List Mgmt. 2021 Mid-Season Draft

In the 2021 MSD, Carlton should select...

  • Charlie McKay (F/S)

    Votes: 10 8.3%
  • Dominic Akuei (NGA)

    Votes: 9 7.5%
  • Best available mature age player

    Votes: 49 40.8%
  • Best available U19 (overlooked in last year's draft)

    Votes: 41 34.2%
  • Other - Specify

    Votes: 11 9.2%

  • Total voters
    120

Remove this Banner Ad

Betts, Levi and Murphy are decent chances to retire, we're probably going to trade two or three out, and I don't see the point in retaining all of Gibbons, Newnes or Newman, so I'd expect at least two to go.

That's likely 8 names right there, and that's without any discussion of list size changes now that things have rebounded.

EDIT: completely forgot about Kennedy and OMac: they're gone too. I'd also look at moving on from Pittonet if he's out of contract.

Until our younger players take the next step and or show more consistency, I would be surprised if the likes of Newnes, Gibbons, Newman come off the list, especially with Betts and Murphy most likely retiring

OMAC and Pitto will stay as cover given how thin we are with talls
 
Until our younger players take the next step and or show more consistency, I would be surprised if the likes of Newnes, Gibbons, Newman come off the list, especially with Betts and Murphy most likely retiring

OMAC and Pitto will stay as cover given how thin we are with talls
Newnes is done , we milked the last few games of his career but if we are too improve from here Newnes can't be playing in the seniors . Just my opinion anyway .
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Why have you become the forum gatekeeper all of a sudden? You never used to be like that.
It was intended as a joke and an observation, but I'll be honest: I misread the comment and thought I was posting in the R11 pre-match thread. :p
 
He did very well, again has been one of the best players for the Dragons as has Tom Silvagni for the Chargers, I think we will have those two boys wrapped up as Father Sons in this National Draft as Midfielders and damn good ones, McKay as a rotating defender/midfielder and Tom as a Forward/Midfielder. They would be two great pic ups so Austin should really focus on getting the best possible tall mobile player in this draft.

Have either nominated for the mid season draft? I’m excited at the prospect of getting some father sons this year.
 
LTI - McDonald, Marchbank & Cuningham..
You only have to give MSD players 6 or 18 month contracts...

That's why I said take 3 picks for 6 month contract to cover injuries or for extra VFL depth..
If they perform, offer them another contract as they are already on our list, if not move them on...

Clearing 9 spots wouldn't be easy (Bolded Blue= Rookie)
The below would give us 9 list spots and 1 Rookie spot... Only if you absolutely had to

Retire - Murphy, Betts & Casboult
Trade - SPS :thumbsdownv1: Dow, Setterfield
Trade/Delist - McDonald, O'Brian, Kennedy, Newnes, Williamson

Delist & Rookie - Marchbank & Cuningham (Delist to rookie spot (still get paid the same)

Upgrade - Owies

Also another issue we have is, what are we going to do with Father Sons & NGA players this year?

Father Son Academy,
Dane Whitnall, Charlie McKay, Tom Silvagni, Thomas Gleeson & Mackenzie Hogg... + Ben Silvagni (BOG again today for the Bullants)

NGA
Dominic Akuei
Great for Ben silvagni -- hope he keeps improving and makes it -- with our lack of talls and excess of averaged developing mids I was surprised we flicked him drafted fogarty and kept Kennedy on a rookie list ..
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

LTI - McDonald, Marchbank & Cuningham..
You only have to give MSD players 6 or 18 month contracts...

That's why I said take 3 picks for 6 month contract to cover injuries or for extra VFL depth..
If they perform, offer them another contract as they are already on our list, if not move them on...

Clearing 9 spots wouldn't be easy (Bolded Blue= Rookie)
The below would give us 9 list spots and 1 Rookie spot... Only if you absolutely had to

Retire - Murphy, Betts & Casboult
Trade - SPS :thumbsdownv1: Dow, Setterfield
Trade/Delist - McDonald, O'Brian, Kennedy, Newnes, Williamson

Delist & Rookie - Marchbank & Cuningham (Delist to rookie spot (still get paid the same)

Upgrade - Owies

Also another issue we have is, what are we going to do with Father Sons & NGA players this year?

Father Son Academy,
Dane Whitnall, Charlie McKay, Tom Silvagni, Thomas Gleeson & Mackenzie Hogg... + Ben Silvagni (BOG again today for the Bullants)

NGA
Dominic Akuei

I doubt if Ben's coming back
 
LTI - McDonald, Marchbank & Cuningham..
You only have to give MSD players 6 or 18 month contracts...

That's why I said take 3 picks for 6 month contract to cover injuries or for extra VFL depth..
If they perform, offer them another contract as they are already on our list, if not move them on...

Clearing 9 spots wouldn't be easy (Bolded Blue= Rookie)
The below would give us 9 list spots and 1 Rookie spot... Only if you absolutely had to

Retire - Murphy, Betts & Casboult
Trade - SPS :thumbsdownv1: Dow, Setterfield
Trade/Delist - McDonald, O'Brian, Kennedy, Newnes, Williamson

Delist & Rookie - Marchbank & Cuningham (Delist to rookie spot (still get paid the same)

Upgrade - Owies

Also another issue we have is, what are we going to do with Father Sons & NGA players this year?

Father Son Academy,
Dane Whitnall, Charlie McKay, Tom Silvagni, Thomas Gleeson & Mackenzie Hogg... + Ben Silvagni (BOG again today for the Bullants)

NGA
Dominic Akuei
Pretty sure I read last week anyone taken in the mid season draft will be on a guaranteed 18 month contract .
 
I see Mirkov hasn't played today in the VFL (lucky for him).
Does that mean we've decided to stop hiding him in plain sight? 😆
Big Project player
Until our younger players take the next step and or show more consistency, I would be surprised if the likes of Newnes, Gibbons, Newman come off the list, especially with Betts and Murphy most likely retiring

OMAC and Pitto will stay as cover given how thin we are with talls
Betts and Murphy can choose when there done, big Levi is just a wrecking ball at the moment with a hint of he’s old marking self, he’s just hurting blokes, heart and soul player
 
Big Project player

Betts and Murphy can choose when there done, big Levi is just a wrecking ball at the moment with a hint of he’s old marking self, he’s just hurting blokes, heart and soul player
Newman is definitely not going anywhere I think Gibbons could be traded because he does have currency but Newnes has slowed down and the game has quickly gone past him
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2021 Mid-Season Draft

Back
Top