3rd Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 14-18 1050hrs @ The Gabba

Who will win?


  • Total voters
    46
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Being ignored by some that we still hold an almost 200 lead.
It's ultimately been a pretty solid effort, just not to be with the rain delays. The first part of that is getting lost on some given the last hour.

I'd say if we can't trust Marsh to bowl more than he did in this situation, he shouldn't be in the team (especially with no Green). But can't fault Cummins and Starc's efforts today.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The half hearted short balls are much easier for tail enders to score off.

Using ODI tactics when the bowlers aren’t fresh is beyond stupid, especially when there was definitely still a little in the pitch. If they get the runs with us pitching it up then well played but trying to buy tail end wickets is such negative captaincy.
They needed most to be in to stop singles, just aim top of off stump, and make them take a risk to score.

We had a long on when there should have been a mid on, easy single. Then had Starc at mid-off way to wide. They get a few singles through there. Just got it all wrong. Plus he is trying to think about all this when he is totally knackered. When he was that stuffed and still bowling through necessity let Smith take charge for a while.
 
We may get MORE out of getting some more runs like the openers, Marnus etc
If India were smart they just give the fast bowlers 1 spell in the morning and then rotate the part timers for the rest of the day. Con Australia into thinking that Khawaja, Labuschagne and Marsh are in form and McSweeney is a test opener
 
Yes

They still think Inglis should be playing instead of Carey
Everyone keeps saying this and yet I haven’t seen a single person actually say that Inglis should be in over Carey.

I’ve only seen people say Inglis should be in as a specialist bat.
 
Marsh said pre-game that he was willing to bowl more overs for the team if required. That hasn't been anywhere near the truth.


Quote Marsh:

"I'll try and be ready to bowl as much as Patty needs me. Our allrounders haven't bowled a hell of a lot in Australia the last few years"
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

They needed most to be in to stop singles, just aim top of off stump, and make them take a risk to score.

We had a long on when there should have been a mid on, easy single. Then had Starc at mid-off way to wide. They get a few singles through there. Just got it all wrong. Plus he is trying to think about all this when he is totally knackered. When he was that stuffed and still bowling through necessity let Smith take charge for a while.
Yup and it’s a pattern Jim happened on the away ashes Pat loses it a bit when bowling to the tail .. perhaps he gets tired and mucks up his decisions with the ball field placements
 
Marsh said pre-game that he was willing to bowl more overs for the team if required. That hasn't been anywhere near the truth.
It’s not his fault if the captain doesn’t throw him the ball.
 
Some of the melts here are ridiculous.

We have a lead of 190.

We have dominated the test.

Are the stupid short ball to the tail tactics annoying - yes.

Should we have bowled them out and been able to enforce the follow on - yes as well.

Was Smiths drop costly - yes.

Would we have won if not for the drop? Who knows

Fact is we have lost a good 5-6 sessions in the match to rain

Was always pushing it uphill to get a win in that context

On SM-S921B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
No point a bowler down with this weather around we aren't bowling them out in time. Game is gone. We should just bat all day tomorrow.

yeah spot on - the game is now gone.

no point risking losing to win, with the way the series is poised and with hazlewood out of the game.

no point risking our bowlers tomorrow - would hate to go to melbourne without another quick.
 
Some of the melts here are ridiculous.

We have a lead of 190.

We have dominated the test.

Are the stupid short ball to the tail tactics annoying - yes.

Should we have bowled them out and been able to enforce the follow on - yes as well.

Was Smiths drop costly - yes.

Would we have won if not for the drop? Who knows

Fact is we have lost a good 5-6 sessions in the match to rain

Was always pushing it uphill to get a win in that context

On SM-S921B using BigFooty.com mobile app

Its fascinating mindset that enters the bowler and captain with the short pitch stuff to the lower order.

We are far from the only team that does it just makes me chuckle a little.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

3rd Test Border Gavaskar Trophy December 14-18 1050hrs @ The Gabba

Back
Top