All good !!!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading Part 2
- Thread starter 1990crow
- Start date
- Tagged users None
yep definitely he was one but clearly a marginal player not getting games at Saints behind champs as you pointed out. look there probably are some examples but the fact we need to rack our brains to come up with 1-2 in the last 15 years is really the substance of my argument. and that is its not common
Apologies if I'm late to the party on this, I took a bit of a hiatus from BF. Just trying to ascertain I have the state of play correct.
We have 34 primary list contracts, and 4 rookie list contracts (including Gallagher as Cat B) leaving us a maximum of 4 more primary list spots.
At the draft, we have to add at least 3 more players to the primary list (even if it is from rookie upgrades).
So we only have one free spot for the likes of Cumming, ANB and Luko. Is that correct?
I presume we want at least Pick 4 and Welsh to be added to the primary list.
I know we can delist an out of contract player and take them back in the rookie draft, but I don't think we can move a contracted player to the rookie list, yes?
Have any contracted players put their hand up to be traded out?
We have 34 primary list contracts, and 4 rookie list contracts (including Gallagher as Cat B) leaving us a maximum of 4 more primary list spots.
At the draft, we have to add at least 3 more players to the primary list (even if it is from rookie upgrades).
So we only have one free spot for the likes of Cumming, ANB and Luko. Is that correct?
I presume we want at least Pick 4 and Welsh to be added to the primary list.
I know we can delist an out of contract player and take them back in the rookie draft, but I don't think we can move a contracted player to the rookie list, yes?
Have any contracted players put their hand up to be traded out?
- Oct 2, 2022
- 6,363
- 8,761
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
You can delist a contracted player and put them on the rookie list. We did that last year with Hamill.
We can move a contracted player to rookie list but currently only have 1 spot on rookie list as T.Muzz needs to be added to the 4 and we have given Borlase & Keane contracts. We could of course promote one of them but it defeats the purpose. Might depend if Welsh can drop to rookie list?
Its possible he does TBH.
Had a poor SANFL year, poor U18 Champs..... he's a big work in progress type.
That would be a perfect result for us. Doubt it happens, we probably need to be prepared for him to be taken in ND anyway which may mean we pick him late as we have no rookie spots left
I think we pick him in the ND as late as possible.
Here is my predictions for the off season moves:
ANB - will over pay for him like the idiots we are.
Cumming - will get as a free agent. Good work.
Luko - Will sign with Port. They have the old fake tough man retiring and Marshall questionable. Will go hard for him.
Will keep pick 4, draft a mid and then play him in the SANFL on the wing for as long as possible before finally picking him and playing him as a forward pocket.
Will get Walsh for points as a bid in the late 20's.
Nothing else will happen. No other players.
ANB - will over pay for him like the idiots we are.
Cumming - will get as a free agent. Good work.
Luko - Will sign with Port. They have the old fake tough man retiring and Marshall questionable. Will go hard for him.
Will keep pick 4, draft a mid and then play him in the SANFL on the wing for as long as possible before finally picking him and playing him as a forward pocket.
Will get Walsh for points as a bid in the late 20's.
Nothing else will happen. No other players.
If we have to match a bid in the 20s i dont think we'll bother.
yes we will because it will just be points - picks in 40s added up
I reckon that would be way above where he'd be in our talent list.
And most clubs for that matter.
Something I saw the other day had him around pick 50
thats talent order not where a bid will come
I dont think a bid will come inside 30.
about there -30ish
There is no chance a big is coming in 20 picks early for him. it'll be 40+
Unlikely
GreyCrow
Make me an Admin!
- Mar 21, 2016
- 81,578
- 133,419
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Sturt, White Sox
- Sep 25, 2014
- 5,204
- 3,737
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Sturt, Adelaide United & Leeds United
Are there any second string ruckman out there that should a number 1 ruckman that is better than ROB? if so who and if there is we should go and get him!
lets see smarty
Fuddnuddler
Debutant
Visentini (but Port won't let him go).
Peter Ladhams (loose canon but has natural ability and would put selection pressure on ROB that he has never known from Strachan)
Id have said Ned Moyle too, before he signed an extension
- Aug 21, 2008
- 6,636
- 13,489
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Nick Bryan
Would be interesting to see some stats on these movements. Whilst it seems like we don't get our fair share, with Adelaide location claimed as an inherent disadvantage, the smaller number of movements are shared between only 2 clubs. Same with other interstate sides. So whilst the larger number of movements are players to Victoria, there are 10 clubs that share in those players.
Similar threads
- Poll
