Autopsy AFL 2024 Round 14 - North v Pies Sun June 16th 1pm AEST (Marvel)

[MagpieJoel]

Let's circle back to the granny when they called 'advantage' to a lions player kicking over his head whilst being tackled instead of calling it back to the Brownlow medallist.

Pies always get the calls so I usually take 3-4 goals off their totals in terms of assessing performances.

Haha.

 

[danster168]

They shouldn't have been playing in the GF to begin with, GWS were stiffed by the umps in the prelim also.

100%. Toby Green had his neck ripped off. Play on.

 

[bzparkes]

100%. Toby Green had his neck ripped off. Play on.

Yep. They can claim it was the 'Toby' rule all they want but if they were playing another team, I reckon it gets paid.

 

[danster168]

Yep. They can claim it was the 'Toby' rule all they want but if they were playing another team, I reckon it gets paid.

But at the same time whinge like little sooks every time Ginnivan got caught high.

 

[HotPiesWithSauce]

Because Collingwood appear to suspiciously be on the receiving end of incredibly favourable umpiring late in close games incredibly often.

Except we aren't, having a game taken from us against Freo for a very touchy decision for example

It's just the biased "neutral" echo chamber that some people surround themselves with convinces them otherwise

 

[bzparkes]

Except we aren't, having a game taken from us against Freo for a very touchy decision for example

It's just the biased "neutral" echo chamber that some people surround themselves with convinces them otherwise

Great, you have one example, after your entire finals series last year(+ GF) was massively dictated by the umpires.

 

[juss]

What a crazy game. Very high scoring and a ridiculous turn around in game.

 

[mumblingpie]

But at the same time whinge like little sooks every time Ginnivan got caught high.

Offcourse your bitching and complaining in another game thread, fk you must be the life of the party

 

[wcesam]

100% a 2 week holiday for Maynard.

 

[MagpieJoel]

100%. Toby Green had his neck ripped off. Play on.

The salt oozes from your skin.

 

[danster168]

Offcourse your bitching and complaining in another game thread, fk you must be the life of the party

yeah we should really celebrate umpire blunders. wake up

 

[danster168]

The salt oozes from your skin.

because you can't even deny anything. You can't deny the father sons, you can't deny the nga gifts, you can't deny the umpires, you can't deny that Daicos is soft so you just say 'oh so salty' lol

 

[FireKrakouer]

No, people hate a game being won due to the wrong decision.

Because that rule is never applied consistently.

If it we're it'd be fine. Instead, umps seem to pick and choose when they want to pay it.

Carn m8 you can't say you want the right decisions then complain about an objectively proven correct decision. Maybe it's more about which team you'd prefer to win then it is about a desire for fairness.

 

[Thrawn]

because you can't even deny anything. You can't deny the father sons, you can't deny the nga gifts, you can't deny the umpires, you can't deny that Daicos is soft so you just say 'oh so salty' lol

I'm going to say it wasn't the umpires fault, just for you.

 

[bzparkes]

Carn m8 you can't say you want the right decisions then complain about an objectively proven correct decision. Maybe it's more about which team you'd prefer to win then it is about a desire for fairness.

I never complained about it. Wtf are you on?

 

[adammania9]

They shouldn't have been playing in the GF to begin with, GWS were stiffed by the umps in the prelim also.

My heart is weeping

 

[FireKrakouer]

I never complained about it. Wtf are you on?

I quoted the post in which you complained about it.

 

[adammania9]

Great, you have one example, after your entire finals series last year(+ GF) was massively dictated by the umpires.

QF -6 free kicks
PF +-0 free kicks
GF -6 free kicks

Total: -12 free kicks

Such an amazing run of free kicks

 

[bzparkes]

I quoted the post in which you complained about it.

I wasn't complaining. I was giving you a reason why some fans were up in arms over it. If he ran too far, he ran too far.

No issue with it myself.

 

[bzparkes]

QF -6 free kicks
PF +-0 free kicks
GF -6 free kicks

Total: -12 free kicks

Such an amazing run of free kicks

It's not about the number mate, surely you're smart enough to understand this?

 

[adammania9]

It's not about the number mate, surely you're smart enough to understand this?

The fact you even mentioned the Grand Final is embarrassing. Lions had countless favourable decisions, including a goal given from a 50 the AFL conceded shouldn't have been awarded

 

[adammania9]

its true. you can celebrate it but many neutrals don't give much credit for the pies 2023 gf. Kissed with umpires in every final game and kissed with the tribunal. All whilst having a record number of father/son and nga picks. Talk about an asterisk

Oh no! All the premiership memorabilia means nothing because Bigfooty chums don't rate it! Collingwood have to give back the cup because danster168 isn't on board!

Melbourne literally have more F/S' on their list, champ

 

[TW Sherrin]

Everyone's in here carrying on, including Pies supporters who know they got kissed on the proverbial but acting like sore winners.

Giving up a lead 54 point lead but it's the umpires fault. Subbing Phillips was the biggest factor in losing the game.

Btw are we only discussing decisions in the last 10 minutes or can we can go back further?

 

[TW Sherrin]

One hand on a bloke's jumper where he spun himself while being tackled, all in one motion.

Maynard planted his foot and put himself on the rotisserie. You won't see a better example of a dangerous tackle all year.

Except the north players head didn't hit the ground and tbh it wasn't even a free kick.

 

[danster168]

Oh no! All the premiership memorabilia means nothing because Bigfooty chums don't rate it! Collingwood have to give back the cup because danster168 isn't on board!

Melbourne literally have more F/S' on their list, champ

lol. yeah mate, Taj Woewodin, what a gun! thank God we had special access so other teams couldn't snap him up. Same as Joel Smith, literally took him out of respect to his old man. What a gun. He would've been a first rounder if he wasn't a basketballer lol