List Mgmt. 2023 List Management thread

[Snuffaluphagus]

Mod notice after Mr Bob did a lot of annoying work in moving days of posts out of here. As we are heading into offseason, this thread is for 2023 list management only. Getting upset on previous trades can be taken to the vent thread. Lets keep this thread on track in the part of the year it's actually relevant

 

[DragoDelph]

I would say Dogga's best friend is Ruscoe and his second best friend is Ruscoe's mum. If Freo want him, it'd be a thing

So stable pony. Gotcha

 

[Swiggy]

He's a HB now? Didn't he debut forward?

Playing down back for pies VFL and when he plays AFL

 

[Joao]

Playing down back for pies VFL and when he plays AFL

Well I have to say, its very hard to get excited about a fringe half back.

 

[Swiggy]

Well I have to say, its very hard to get excited about a fringe half back.

He’d play AFL at most clubs I’d say, pretty tough side to crack into ATM

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

He’d play AFL at most clubs I’d say, pretty tough side to crack into ATM

The Pies supporters opinions on him arent flash going off their board. I think you might be right and there's possibly something there but it's not someone I'm going to be overly excited about and the list position is going to be a hard one...

 

[Swiggy]

The Pies supporters opinions on him arent flash going off their board. I think you might be right and there's possibly something there but it's not someone I'm going to be overly excited about and the list position is going to be a hard one...

Need to find way to improve the list. I’m more looking at him to replace Hughes down back & let chapman move up the ground

 

[Couch Coach]

The Pies supporters opinions on him arent flash going off their board. I think you might be right and there's possibly something there but it's not someone I'm going to be overly excited about and the list position is going to be a hard one...

FWIW Ruscoe is a great clubman and is a step above VFL.
His best possition is 3rd tall defender and is fighting with Howe and Murphy to get games with us.
He could be a solid AFL player at the right club (not a star) but play his role.
The knock on him is closing speed and overhead ability (which he is improving in the VFL).
Just my thoughts FYI.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

FWIW Ruscoe is a great clubman and is a step above VFL.
His best possition is 3rd tall defender and is fighting with Howe and Murphy to get games with us.
He could be a solid AFL player at the right club (not a star) but play his role.
The knock on him is closing speed and overhead ability (which he is improving in the VFL).
Just my thoughts FYI.

So he's playing really well at VFL? My interest would be piqued if that's the case. I dont have any knock on him not being in your best 22 obviously when your team (and particularly the backline) is incredible. Sounds like a decent way to effectively make Hughes 10 years younger

 

[Taylor]

Sounds like a decent way to effectively make Hughes 10 years younger

And bigger. Trey is eye to eye with Pavlich.

 

[KinderSmock]

FWIW Ruscoe is a great clubman and is a step above VFL.
His best possition is 3rd tall defender and is fighting with Howe and Murphy to get games with us.
He could be a solid AFL player at the right club (not a star) but play his role.
The knock on him is closing speed and overhead ability (which he is improving in the VFL).
Just my thoughts FYI.

He's got class. There have been a couple of times that an opposition player has got injured and he's been there to make sure they're okay. Did it as a rookie, too.

 

[freo_leo29]

He's a HB now? Didn't he debut forward?

He was average forward so got moved back


He is also average back


Think he's more of a club culture pick kind of guy, like a Sheridan


I'd take him if he got us schleicher in AFLW tho lol

 

[Swiggy]

Has Zac Fisher

16

Zac Fisher

Age

26

Ht

175cm

Wt

76kg

Pos.

D/F

Career

Season

Last 5

D

16.2

4star

K

8.3

3star

HB

7.9

5star

M

1.8

2star

T

3.0

5star

MG

384.0

5star

D

17.0

4star

K

10.0

4star

HB

7.0

4star

M

3.0

3star

T

0.0

1star

MG

384.0

5star

D

12.2

3star

K

6.8

3star

HB

5.4

4star

M

1.2

2star

T

3.0

5star

been linked?

Ginnivan would fit a need but freo would never go for him

 

[DragoDelph]

Has Zac Fisher been linked?

Ginnivan would fit a need but freo would never go for him

The fish has been linked to WC, also wouldn't surprise if he went to a different Melbourne club.
C'wood head of recruiting pretty much shut down any move for Ginny on Gettable, so any noise has disappeared for now.

 

[DragoDelph]

Category	Name	Notes	Value	Current Status
IN	Dyson Heppell	Is this the year? The year the true Johnny Docker returns? Yes, yes it is.	Free Agent	GUARANTEED
IN	Aaron Naughton	Look, we know it 'aint happening. But it could. It won't. But it might...	2x Firsts	PIPE DREAM
IN	Logan McDonald	IF Sydney go after Naughton & Barrass... THEN something has to give. Right?	First + Second	UNLIKELY
IN	Tyler Brockman	Yet to sign at Hawthorn, has been linked to WC, though nothing concrete yet.	20-35	POSSIBLE
IN	Sam Flanders	OOC at GC, more than likely will end up in Vic. Link to Serong, tenuous at best.	25-35	UNLIKELY
IN	Mystery Forward	Have been linked to a mystery forward player. 195cm. Potentially one of those above, potentially someone else. The mystery continues.	?
IN	Jeremy Sharp	Now OOC at the suns, maybe has the shits and will go to WC, maybe not.	R4	POSSIBLE
IN	Elliot Yeo	Rumour won't go away. Would have to be cheap, or WC to pay majority of salary. Gives Fyfe a rehab buddy at least.	45-100	UNLIKELY
IN	Brodie Grundy	Could move again, especially to a club who loses a primary ruck (Freo, WBD, Port). Would only be an option if Big Onions bails.	25-50	UNLIKELY
IN	Mitch Georgiades	Still OOC at Port. Could be a good rehab mate for the Kuek-en. Has indicated that he's not interested in WC. If he leaves, expected to go to Vic though	20-30	UNLIKELY
IN	Trey Ruscoe	Culd be a good moneyball option. OOC at C'wood. Also a potential stable pony for Astro. No mention anywhere of a link though.	R3-R4	UNLIKELY
OUT	Brennan Cox	Crows are 2x backmen down for 2024, and missed on Redman. May come harder for Brennan now. Still contracted for next year, so will cost them.	1st + 2nd	UNLIKELY
OUT	Sean Darcy	Noise won't go away, though it's mainly from media know-it-alls with no inside running. Would be shocked if the Prince of Perth left	2x 1sts	UNLIKELY
OUT	Rory Lobb	Dogs are the team unless something changes late. Bell has stated we will hold him to contract. Dogs have offered a second rounder	R1	LIKELY
OUT	Joel Hamling	Still a chance he gets offered a new contract, wouldn't be the worst player to keep around for depth	-	LIKELY
OUT	Neil Erasmus	Word that the toast are into him. Would cost a mint.	6-10	UNLIKELY
OUT	Nathan Wilson	Likely to be delisted	-	LIKELY
OUT	Travis Colyer	Likely to be delisted	-	LIKELY
OUT	Lachie Schultz	Has hit a trigger for 2024. Word is Dogs are interested, and Hawks may come again. Has been offered an increased contract to stay.	25-35	UNLIKELY
OUT	Liam Henry	Here we go again. Linked to WBD & Melbourne currently. Mixed reports from ITK's around staying/going. Seems like Colon and the club are each playing games, so who knows where it really stands.	15-25	POSSIBLE

Spoiler: OPPOSITION WATCH

• Barrass heading to Sydney.
• McKay (the North version) off to the Bombers.
• Parish linked to Geelong.
• Himmelberg?
• Wingard, Fantasia, Gresham all linked to moves elsewhere.
• WC trying to move Ryan, linked to the Hawks.
• TDK likely to stay at Carlton, Silvagni potentially out.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Category	Name	Notes	Value	Current Status
IN	Dyson Heppell	Is this the year? The year the true Johnny Docker returns? Yes, yes it is.	Free Agent	GUARANTEED
IN	Aaron Naughton	Look, we know it 'aint happening. But it could. It won't. But it might...	2x Firsts	PIPE DREAM
IN	Logan McDonald	IF Sydney go after Naughton & Barrass... THEN something has to give. Right?	First + Second	UNLIKELY
IN	Tyler Brockman	Yet to sign at Hawthorn, has been linked to WC, though nothing concrete yet.	20-35	POSSIBLE
IN	Sam Flanders	OOC at GC, more than likely will end up in Vic. Link to Serong, tenuous at best.	25-35	UNLIKELY
IN	Mystery Forward	Have been linked to a mystery forward player. 195cm. Potentially one of those above, potentially someone else. The mystery continues.	?
IN	Jeremy Sharp	Now OOC at the suns, maybe has the shits and will go to WC, maybe not.	R4	POSSIBLE
IN	Elliot Yeo	Rumour won't go away. Would have to be cheap, or WC to pay majority of salary. Gives Fyfe a rehab buddy at least.	45-100	UNLIKELY
IN	Brodie Grundy	Could move again, especially to a club who loses a primary ruck (Freo, WBD, Port). Would only be an option if Big Onions bails.	25-50	UNLIKELY
IN	Mitch Georgiades	Still OOC at Port. Could be a good rehab mate for the Kuek-en. Has indicated that he's not interested in WC. If he leaves, expected to go to Vic though	20-30	UNLIKELY
IN	Trey Ruscoe	Culd be a good moneyball option. OOC at C'wood. Also a potential stable pony for Astro. No mention anywhere of a link though.	R3-R4	UNLIKELY
OUT	Brennan Cox	Crows are 2x backmen down for 2024, and missed on Redman. May come harder for Brennan now. Still contracted for next year, so will cost them.	1st + 2nd	UNLIKELY
OUT	Sean Darcy	Noise won't go away, though it's mainly from media know-it-alls with no inside running. Would be shocked if the Prince of Perth left	2x 1sts	UNLIKELY
OUT	Rory Lobb	Dogs are the team unless something changes late. Bell has stated we will hold him to contract. Dogs have offered a second rounder	R1	LIKELY
OUT	Joel Hamling	Still a chance he gets offered a new contract, wouldn't be the worst player to keep around for depth	-	LIKELY
OUT	Neil Erasmus	Word that the toast are into him. Would cost a mint.	6-10	UNLIKELY
OUT	Nathan Wilson	Likely to be delisted	-	LIKELY
OUT	Travis Colyer	Likely to be delisted	-	LIKELY
OUT	Lachie Schultz	Has hit a trigger for 2024. Word is Dogs are interested, and Hawks may come again. Has been offered an increased contract to stay.	25-35	UNLIKELY
OUT	Liam Henry	Here we go again. Linked to WBD & Melbourne currently. Mixed reports from ITK's around staying/going. Seems like Colon and the club are each playing games, so who knows where it really stands.	15-25	POSSIBLE

Spoiler: OPPOSITION WATCH

• Barrass heading to Sydney.
• McKay (the North version) off to the Bombers.
• Parish linked to Geelong.
• Himmelberg?
• Wingard, Fantasia, Gresham all linked to moves elsewhere.
• WC trying to move Ryan, linked to the Hawks.
• TDK likely to stay at Carlton, Silvagni potentially out.

Whats everyone thoughts on keeping Lobb this year? A R1 might be optimistic but I'd be pretty comfortable with maybe 2 2nds?

 

[poshman]

Whats everyone thoughts on keeping Lobb this year? A R1 might be optimistic but I'd be pretty comfortable with maybe 2 2nds?

I was so confused for a moment here... haha

 

[DragoDelph]

Whats everyone thoughts on keeping Lobb this year? A R1 might be optimistic but I'd be pretty comfortable with maybe 2 2nds?

I mis ONE thing. ONE!!

 

[muzzington]

Maybe they're offering a second rounder to take him back.

 

[Ge3ks]

Has Jeremy Sharp played for the Suns AFL team since Dew was sacked?

 

[Taylor]

Has Jeremy Sharp played for the Suns AFL team since Dew was sacked?

He last played a game August 13th 2022

 

[Joao]

Those Ruscoe reports do nothing for me.

 

[Ge3ks]

He last played a game August 13th 2022

Looks like Sharp has been playing well in the 2nds. Last game he played he got the maximum 10 coaches votes. Tore up the wing role, albeit against a weak non-AFL team. Seems he can play good footy, but just not for the Suns. Out of favour even with the new coach.

 

[muzzington]

I didn't realise he was 189cm. Kept thinking he was much shorter.

 

[freo_leo29]

If we do lose Henry then sharp is probably our backup pick

 

[apuchar]

If we do lose Henry then sharp is probably our backup pick

He spent some time playing as a running HB during the champs, I think. Happy to stand corrected. So that could also be an option if he is cheap and is still willing to come to us.