Autopsy AFL 2024 Round 15 - Blues v Cats Fri June 21st 7:40pm AEST (MCG)

[amazingjoshy]

Did the umpire call play on or has BT lost it again?

BTs lost it

And half this board has feel for it

 

[Skull Face]

Just got home and turned the game on and thought I must have really stuffed because the Giants were playing. Imagine the furor from Colllingwood if another team turned up in black and white.

Been doing it since before your club was formed who stole what now

 

[Worm4]

Another umpire stuff up, no doubt Laura Kane will be defending it again on Monday with another ludicrous explanation.

She can't defend it. Firstly the mark was taken on the 50m line, secondly umpire drags player on mark back 4 or 5 metres closer to goal, lastly Cameron runs off his line with natural arc. Clearly it's amateur hour, and she will back it up with an amateur response on Monday

 

[Elixuh]

100 point loss coming up. Scott will blame it on the bye.

 

[Delediodamage]

He's not allowed to talk to the coaches?

He is the captain you know?

Of course. I never said he couldn’t…. But Scott would have known Cincotta was highly likely to go to him. They would have spoken about it before the game. Yet he’s off in the first 10 mins? Very rare for Stewart to be off the ground.

Based on that I’d suspect he was told to come off the ground as a tactical decision to break the tag. My opinion only, but that’s how it appeared.

 

[BigFrizz36]

Owies talent versus grandstanding ratio surely the highest in the league.

Flog of bloke isn’t he.

Small bloke goes to U.S.A on a basketball scholarship and makes a success of it. Comes back as a cat B rookie in a game he hasn't played for years and makes a success of himself at the highest level.

Flog on an internet forum calls him a flog.

 

[keithrichards]

Umpires got it right.

Cameron didn’t run off the line in the way players do to gain extra meters (why would he, he had the journey comfortably).

Was A natural arc.


Commentators are ducking idiots

 

[kreuze_missile]

So when are they taking that Cameron goal off…?

 

[_Mike_]

It wasn't called play on. BT just made that up in his head and ran with it.

BT, Richo & Hodge.. 3 stooges of commentary

 

[Captivating]

Laura will sign that off.


Nothing to see here.

FMD

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

Rightly so. It was a goal. You don't have to kick over the man on the mark thanks to the AFL bending the rules to accomodate Franklin.

 

[Skull Face]

Good common sense from the umps.
That's just his natural arc, they never ever called that play on prior to 2021.

He literally walked in a straight line past the man on the mark it's not an arc it's creeping off the line and play on but who cares cats need all the handouts they can get.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

He’s a gun and was sad to see him go, but it was a dumb career move timing wise.

Has played for the last 2 Premiers without winning a medal.

On top of that, didn’t play any finals for Collingwood in 22 because his attitude stunk as he’d checked out.

Geelong didn’t play finals in 23.

He’s a soft ****. Wanted to ‘go home’ 50 minutes down the road.

Pies better off without him.

 

[parano1a]

Port do it at least once a year

Only with Collingwood's explicit permission.

 

[_Mike_]

Anyway, Carlton aren’t losing this. Cats can barely string a run together

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Just got home and turned the game on and thought I must have really stuffed because the Giants were playing. Imagine the furor from Colllingwood if another team turned up in black and white.

We seem to be fine with St Kilda doing it. They also happen to have red.

Bit like Carlton, blue and white but tonight with some orange.

Sorry to ratio you.

 

[Veer Right]

A number of cats look cooked

Danger - body
Blicavs - output
Stanley - rotten
Rohan - Not doing much/injuries
Hawkins - The end can come fast for some
Oconnor - Surely they have better in the seconds?
Mullin - provides nothing

Midfield is probably the worst midfield in the AFL.

Badly need to chase a Ruck and star mid.

 

[BuddysBiggestFan]

Umpires keeping Geelong in it

First the mark was on the 50m mark not 40m then he lets Cameron play on after the siren

Morons ruin every single game

 

[amazingjoshy]

Umpires got it right.

Cameron didn’t run off the line in the way players do to gain extra meters (why would he, he had the journey comfortably).

Was A natural arc.


Commentators are ducking idiots

They are
But on this occasion it was just BT

 

[BringFevBack2021]

I thought the umpire raised his hands for end of play not for play on?

Looked a natural arc to me for one and two Jezza has that covered without the arc - would be a very stiff call

 

[Chism]

She can't defend it. Firstly the mark was taken on the 50m line, secondly umpire drags player on mark back 4 or 5 metres closer to goal, lastly Cameron runs off his line with natural arc. Clearly it's amateur hour, and she will back it up with an amateur response on Monday

Can you imagine this place if Curnow got that exact same treatment to goal!

Anyone else gets its and it is play on as usual!

Charlie Curnow has the numpties on here on edge!

 

[lizard man]

I think the cats need to trim Hawkins down in weight and throw him on the wing to help reinvent him and get him into the game more

 

[TENACIOUS]

Laura will come out and say the umpire shouldn’t have signaled time.. Whilst Cameron was 30m off his line, as it might of distracted him…

 

[Bungeye]

Prior to 2021 I'm pretty sure you had to kick over the man on the mark. You weren't even allowed to deviate to allow for your natural arc.

 

[Chief]

Sorry - rogue addon chewing up our resources. Be back to normal in a minute.

 

[T2B_]

BigFooty servers melting tonight