List Mgmt. 2022 Trade Thread - Part II

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Still no mention of NWM going anywhere. I'm thinking BS!!!!


But then again they say we will have to offload players to get draft picks to pay for De Goey.
Only if the Pies match, which I don't think they will. They've been burnt on Grundy, so they likely won't offer him more than 2 years. That's if they match what St Kilda seems willing to pay for him.

I think in Degoeys ideal world, he wants to stay at the Pies. But our offer could be too good to pass up.

I just read the article, and I think you've read it wrong. I think what they're trying to say is if we bring in Degoey, we might want to trade a player or two away who me might not need (ie Zak Jones) to take to the draft.
 
I know this has been said before, but will reiterate
There are no real ITK's, just people who may know one or two at the club, that may tell them what they think
Others my have friends or golfing buddies, or running partners who have contacts.

What most do is relay what they know to be fact at the time. Lots of stuff would be told in confidence and not put out publicly

It keeps the forum alive for discussion, after all the time they have been bagged for info, I don't, think they are looking for kudo's.
Anyway carry on. Most whispers never come to fruition.
I am still waiting on Kelly and Heeney to arrive.


Except for Gubby88 who is Gubby Allen. ;)
 
Still no mention of NWM going anywhere. I'm thinking BS!!!!


But then again they say we will have to offload players to get draft picks to pay for De Goey.


How the **** is Lachie Scholl on the table. He looked like one of their most promising players and how can old rubber cap Carlton be his destination?
 
Only if the Pies match, which I don't think they will. They've been burnt on Grundy, so they likely won't offer him more than 2 years. That's if they match what St Kilda seems willing to pay for him.

I think in Degoeys ideal world, he wants to stay at the Pies. But our offer could be too good to pass up.

I just read the article, and I think you've read it wrong. I think what they're trying to say is if we bring in Degoey, we might want to trade a player or two away who me might not need (ie Zak Jones) to take to the draft.
Our offer must be that its extra $'s because no draft picks are involved. If the Pies match then its no go.

Yeah - you might be right about trading out similar types.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Only if the Pies match, which I don't think they will. They've been burnt on Grundy, so they likely won't offer him more than 2 years. That's if they match what St Kilda seems willing to pay for him.

I think in Degoeys ideal world, he wants to stay at the Pies. But our offer could be too good to pass up.

I just read the article, and I think you've read it wrong. I think what they're trying to say is if we bring in Degoey, we might want to trade a player or two away who me might not need (ie Zak Jones) to take to the draft.
If they matched then he'd just stay there. It seems at the moment their offer is well under ours. Either he'll sign their offer or sign ours but there's no way we'll trade for him I don't think.
 
Instead of going to for shitkickers playing in the reserves of other teams, why don’t we do a Demons & trade next yrs 1st pick into this yr for another top 10 pick?

From memory, Dees have done it twice for Oliver/Weideman, then Jackson/Pickett

If Hill leaves for Norf with the highly rumoured end of 1st Rd pick coming to us for him, that’s 2 top 10 picks & 2 picks in the 20s… 🤔

Then just hit the draft & take 1-2 free agents
I’d do it in an instant. A good way to fast track things.
 
If they matched then he'd just stay there. It seems at the moment their offer is well under ours. Either he'll sign their offer or sign ours but there's no way we'll trade for him I don't think.
Agree.
The fact that he’s a FA ( just like Crouch who we refused to trade for - to the Crows’ fans utter chagrin) is why we’re chasing him.

No chance we’ll trade for him.
 
Still no mention of NWM going anywhere. I'm thinking BS!!!!


But then again they say we will have to offload players to get draft picks to pay for De Goey.
I’ve said it on here he is looking to get back at end of next or quite possibly end of this year to south Australia. Also said Byrnes and Bytel looking for new homes. Byrnes not many takers so far.
 
Agree.
The fact that he’s a FA ( just like Crouch who we refused to trade for - to the Crows’ fans utter chagrin) is why we’re chasing him.

No chance we’ll trade for him.


The pies can't afford to go too high so can't play chicken and put up a matched offer.
 
Reckon after we sort out the Dunstan coup, lets put the feelers out to Hind, McCartin, Longer and Hickey too.


Jokes aside, a few of those blokes are doing ok. Hind can **** off, seeing his interaction on the bench with Rutten makes me think he’s a bit of w***er. McCartin would probably get a game with us at the moment. Hickey’s first half of the season and last year we’re pretty good.

As unrealistic as it is, if either of McCartin or Hickey wanted back to the club and it was for peanuts, I’d say yes.
 
Sounds like because he doesn’t take it seriously and the players are pissed off with him. The way we play looks divided this year. Makes some sense.
If true, I like the fact that the players are not happy with someone not fully invested. Time to let him go - don’t need that attitude at the club.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top