-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 Draft & Trade Hypotheticals
- Thread starter hairy biker
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Doing some late night research on potential draftees and since there's not really an inside mid around our first 2 picks at least, maybe there's some later...but anyway, there's a couple of (still) young guys at West Adelaide that both made SANFL Team of the Year. We might have to abandon our alleged interest in a Hawks KPD though.
Sam Frost – 184cm / 88kg mid, 22 yo, ave 7.4 tackles, 6.8 clearances, former Giants Academy player, from ACT, was named Allies captain in 2021, but U18 champs cancelled due to Covid, previously a defender, now mid
Kobe Ryan – 183cm / 77kg mid, 20 yo, ave 9 tackles, 6.6 clearances, was even more slightly built in his draft year (Frost is still the bigger unit), but went through each grade to play 4 seniors games and has obviously carried on with it. Couple of posters on the Mature Agers thread (Main Draft Board), including a West fan talking him up.
Not sure how up to date weights are, could be a year out of date.
Sam Frost – 184cm / 88kg mid, 22 yo, ave 7.4 tackles, 6.8 clearances, former Giants Academy player, from ACT, was named Allies captain in 2021, but U18 champs cancelled due to Covid, previously a defender, now mid
Kobe Ryan – 183cm / 77kg mid, 20 yo, ave 9 tackles, 6.6 clearances, was even more slightly built in his draft year (Frost is still the bigger unit), but went through each grade to play 4 seniors games and has obviously carried on with it. Couple of posters on the Mature Agers thread (Main Draft Board), including a West fan talking him up.
Not sure how up to date weights are, could be a year out of date.
Last edited:
SwansLifer
Senior List
- Aug 29, 2024
- 241
- 323
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Re: Chad. If he doesn't want to sign a long term extension then just let him go to WA. Give him a nudge if need be and let him know both parties just need to move on in their desired direction. Extract max value.
It's interesting what Paul Roos mentioned. The Swans might need to trade star players and make hard decisions, the ones deemed not up to it in big games.
I wonder who he is speaking of here?
Swans Star Players: Heeney, Gulden, Warner, Blakey, Papley.
Is there any others you would put in as stars?
It's interesting what Paul Roos mentioned. The Swans might need to trade star players and make hard decisions, the ones deemed not up to it in big games.
I wonder who he is speaking of here?
Swans Star Players: Heeney, Gulden, Warner, Blakey, Papley.
Is there any others you would put in as stars?
- Sep 15, 2021
- 1,303
- 2,788
- AFL Club
- Sydney
His set shots make McLean and Amartey look like dead eye dicks
Last edited:
SwansLifer
Senior List
- Aug 29, 2024
- 241
- 323
- AFL Club
- Sydney
fit 4 life
Debutant
Don’t know anything about tactical moves, but to me one glaring weekness is Tom McCartin, I think we definitely need a huge strong CHB, every time Tom goes near the ball, I have no confidence, I also worry if he does put himself in that hard contest, there is another concussion around the corner, I’m sure the players would be aware of it also, can’t believe we missed out on Tom Barass, we just seem to need more strength in our backline, whether that is trying McClean there
sataris
Chief Toastie Officer
- Feb 15, 2015
- 10,694
- 21,690
- AFL Club
- Sydney
False. It was Chad's manager.
Also what's wih everyone crapping on Tom McCartin lately?
Guy has been fantastic for a few years, has a couple of ordinary (not bad mind you) games and lots of BF posters suddenly decide he can't play...Do people just need someone to shit on now that Melican is back to his best?
Guy has been fantastic for a few years, has a couple of ordinary (not bad mind you) games and lots of BF posters suddenly decide he can't play...Do people just need someone to shit on now that Melican is back to his best?
Oooh that makes a bit more sense. Thanks for clarification.
SM
Bigfooty Legend
He's been crap all season, when did he have his fantastic games?
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
If a late first was what they wanted not a big deal they are late firsts (20+ with the academy/nga/FS).
SwansLifer
Senior List
- Aug 29, 2024
- 241
- 323
- AFL Club
- Sydney
- Oct 2, 2016
- 12,517
- 26,119
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Who paid his manager?
Nuh. They can have our second, tops. Not even the Norf pick. They get pick 40 or whatever it is.
This is guy who is line to sign the biggest contract in footy history and he's not worth two good firsts? Come on.
SM
Bigfooty Legend
Hand him the football and his decision making is attrocious, regularly gets caught HTB, and is now getting outbodied in marking contests. Early in the season he missed a chunk of games with a concussion and it coincided with us comfortably dealing with Carlton's two key forwards without him. He wasn't missed.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Never said two firsts just one with something back our way. On basic terms let’s assume we trade Chad to WCE we’d have 3, 13 (hawks first), and one of our current late firsts. Give one to Melb for Oliver. That’s not a horrible haul. Get the best KPD in the draft at 3 or Finn O Sullivan or something, some on here love Harvey Langford too. Best key at 13, best available at the third.
I remember him running down a small forward on the wing.
I recall him desperately getting hands to a ground ball in front of goal pushing it wide and saving a goal.
I see him regularly taking on the opponents best big forward, in our team that rarely wins first use of the footy and relies on rebound to score and did so freely, but our KPD is crap? It's laughable. He starts in every team in the comp.
Even when he's beaten in the air, it's not often because he's not RIGHT there with an attempted fist or spoil. If opponents can deliver a good pass into a big forward it is very hard to stop one on one. But he's one of the better defenders going round. At times he'll get beat - it happens and people need to accept that's life as a KPD.
Sure I wouldn't say no to a bigger forward and make him a marking interceptor. But nobody is giving us that guy and ITMT he's going a good job.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Having said that, one of his best attributes in the 2nd half of the season was the ability to take out himself and Melican in the contest...
I think he's had some great moments, and shocking ones, often in the same game.
Our turnover and rebound game has for the most part, been up there with the best. The talls play a part in this.
Now, there's many games where opponents get a run on, usually early, and a few where that just continues e.g. Port, Lions. It's a credit to our defence that we've kept some scorelines manageable in order to come back.
I don't think singling out or blaming the defence for looking flustered and making mistakes, is the main problem tbh. They suffer from what the 14-16 players up the field are doing or not doing.
That said, Rampe is nearly done, so yeah, we need a new KPD into the 22 soon.
Edwards is the bigger type we have, but probably not ready. So we either make do, or maybe bring in another bigger mature ager to cover the size deficiency we have sometimes.
I literally would not take Oliver on a free given the contract, his reported ahem "off field issues" and that he looks pretty well over football as a thing. Ridiculous. Just be satisfied he is going to continue to ruin Melbourne, or perhaps Geelong's salary cap.
Can't use pick 3 in this draft on a KPD, best available there - For sure the 13 and our first pick I'd be going there though.
I really like the sound of Alix Tauru as a Rampe replacement.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Normally I’d agree with you at 3, but the best defender in the draft is the best Rampe clone you’d ever get. The top 6-8 picks would all be no1 picks any given year he’s in that bunch, this year is the best top 20 we will see. Personally and let’s eliminate Jagga he won’t be available if Finn is there at 3, doubt I’d let him slide more. Gut feeling is the Tigers take Langford at 1.
