List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[Kangaroos4eva]

The melts have begun and we still have weeks before the trade season starts. Love it!

Bring this one out every trade season.

 

[The Nostradamus]

he didnt want to ruck
He had to ruck
Now he dont like them anymore

Yep they have seriously mismanaged SDK

Time to pounce and let SDK play every game in his preferred position

They can use the future first they get from us to go get smith

 

[Moti]

I assumed he would end up wing or HFF next year

I have him HF, Wing and in the middle with the very occasional run across HB.

We need his speed in the middle.

 

[chubbspeterson]

Who are you thinking then?

Josh rachele is one I think we should be looking to bring home and after him getting dropped and hung out to dry could be gettable

The guy doesn't know anything, he's just claiming they're up to something big for starters.
And I just don't think we're a chance to get either of them as those teams would be wanting to hold onto them and even if those guys left they'd be nominating Carlton.

SDK has gone backwards as a defender this year, so much so they threw him in the ruck to get him out of a slump.
Cats seem unsure of what his best position is long term. I'd prefer SDK out of the two because he's younger.

 

[Waynesworld]

I guess the flipside is that our player retention over the past couple years would have be among the highest in the league.

Would be hard to attract elite talent to a club like ours, but we're doing a lot better at keeping good players than many clubs much higher up the ladder.

I wish the AFLPA would publish the results from the club-by-club player satisfaction survey they do. For all the lack of Cotton On and Hungry Jacks franchises we can offer, we must do pretty well there.

Lol we have done well with retaining our players as most wouldn't be getting senior games at other clubs (with a few exceptions of course)!

 

[Devski]

Absolutely silly not to put a massive offer forward for SDK. Preference over any Houston deal.

Play KPD for us, earn a shit load and at the end of 2025 when your brother is RFA, we will get him across to us to play as a FWD.

You'll both be playing together making a bag at an up and coming team full of elite 19-20 year olds.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Lol we have done well with retaining our players as most wouldn't be getting senior games at other clubs (with a few exceptions of course)!

Re-signed Sheezel
Re-signed Wardlaw
Re-signed Larkey
Re-signed Zurhaar
Re-signed Curtis
Re-signed Xerri
Re-signed Chom

All were sought after by other teams by varying extents.

 

[Tas]

On the Port board they are mulling over how to split our pick 2...

 

[Samsquanch]

If it helps Tom Hawkins was on $45k per season since 2011 because he wanted to make a sacrifice to keep the group together

Imagine the sacrifices Pattie Dangerfields is making. He's so lucky that the tribunal hasn't handed him any big fines when they've dismissed the cases against him or he'd probably be paying out of his own pocket to play footy.

 

[Waynesworld]

Re-signed Sheezel
Re-signed Wardlaw
Re-signed Larkey
Re-signed Zurhaar
Re-signed Curtis
Re-signed Xerri
Re-signed Chom

All were sought after by other teams by varying extents.

So their managers told us.

Not so sure we didn't get the raw end with the Zurhaar deal either

Chom, Larkey and Xerri all said that they wanted to repay the faith we had in them over long periods of development / injury

Curtis would be lucky to hold a spot in some of the top teams

Sheezel and Wardlaw have bought into the Clarko belief as they weren't part of the previous administrations shit shows.

 

[Elroo]

On the Port board they are mulling over how to split our pick 2...

Yeh I saw that, along with demands for our pick 2, 2025F1 & a our next 2 yrs worth of 2nd round picks for Houston.

 

[koshari]

They have Farrell, Bergman and Sinn they don’t need another hbf

Would be happy to take any of these 3 off them too

i prefer the original sin,

 

[roos_fanatic08]

I think one of our posters relayed Carlton itk that Carlton would use pick 11 for SDK, hence port spitting the dummy over their offer for houston

Would make sense as to why Carlton are trying to move on Owies/Kennedy/Young too...

 

[chubbspeterson]

So going to the club you barracked for as a kid is a thing... unless it's North Melbourne?

Good to see Collingwood's fluid cap on show.

Got us covered. I'll show this image to our BFNAAK's Josh Weddle, Max Gruzewksi, Nate Caddy and Darcy Wilson and then have them repeat the words "I must come to the NMFC".

 

[HBFlanker]

Really like the commentary around moving next years first into this year, or using it for Houston.

With next year being able to trade two years in advance on picks, it opens up the ability to potentially buy back in to any draft.

Id do next years first for picks 9 and 27 from Fremantle in this years draft is a good trade

 

[Hazey1977]

Chicken Banh Mi’s have a habit of catching up with you.

True story.... At a public health conference and at lunch Roll'd was rolled out. The epidemiologists literally warned everyone to stay the f*$k away from the Chicken Banh Mi!

Sent from my SM-G781B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[blackshadow]

Our F1 being floated for GC's Pick 12...

No doubt with something coming back

 

[chubbspeterson]

The biggest factor is how they manage to carry Hipwood.

He did have OP. I don't rate Hipwood but good on him for battling through.

 

[backtothedraft]

Really like the commentary around moving next years first into this year, or using it for Houston
With next year being able to trade two years in advance on picks, it opens up the ability to potentially buy back in to any draft.

Id do next years first for picks 9 and 27 from Fremantle in this years draft is a good trade

I have come around to this way of thinking as well with future trading opening up next year. Will the value of a 2025 first round pick traded into this year be higher than if trading next year. It is easy to envisage a shift in how players are valued with a larger pool of picks available.

 

[pupstar]

Armstrong isn’t in the top 5 talents let alone top 2.

Smilie will be lucky to be top 10, probably Armstrong as well.

Says who how much of him have you actually seen of him. couple of high lights on big footy Explain in detail why he is not a top 10 pick.

 

[chubbspeterson]

Really like the commentary around moving next years first into this year, or using it for Houston.

With next year being able to trade two years in advance on picks, it opens up the ability to potentially buy back in to any draft.

Id do next years first for picks 9 and 27 from Fremantle in this years draft is a good trade

It might be tougher to get teams to trade out next year though if they need to match a bid in the same round on a F/S or academy kid. We'll have to wait and see what the bidding rules are I guess and whether you can match a bid with a future first if you can't trade into that round. Won't matter for us until 2026 with Harris and McCartney.

 

[Passmore]

Dirty in being dropped a couple of times …

Clearly made of stern stuff.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[Passmore]

Why are we all feeding this Stevie J blokes ego?

99.99% of "ITK" is made up. Stevie's just getting in on the act.

The only one I had any faith in his info has gone and ****ed off....

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[DuckYeah]

Our F1 being floated for GC's Pick 12...

Isnt that pick useless to Gold coast? Dont they need points because they have up to 15 players available through academy?

 

[DunderHead]

Who would we choose De Koning or Clarry?

 

[DuckYeah]

So their managers told us.

Not so sure we didn't get the raw end with the Zurhaar deal either

Chom, Larkey and Xerri all said that they wanted to repay the faith we had in them over long periods of development / injury

Curtis would be lucky to hold a spot in some of the top teams

Sheezel and Wardlaw have bought into the Clarko belief as they weren't part of the previous administrations shit shows.

Curtis would be lucky to hold a spot in some of the top teams

Ya kidding aren’t ya? I wonder how good him and some of our other players would be in a gun side.