List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[The Filth Wizard]

We are going to wipe almost a years worth of draft picks for some 30+ year olds and a midget.

Cats pick up a delisted fa in Martin and a young gun in Bailey williams (more than likely on the cheap) and will probably turn them in AA’s. That’s how you do trade period.

I'll be unhappy to be proven wrong but I think Jack Martin is an awful pick up for the Cats. They've basically replaced Rohan with a worse, more injury prone version.

 

[giantroo]

THE FUTURE of Western Bulldogs small forward Riley Garcia remains unclear, with AFL.com.au's Josh Gabelich reporting his future is tied up in that of Collingwood's Joe Richards.

AFL.com.au's Inside Trading reported last month Port Adelaide, West Coast, St Kilda and North Melbourne had expressed varying levels of interest in Garcia, who has been looking for more midfield opportunities.

Gabelich says the Power are the frontrunners should Garcia decide to leave, but that Port's priority at the moment is luring Richards away from the Magpies.


"He got a lot of support in the room last night (at the Bulldogs' best and fairest), there's a lot of love for him," Gabelich said on Trade Exchange.

"Port Adelaide is the one. I believe if he is to leave the Western Bulldogs, it will be to Port Adelaide.

"But they've got other priorities at the moment ... they're narrowing in on Joe Richards and I think if Richards stays at Collingwood, the Power will pivot to Garcia.

"I think there's a belief now that he will stay at the Western Bulldogs." - Martin Smith

 

[jay317]

Yes, but there is this thing called trading....... we can get others.

And what do you propose we'd trade to get one? (So in a sense, what we're giving up for him?)

 

[spurs]

Jesus.

How would you trade, what's your scenario? Split pick 2? Keep it? Keep F1? If not, what pick, or picks would you like in return for this year?

 

[SpiderBurton22]

 

[The Nostradamus]

I hope we’ve at least done some due diligence on clarry to see if we should get in the convo

 

[Shinboner1]

I hope we’ve at least done some due diligence on clarry to see if we should get in the convo

Oliver isnt coming to north mate

 

[Makeshift Park]

Acquiring Oliver and Smith in one offseason has the capacity to make the Taranto and Hopper trade seem sage in comparison

 

[justroyal]

All Geelong has to do now is get TT and they’ve got possibly one of the best mids

 

[Gippy Roo]

Boom welcome Luke Parker
Now the question is will konstanty join him


Incorrect

North has spoken with Konstanty but a while ago. North are yet to follow up with him. Konstanty has already met with two Victorian teams. Hope we make contact this week! Would love him at the club but is looking less likely as time goes on. Pick up the phone Brady!!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Warlord69]

North has spoken with Konstanty but a while ago. North are yet to follow up with him. Konstanty has already met with two Victorian teams. Hope we make contact this week! Would love him at the club but is looking less likely as time goes on. Pick up the phone Brady!!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Carlton are the frontrunner

 

[BlueandWhiteinmyBlood]

Can we please ban this guy as a source. He is throwing so many darts hoping to just hit one.

Gothard was drafted last year and has the standard 3 year contract as a first round draftee.

I understand and agree that it’s unlikely he would come but just because there is a contract isn’t the reason it’s unlikely. Parker, Houston and Daniel from our possible acquisitions alone at North are all under contract. A contract is only good for a home loan

 

[shinboner magic]

Imagine if ‘Stevie J ‘ nails one of his trade rumours - he’ll be a runaway train after that

 

[Gippy Roo]

No need to offer that much. At this stage Konstanty will either be delisted or traded for a late pick.

He is expecting to get delisted. He isn’t sure where he’ll end up at this stage and is open to coming to North but has not heard from them for a while, nor has any offer in front of him from us (as of last week).


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[justroyal]

Imagine if ‘Stevie J ‘ nails one of his trade rumours - he’ll be a runaway train after that

And the hero we all needed…. Well, since KIA31 or whatever went away..

 

[The b shart]

All Geelong has to do now is get TT and they’ve got possibly one of the best mids

2 first rounders coming our way

 

[AnEmptyChair]

We are going to wipe almost a years worth of draft picks for some 30+ year olds and a midget.

Cats pick up a delisted fa in Martin and a young gun in Bailey williams (more than likely on the cheap) and will probably turn them in AA’s. That’s how you do trade period.

We've got a million kids on the list as it is. Honestly think 2-3 years of Luke Parker and 5 years of Caleb Daniel helps us more at this stage than another 18 year old pick 40

 

[Colby Cheer Squad]

All Geelong has to do now is get TT and they’ve got possibly one of the best mids

And also, their entire starting midfield could be wiped out in one random piss test swoop.

 

[perplexed]

Throw up an alternative trade for our F1

Why would we trade our F1? Future picks always cop a discount and we will need it next year when we have a pile of duds OOC. We will get a bigger return for splitting pick 2.

 

[My Left Foote]

If people are going to insist on posting RooSteve19 Trade Roomours* then for every post, to balance things out, I’m going to post one of his bullshit lies here are 3 to kick it off.

I ask you to pay special attention to the number of likes for each Tweet, not that Likes = Authenticity, but this guy is just making shit up.



*Copyright The Filth Wizard

 

[Colby Cheer Squad]

Based on draft points perhaps, but the reality is that there is a 95% of the top 10 players on your draft list not going to be available with two late firsts.

You do know it's not possible to extract 95% of 10 players, right? You'd end up with a player cut in half.

 

[archereleven]

All Geelong has to do now is get TT and they’ve got possibly one of the best mids

Or, the whole thing blows up in their face.

On SM-G991B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The Nostradamus]

North has spoken with Konstanty but a while ago. North are yet to follow up with him. Konstanty has already met with two Victorian teams. Hope we make contact this week! Would love him at the club but is looking less likely as time goes on. Pick up the phone Brady!!


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

hopefully when we finalise and speak to parker's manager who is also Konstanty's we can work him into the deal for free with the swans

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Tom Harleys interview on radio this morning made the Warner/Freo sounds like it was a real chance in 2025, making our F1 a really attractive asset for them. What does everyone think is an acceptable deal? I'll have a go at the bones of a deal looping in Brisbane:

North
In: 9, 18, 69
Out: F1, 22, 40, 58

Brisbane
In: 22, 27, 58
Out: 18, F3 (Lions), 69

Fremantle
In: F1 (North), 40, F3 (Lions)
Out: 9, 27

North 2024 Draft picks
2,9,18,64,69

The Rawlings thread would go into meltdown if we did that!

 

[backtothedraft]

Why would we trade our F1? Future picks always cop a discount and we will need it next year when we have a pile of duds OOC. We will get a bigger return for splitting pick 2.

There doesn't seem to be the appetite across the league for any club to move up the board, so splitting pick 2 seems highly unlikely, particularly if we are after a deal that strongly favours us. Usually at this point of the year there would have been significant commentary about such moves, but the lack of coverage probably tells the story and reflects the strength and evenness of this years draft. Thursfield mentioned on the members Q+A that they are open minded on trading an F1 to secure a player or get another pick in the first round this year as they rate the draft. I was simply throwing up an example of what i think that could look like.