Autopsy AFL 2023 Round 20 - Collingwood v Carlton Fri July 28th 7:50pm EST (MCG)

[Pendleton10]

light work

 

[Skull Face]

So it's not worth 4 premiership points?

Come on fadge I already explained this earlier in the thread keep up

If we beat Pies, Dees, GC to get to 12.5 wins we miss finals
If we beat Saints, GWS, GC to get to 12.5 wins we play finals

Friday night is meaningless save for momentum, still have to win the games vs sides near us on the ladder to deny them the chance to get to 13 wins.

 

[Truetiger]

Hate wanting Collingwood to win, but need just that this week

 

[Fadge]

Come on fadge I already explained this earlier in the thread keep up

If we beat Pies, Dees, GC to get to 12.5 wins we miss finals
If we beat Saints, GWS, GC to get to 12.5 wins we play finals

Friday night is meaningless save for momentum, still have to win the games vs sides near us on the ladder to deny them the chance to get to 13 wins.

You really don't understand the system, do you?

Maybe you bank the 4 points against Collingwood and other results fall your way, and the results against St. Kilda and/or GWS are irrelevant.

 

[Skull Face]

You really don't understand the system, do you?

Maybe you bank the 4 points against Collingwood and other results fall your way, and the results against St. Kilda and/or GWS are irrelevant.

For sure that could happen but if we beat both then other results dont really matter.

 

[ep2018]

Carlton will win this. Dont want to be playing them first up in finals I reckon. Or maybe they'll do a Richmond 2014 and be so mentally cooked making the finals from so far back they are easy prey week 1.

 

[Madblue]

Both sides are playing well, hard to pick a winner in what I see as a 50/50 game

Not with our outs Arrow I'm affraid

 

[Arr0w]

Not with our outs Arrow I'm affraid

No doubt Pies are favourites, but that means little with the form of both sides

 

[timokane]

Pies by 22 points and 92k at the mcg

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

If Cerra Walsh Kennedy and Mckay are all missing we are cooked

 

[JyeDye]

Can't see how we lose this. Been a weak season, Pies would be 10th if this was last year.

 

[HarryBeef]

A large percentage of Collingwood's wins this year have come against bottom 12 teams, so there's a bit of an asterisk against them for mine.

 

[JyeDye]

If Cerra Walsh Kennedy and Mckay are all missing we are cooked

Really upset at Walsh's injury. Was absolutely tearing it up last week, still got a coaches vote despite only playing half the game. He's just not been able to get a steady run back into it, he's still an absolute jet.

 

[JackFlash]

Collingwood by 50 points.

 

[JackFlash]

So you think we'll put the cue in the rack after quarter time?

No, i just think Collingwood is an 8 goal better team than Carlton who will try very hard but, will ultimately get well beaten.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

No, i just think Collingwood is an 8 goal better team than Carlton who will try very hard but, will ultimately get well beaten.

Unfortunately we are a 12 goal worse side with our current outs/injuries, so your prediction that the Pies will win by 8 goals this Friday will most likely be correct.

You really do need a charmed run with injury and umpiring to have that chance at a flag. It looks like it’s all coming together for Collingwood.

 

[Chief]

Sam Walsh (hamstring)

• Scans have confirmed a low-grade hamstring strain
• At this stage, is expected to miss the next 2-3 weeks

Jack Silvagni (knee)

• Scans confirmed a joint sprain to his knee
• A return-to-play timeline will become clearer as he works through his rehabilitation over the coming weeks

Jesse Motlop (calf)

• Had a tight calf in the second half against the Eagles
• Will be a test to play this week

Patrick Cripps (cork)
- Test to play this week

Adam Cerra (hamstring)
- Test to play this week

Jack Martin (calf)
- Test to play this week

Matt Owies (calf)
- Test to play this week

Corey Durdin (shoulder)
- Test to play this week

 

[PieLebo87]

Can't see how we lose this. Been a weak season, Pies would be 10th if this was last year.

If you minus all our wins by 2 goals or less, take away the ones with clearly favourable umpiring, remove Daicos, we’d be 10th. God damn #VICBIAS

 

[PieLebo87]

Patrick Cripps (cork)
- Test to play this week

I wonder if this is a normal ‘test to play this week’, or a Clayton Oliver type of ‘test to play this week’.

 

[Chief]

I wonder if this is a normal ‘test to play this week’, or a Clayton Oliver type of ‘test to play this week’.

I don't know much about Clayton Oliver. Something about an infected blister?

 

[jakson68]

Hate wanting Collingwood to win, but need just that this week

LOL, yes it would be a strange feeling for you come the first bounce next Friday and you say "go Pies"

 

[PieLebo87]

I don't know much about Clayton Oliver. Something about an infected blister?

Walsh will miss less games with a bloody hammy!

 

[Truetiger]

LOL, yes it would be a strange feeling for you come the first bounce next Friday and you say "go Pies"

lol Happy to be on board come Friday, to end Carltons chances much like last season

 

[jakson68]

lol Happy to be on board come Friday, to end Carltons chances much like last season

With Carlton, Geelong, Lions and Essendon coming in the next few weeks, Richmond people will be supporting Collingwood so much, we may need to sign you up as members

 

[Truetiger]

With Carlton, Geelong, Lions and Essendon coming in the next few weeks, Richmond people will be supporting Collingwood so much, we may need to sign you up as members

haha only membership form I could find needs an update . Jokes aside, would be nice if you won all of them.