Rumour Bluemour Discussion XXXVII - A return to normalcy

[FlowersByIrene]

Alex Witherden would be another nice option to look at. I'm a bit surprised that West Coast delisted him. He has played 53 games in the last three years in the backlines of a bad team. He has only just turned 26.

He is about a tenth of the player Newman is. Same ability to get the ball but can't kick and can't defend.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

He is about a tenth of the player Newman is. Same ability to get the ball but can't kick and can't defend.

And sounds like he was voted off the island at BL.

 

[Beyond Blue]

Also from your unattributed source that you've tried to quote our of context:

Scouting notes: NAB League Boys - Round 1

IN the opening round of the NAB League Boys competition, we took a look at all six games with our writers giving their opinion on how some of the players raised by respective Talent Managers as ones to watch, performed in the first round. All notes are the opinion of the individual writer...

central.rookieme.com

Scouting notes: NAB League Boys - Round 2

THERE were plenty of massive individual performances in an historic weekend of NAB League football, and we had reporters at all nine games to take in the action. Key players and talent touted by each club’s talent manager are included, with scouting notes the opinion of each individual writer...

central.rookieme.com

Scouting notes: NAB League Boys - Round 3

ANOTHER blockbuster weekend of NAB League footy saw the best of the best stake their claims as the next big things, with one particular game showcasing some enormous talent to come. With scouts eyeing all nine games across the round, these are our individual, opinion-based thoughts on the...

central.rookieme.com

As you can see, he split time between midfield and forward in what little NAB League he played in 2019, averaging just shy of 5 clearances a game.

Scouting notes: Under 18 Australian side

IN what has become an annual tradition, Australia’s top Under 18s combined to form a side to face a Victorian Football League (VFL) team in a one-off practice match. After defeating North Melbourne last year, the AFL Academy made it two wins on the trot with a victory over last year’s grand...

central.rookieme.com

At the Champs, his first two games were in defence due to coaching fears around their defensive stocks, but he dominated the games, stringing up intercepts and bolting out of defence with the ball.

Here's game 3:

Scouting notes: AFL U18 Championships – Vic Country vs. South Australia

VIC Country kept its perfect 2019 National Championships record in tact with a heart-stopping one-point win over South Australia at on Sunday. We were on hand at GMHBA Stadium to note the standouts from either side – and there were plenty – with the opinion-based notes that of each individual...

central.rookieme.com

27 disposals, 5 clearances, and a game winning goal.

Scouting notes: AFL U18 Championships - Vic Country vs. Western Australia

WESTERN Australia took out the AFL Under-18 National Championships title with a narrow victory over Vic Country thanks to a goal after the siren. We were on hand to note down some of the prominent players, with all notes opinion-based of the individual writer. Vic Country: By: Peter Williams #2...

central.rookieme.com

So arguably the top key position prospect coming into the year went to work on his endurance base and forced his way into the midfield, then did it again at the highest level.


In summary: you have this wrong, though that should have been obvious given what you quoted.

IMO Under 18 draft scouting reports are useful until the players start playing league footy and then they are largely redundant as it’s very difficult translating junior abilities successfully to senior footy.

Whilst it’s possible he could become a good midfielder, Kemp would need a significant step change in all aspects of his game to do so. I’d put the chances of that happening at 25-30% probability.

 

[WalshYouLegend]

Any juicy rumours from ITKs about whether we are going to split our pick 3 or keep it and who we are going to select with it?

Hungry

 

[Jimmae]

IMO Under 18 draft scouting reports are useful until the players start playing league footy and then they are largely redundant as it’s very difficult translating junior abilities successfully to senior footy.

Whilst it’s possible he could become a good midfielder, Kemp would need a significant step change in all aspects of his game to do so. I’d put the chances of that happening at 25-30% probability.

Name literally anything you're referring to, please.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Any juicy rumours from ITKs about whether we are going to split our pick 3 or keep it and who we are going to select with it?

Hungry

Keeping it. We have our target.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Keeping it. We have our target.

Aaaannnnnnndddd……..??????

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Aaaannnnnnndddd……..??????

We’re going to be passing at this selection

 

[GT619]

Any juicy rumours from ITKs about whether we are going to split our pick 3 or keep it and who we are going to select with it?

Hungry

plenty of time for that. be patient. do something else

 

[Jimmae]

Keeping it. We have our target.

And if the target goes early, will we trade down with Richmond or the Saints using 3 & 38?

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

And if the target goes early, will we trade down with Richmond or the Saints using 3 & 38?

I’m not sure what the contingency plan is.

 

[marcmurphy3]

I’m not sure what the contingency plan is.

What's the level of confidence we get him at 3?

 

[BlueTongue]

What's the level of confidence we get him at 3?

1 in 3

 

[Beyond Blue]

Name literally anything you're referring to, please.

I’m really not sure how to respond to that but I’ll give it a go.

IMO Kemp doesn’t have any AFL quality midfield qualities which isn’t really surprising given he hasn’t played or trained as a midfielder in the 5 years he has been on an AFL list. To say that Kemp does based on a rookie scouting report >6 years ago is generous.

 

[mrkyuss]

Had burst speed as a Jnr. That’s an afl mid trait

 

[Blue and Silver]

Kemp will be best used as an intercept defender given license to run and gun.

Or to put it another way McGovern's role.

Yes he looks bad playing as our second key defender. He doesn't have the aptitude for a key defensive post

On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[zeeCFC]

Whatever Kemp is, he needs to improve at it. He did well in games the midfield dominated but was shakey when under pressure and ultimately only played in his non preferred role due to injuries by the end of the year. We would be better served trying to get Lewis Young

33

Lewis Young

Age

25

Ht

202cm

Wt

99kg

Pos.

Def

Career

Season

Last 5

D

11.6

3star

K

7.5

3star

HB

4.1

3star

M

4.4

4star

T

1.6

4star

MG

197.9

3star

D

4.0

1star

K

3.0

1star

HB

1.0

1star

M

3.0

3star

T

0.0

1star

MG

26.0

1star

D

14.4

4star

K

8.2

4star

HB

6.2

4star

M

6.4

5star

T

2.0

4star

MG

181.6

3star

up to scratch

 

[DollarsandSense]

We’re going to be passing at this selection

Does it start with Dr and ends in aper?

 

[ctwenty1]

I’m not sure what the contingency plan is.

You mean we don’t have a Plan B?

 

[Jimmae]

I’m really not sure how to respond to that but I’ll give it a go.

IMO Kemp doesn’t have any AFL quality midfield qualities which isn’t really surprising given he hasn’t played or trained as a midfielder in the 5 years he has been on an AFL list. To say that Kemp does based on a rookie scouting report >6 years ago is generous.

He has clean, fast hands, he has burst from congestion, agility, keeps the ball ticking over and pretty good vision for a long pass by foot.

You're just so used to watching him track in a defensive zone or forcing a pack up forward you've forgotten what he looks like when he gets to dictate his own movement, but you're doing so with an enormous amount of bias:



I dunno how you're not seeing it. Again, I ask you to name a specific thing you feel he can't do in a hypothetical midfield role that he's not already been doing in a variety of defensive roles.

It all comes down to his ability to apply tactics and read the tap to help his team get an effective clearance, something we haven't really done outside of dominant taps/unblocked runs or TDK breaking open the play, so it's not like the bar can be any lower.