List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

Should the AFC offer Taylor Walker a contract for 2025?


  • Total voters
    40
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

tumblr_mhqc9iSDIg1qed7g8o2_400.gif


Not so much why but why now
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Remaining OOC players in 2024

  • Sam Berry
  • Hugh Bond
  • Brayden Cook
  • Lachie Gollant
  • Elliot Himmelberg
  • Ned McHenry
  • Lachie Sholl
  • Rory Sloane
  • Brodie Smith
  • Taylor Walker

Rookies
  • Patrick Parnell
  • Will Hamill
  • James Borlase
 
Tex showed he might keep going on the weekend

Also I think Hamill was pretty solid
I'm of the opinion its time to move on from Tex

Unless he kicks 40+ - I think we need to embrace life without Tex
 
Remaining OOC players in 2024

  • Sam Berry
  • Hugh Bond
  • Brayden Cook
  • Lachie Gollant
  • Elliot Himmelberg
  • Ned McHenry
  • Lachie Sholl
  • Rory Sloane
  • Brodie Smith
  • Taylor Walker

Rookies
  • Patrick Parnell
  • Will Hamill
  • James Borlase
I'd be keeping Borlase - he has shown enough in the games he has played that he is solid back up as a KPP. I also think IF we keep him on, it might show our hand that Curtin is not destined to be a KPP as we ill have Murray, Butts, Keane, Worrell and Borlase able to fill the 2 key posts and 3rd man intercept.
 
Sillier to not chase a player on the presumption that a club will sack its premiership coach and that all the assistant coaches there rate him it's just Bevo being an idiot keeping him out

The list manager's buyer's remorse is what you'd be working on anyway. Might want some space with clubs circling JUH
Oh, chase him, absolutely.

I just don't think it's reasonable to assume the Bulldogs will still be as chaotic at the end of the year as they are now. It's completely self inflicted, and eventually Bevo is going to go.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Hawks are really struggling at 0-5; Mitchell’s (like Nicks) a few years into the job and needing to start showing some improvement; they’re getting smashed in the midfield.

Is there any chance we could offload Laird (or Crouch) to them to help ‘steady the ship’ and pinch a second rounder in return.

Need to exploit those clubs who are vulnerable - god knows it has happened to us. They’ve proved by recruiting Gunston back when clearly cooked that they’re prone to a brain fade.
More likely someone like Butts or Borlase as they need tall defenders.
 
On the Sunday Footy Show they're talking about the Bulldogs

Bailey Dale signed a five year deal last year but is now the sub, a bit on the outer

Could we make an offer and take on 75% of his salary?
Absolutely.
 
I'm of the opinion its time to move on from Tex

Unless he kicks 40+ - I think we need to embrace life without Tex
No, we move him on when he is no longer performing.

Make the call towards the end of the year.
 
Hawks are really struggling at 0-5; Mitchell’s (like Nicks) a few years into the job and needing to start showing some improvement; they’re getting smashed in the midfield.

Is there any chance we could offload Laird (or Crouch) to them to help ‘steady the ship’ and pinch a second rounder in return.

Need to exploit those clubs who are vulnerable - god knows it has happened to us. They’ve proved by recruiting Gunston back when clearly cooked that they’re prone to a brain fade.

It is worth considering trying to trade Laird and Crouch. Laird has value even at his age because he could move into a player development role with a club looking to boost its midfield stocks and developing their young players.

With Dawson as a constant and Soligo looking the goods as a main mid, Rankine, Pedlar, Dowling, Rachele can all rotate through there. The only issue is Crouch is a midfield bull who can win the contested possession. Its hard to replace.
 
It is worth considering trying to trade Laird and Crouch. Laird has value even at his age because he could move into a player development role with a club looking to boost its midfield stocks and developing their young players.

With Dawson as a constant and Soligo looking the goods as a main mid, Rankine, Pedlar, Dowling, Rachele can all rotate through there. The only issue is Crouch is a midfield bull who can win the contested possession. Its hard to replace.
So 2022's Berry....?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top