List Mgmt. 2024 List management Discussion

[Mat Mann]

This is solely for list management discussion, Trades discussion goes in the trade thread, and Draft prospect discussion goes in it's relevant thread.

Spoiler: Draft Order

Spoiler: Trade/Draft periods

Free Agency - Friday, October 4 and will run until Friday, October 11.
Trade Period - Monday, October 7 and will run until Wednesday, October 16.
National Draft - Round One - Wednesday, November 20 followed by the remaining rounds of the
National Draft - The rest - Thursday, November 21.
Rookie and Pre-Season Draft - Friday, November 22.

 

[The Jack]

Membrey was OK at the start of the year, poor in the middle part, along with the team, then good in the later part. Two more years while Caminiti, Heath, Keeler continue to develop, fine by me.

Love Timmy, and he played well at the end of the year, including destroying Barass at Marvel in round 19, but to be fair he was dropping more chest marks than Hanna Priest early in the year. He was looking cooked.

He did well to finish off the year playing good footy.

 

[Jade Buddha]

Only Skunk leaves with a thank you and well wishes, Josh left with a snipe and bitchy attitude to watch the Dogs utterly implode for him to walk away after an ACL. I like to think this is because Skunk can kick straight whilst Josh missed from the line cause he couldn't sniff it to think Bevo was a great idea.



Piesgobuyinggrins?

That’s hilarious

 

[luca77]

Love Timmy, and he played well at the end of the year, including destroying Barass at Marvel in round 19, but to be fair he was dropping more chest marks than Hanna Priest early in the year. He was looking cooked.

He did well to finish off the year playing good footy.

To be fair, if Hannah was a little bit quicker and the games went a bit longer she'd probably have had Tim covered there.

 

[Jade Buddha]

Have decided to……..get a pool because sipping martinis by the pool whist watching St.Kilda is way more fun.

 

[Armoooo]

Have decided I will be purchasing a St Kilda membership for 2025... because I forgot my password for the members' portal about 10 years ago and can't be bothered calling up the club so it will just roll over again.

 

[True Believer]

Have decided I will be purchasing a St Kilda membership for 2025... because I forgot my password for the members' portal about 10 years ago and can't be bothered calling up the club so it will just roll over again.

Request new password...???

 

[Armoooo]

Request new password...???

I signed up to be a member when I was like 10, I don't have access to dogfart3438@hotmail.com anymore so it will take a phone call to resolve. And phone calls are really more of a boomer / gen x thing.

 

[True Believer]

I signed up to be a member when I was like 10, I don't have access to dogfart3438@hotmail.com anymore so it will take a phone call to resolve. And phone calls are really more of a boomer / gen x thing.

Yes, I imagine tapping those virtual buttons and speaking to a human person would be terribly taxing and arduous......



Interesting email address, by the way......

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Hopefully Hind goes well in the NT league and we can "bring him home"! Might tune in to watch, better than watching our rabble.

Are you forgetting that most of the people here were berating the team continuously throughout last season & King bashing, I wasn't, lay off with your dumb & not funny analogy. And the fact is, the team according to most here, their comments- slow, boring, poor coaching, lack of ability to follow the game plan, disastrous disposal. Call it what you want, yeah for mine, a rabble will do.

 

[luca77]

Are you forgetting that most of the people here were berating the team continuously throughout last season & King bashing, I wasn't, lay off with your dumb & not funny analogy. And the fact is, the team according to most here, their comments- slow, boring, poor coaching, lack of ability to follow the game plan, disastrous disposal. Call it what you want, yeah for mine, a rabble will do.

Don't give me this "most people on here" garbage. Your post was ridiculed by plenty of people because it was ridiculous. Not renewing your membership over us not offering Tim two years has nothing to do with me forgetting anything or your claims as to what most people thought of the team last year. If you rate King that much, buy your membership and support him. Mine's on autopay because I support the club and don't throw tantrums over 30 year olds who spent weeks at Sandy.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Don't give me this "most people on here" garbage. Your post was ridiculed by plenty of people because it was ridiculous. Not renewing your membership over us not offering Tim two years has nothing to do with me forgetting anything or your claims as to what most people thought of the team last year. If you rate King that much, buy your membership and support him. Mine's on autopay because I support the club and don't throw tantrums over 30 year olds who spent weeks at Sandy.

So you actually waited on other comments, then added you're ridiculous analogy, follow the monkey's is it?

 

[jwikked]

Have decided not to purchase a membership next year. And will likely watch Dees games wtf, to see J Billing’s lacing it out to Campbell. More joy in watching that than our rabble. Wasn't like he was keeping a kid out. Just realised how truly gutted I am with the Billing’s & Campbell exits.

Membrey chose to leave lol

I don't know if Billings' parents have any interest in watching him play footy, the guy is as uninspiring and boring as it gets. I'm glad you like him, though.

 

[luca77]

Membrey chose to leave lol

I don't know if Billings' parents have any interest in watching him play footy, the guy is as uninspiring and boring as it gets. I'm glad you like him, though.

Scroll back a little bit earlier. Context is kind of important sometimes

 

[jwikked]

Scroll back a little bit earlier. Context is kind of important sometimes

lmao, didn't even notice it was a completely different poster

 

[Barrels]

So you actually waited on other comments, then added you're rediculous analogy, follow the monkey's is it?

The word you’re looking for is ridiculous…

Like your post. You melt.

 

[Saint Watto]

Only Skunk leaves with a thank you and well wishes, Josh left with a snipe and bitchy attitude to watch the Dogs utterly implode for him to walk away after an ACL. I like to think this is because Skunk can kick straight whilst Josh missed from the line cause he couldn't sniff it to think Bevo was a great idea.



Piesgobuyinggrins?

Have decided to……..get a pool because sipping martinis by the pool whist watching St.Kilda is way more fun.

That's very civilised there JB.

Are you a one or two olive type of guy?

 

[Sunshine Sainter]

Have decided not to purchase a membership next year. And will likely watch the Pies games wtf, to see Josh & Nick Daicos lacing it out to Tim Membrey. More joy in watching that than our rabble. Wasn't like he was keeping a kid out. Just realised how truly gutted I am with the Battle & Membrey exits.

Myself and my wife have both just had our annual interstate memberships renewed. Won't attend any games, but will support the club no matter who they trade, delist, sack or give away.

 

[Jade Buddha]

That's very civilised there JB.

Are you a one or two olive type of guy?

2 Watto you can never have enough of a good thing

 

[Premium]

Have decided not to purchase a membership next year. And will likely watch the Pies games wtf, to see Josh & Nick Daicos lacing it out to Tim Membrey. More joy in watching that than our rabble. Wasn't like he was keeping a kid out. Just realised how truly gutted I am with the Battle & Membrey exits.

It happens at a lot of clubs - the loss of Battle is not great , but he most probably had his reasons.
Tim has been one of our best players for so long and to see him delisted would of hurt the same it did Seb Ross.
But letting them go for nothing to me is better than seeing them playing at Sandringham - seeing club champions regulated to the 2nds is not really the way I want them to end there careers.
The AFL is a cut throat game today , players managers hold the club to ransom trying to get every dollar they can for there player - which is well and good , but when a player is at his end of his career and his position in the team is really hindering the progress of developing good young talent entering there prime they should know before being told.

Very few players get to play football into there 30s and Tim and Seb should be very satisfied in there careers.
It's sad to see greats leave this way but you have to make tough decisions and good on the club to make them.

 

[austinnn]

Myself and my wife have both just had our annual interstate memberships renewed. Won't attend any games, but will support the club no matter who they trade, delist, sack or give away.

Me too. Imagine your multi-decade loyalty to a club hinging on retaining a slowing-down 30 yr old player with the list spots so valuable.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Me too. Imagine your multi-decade loyalty to a club hinging on retaining a slowing-down 30 yr old player with the list spots so valuable.

19 games, 30 goals, on par with his career ave. 2nd in the goalkicking award, what's slowing down about that?. At least get some facts before you sprout you're slowing down made-up BS.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

The word you’re looking for is ridiculous…

Like your post. You melt.

Thanks for the spell check Barrel's.
You're a Chump
No, I mean Chimp
Oh shit sorry
Champ, that's it.

 

[Harvey to Hayes]

Have decided not to purchase a membership next year. And will likely watch the Pies games wtf, to see Josh & Nick Daicos lacing it out to Tim Membrey. More joy in watching that than our rabble. Wasn't like he was keeping a kid out. Just realised how truly gutted I am with the Battle & Membrey exits.

People leaving the fold for ludicrous reasons has never bothered me, when they slink back like nothing happened however really shits me. If you start barracking for the Filth don't come back...

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

People leaving the fold for ludicrous reasons has never bothered me, when they slink back like nothing happened however really shits me. If you start barracking for the Filth don't come back...

Who said barrack, I said I'd watch Collingwood games to see how Membrey goes. And i did add wtf, meaning why am i having to do that? You know what bothers me the most these days, is that, someone like yourself, with less than a monkey's brain comes here & interprets my message incorrectly.

 

[Sully111]

Have decided not to purchase a membership next year. And will likely watch the Pies games wtf, to see Josh & Nick Daicos lacing it out to Tim Membrey. More joy in watching that than our rabble. Wasn't like he was keeping a kid out. Just realised how truly gutted I am with the Battle & Membrey exits.

oh no