Was it? Tredrea played in a different era And yet has a worse goal average per game then hawkins from lower games. He only kicked more than 7 goals once. That was 8 goals against a vfl level post salary capt cheating carlton. his best season was better then hawkins best season but not by a lot and he only did that once. tredrea also didnt have the supreme passing skills and dominant ruckwork skills of hawkins.
Slightly different though. When Tredrea played there was still the distinction before full forward and centre half forward. He was the latter.