List Mgmt. 2021 NAB National AFL Draft

Remove this Banner Ad

Phantoms haunt operas, mocks with players that have a number beside them are for rankings. If you rank someone highly ie with a low number and that player doesn't picked at or around that number then you fugged up. That's some real nonsense, this is where KM rates them only he doesn't really rate them, what a cop out!
Seems to me you don’t quite grasp the concept of a phantom draft.
 
Seems to me you can't judge talent, after their bigfooty pump up I look forward to Bohdi and Schlong featuring prominently at the top of the draft.
Lol, mate, what are you talking about? You clearly do not understand what a phantom draft is!

It's a mock draft, in any other words. There is a very clear distinction between someone's personal rankings of a prospect and where they think players will be taken. Mock drafts involve people putting the cap of other teams on, trying to foresee what they'll do. The personal rankings of such a person don't matter that much, especially if someone rates a dark-horse very highly.

Just because KM rates left-field guys highly doesn't at all mean he should expect them to be drafted early.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

What's the point of rating players then?. If you don't think Bohdi Uwland is a top 10 then don't put him in your top 10, same with Schlensog. Couple of Barry Crocker assessments in the final analysis.
Phantom draft = what you think will happen, based on variables like club needs, media reports etc.

Power rankings = personal ratings of players, that may not necessarily align with what happens on draft night

Is it really that difficult to grasp?
 
Phantom draft = what you think will happen, based on variables like club needs, media reports etc.

Power rankings = personal ratings of players, that may not necessarily align with what happens on draft night

Is it really that difficult to grasp?
It's doing my fn head in!
 
Madge is an ugly playing footballer but he was used to plug one of the truly gaping holes in the train wreck that was our backline in the '18 season and he played his role right through to the GF.

Think about that a bit before you empty the sht can over the lads head - he was one kick away from being a premiership player and some good judges are convinced we did not get a fair shake in that game.

Always gives his all and it's not his fault that he keeps getting selected when it's an indictment on selection and recruitment that he hasn't been forced out of the team.

Point the finger of blame where it belongs.
Get your facts right before coming off the Thommo long run. Never played.
 
Phantom draft = what you think will happen, based on variables like club needs, media reports etc.

Power rankings = personal ratings of players, that may not necessarily align with what happens on draft night

Is it really that difficult to grasp?
What is the point of ranking a player highly and then him not getting picked up by an AFL Club?
Phantom draft = what you think will happen, based on variables like club needs, media reports etc.

Power rankings = personal ratings of players, that may not necessarily align with what happens on draft night

Is it really that difficult to grasp?
Bigfooty at its finest! I rank this guy highly but AFL teams won't, hilarious! Funny how these mocks fall into line with rankings provided by Cal Twomey who actually know what they're on about. I've never heard of or seen 'power rankings' in any sport the featured the disclaimer not necessarily in the order that I have them, its always first to worst unless you're making excuses for KM. The guy does a great job of cutting and pasting better judges opinions.
 
What is the point of ranking a player highly and then him not getting picked up by an AFL Club?

Bigfooty at its finest! I rank this guy highly but AFL teams won't, hilarious! Funny how these mocks fall into line with rankings provided by Cal Twomey who actually know what they're on about. I've never heard of or seen 'power rankings' in any sport the featured the disclaimer not necessarily in the order that I have them, its always first to worst unless you're making excuses for KM. The guy does a great job of cutting and pasting better judges opinions.
Then I'd suggest you pay little to no attention. Take the loss and move on, you're just digging yourself a deeper hole
 
What is the point of ranking a player highly and then him not getting picked up by an AFL Club?

Bigfooty at its finest! I rank this guy highly but AFL teams won't, hilarious! Funny how these mocks fall into line with rankings provided by Cal Twomey who actually know what they're on about. I've never heard of or seen 'power rankings' in any sport the featured the disclaimer not necessarily in the order that I have them, its always first to worst unless you're making excuses for KM. The guy does a great job of cutting and pasting better judges opinions.
He does a phantom draft where he tries to predict the order of the draft. And something he calls "power rankings". Silly name, but it's how he rates them himself and usually contains a few he knows clubs aren't interested in.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Blake Howes is one I would be interested in Might go as high as early 20”s but could slide to third round

190cm super athletic utility who can play half forward, wing, half back or even pinch hit out of goal square ala Stevo
 
What about this bloke or his half brother Dimple Grants?

Kudos to his parents, Grouse!!


Hmm reminds me of an episode of Yes Minister.
 
While Collingwood now has enough points to match any bid on Daicos – they hold Picks 36, 38, 40, 46, 48, 55 and 58 – it’s still looking to add teenage talent to its list, with the club expected to use three to four picks to take players at the draft. One of those players could be 174cm utility and Next Generation Academy prospect Youseph Dib, who looms as a later pick.

 
Looks a ripper. Where's he expected to go?
I have always thought he would be a top 10 pick, if he goes outside top 10 then lucky the team who get's him. I think he is better than some of the players who are rated above him, pick 8 for me, he's a gun
 
Heard Sam Banger Banks on SEN this morning. Sounds like a ripper. Shifter Sheahan says he is the best kick in the draft. He is a 187 rebounding half back who thinks his game is similar in style to Jaidyn Short
Would be a good fit for us if he slides in to 40”s

Big fan. Just had a horrible year with injury this year though.

Seems like he could be a great leader and culture builder in the future too. Bit of Bob Murphy around the way he plays in my opinion.

 
We should be recruiting mega fans of Collingwood. If they're talented enough, of course. Look at Trenna, he was the biggest Collingwood fan growing up. Comes to Collingwood to live out a dream. Provided they are talented and they get opportunity, fans are some of the best recruits. Less likely to leave as they love the club, idolise the senior players, etc.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2021 NAB National AFL Draft

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top