is out-of-contract at the end of the season and could attract plenty of interest, given his strong start to the year.


"North Melbourne and St Kilda are the two clubs that I've heard are keeping very close tabs on Zak Jones," Cleary said on Sportsday.

"He was of their best in last year's grand final and is averaging 21 touches this year."

http://m.3aw.com.au/news/st-kilda-a...ngster-says-mitch-cleary-20170426-gvt7in.html

Do we need another Half back flanker type who's terrible by foot?

Honestly, I could see him taking over Sav's position as he's got good pace, but he'd need to work on his kicking

If we could turn him into a midfielder like his brother, I'd be keen, but again his ceiling would be pretty low