Changes For Melbourne

[statman87]

After another disappointing game we again come to the time to select the next weeks team my changes will be as follow

In
Surjan :superb for the Maggie's
Brogan : if fit


Out
Trengrove : (if injured) which is more than likely
Stewart : 6 touches not good enough

EMG : Motlop , Salopek , Davenport

No real pushers from the Sanfl as only a few played but on those who did play Surj was the best and Mots and Sal played ok, so thats the way i selected

 

[finbarr]

Out - Chad Cornes, Kane Cornes, Ebert.

In - Don't know yet.

 

[PatientMental]

Out:
Daniel Spudwart - Never again
David Rodan - Keeps getting subbed with his almighty 6 touches
Kane Cornes - Did nothing

In:
Motlop - 4 Goals 1
Surjan - Must have been bog
Brogan - If fit

Positives:
Gray, Hartlett, Lobbe played to the level we expect week in week out and Hitchcock finally had some impact as a sub albeit in junk time.

 

[statman87]

Out:
Daniel Spudwart - Never again
David Rodan - Keeps getting subbed with his almighty 6 touches
Kane Cornes - Did nothing

In:
Motlop - 4 Goals 1
Surjan - Must have been bog
Brogan - If fit

Positives:
Gray, Hartlett, Lobbe played to the level we expect week in week out and Hitchcock finally had some impact as a sub albeit in junk time.

i agree with rodan i think 6 i not enough but kane didnt play that bad he had 21 touches thats good enough and stewart 6 did absolutely nothing

 

[PatientMental]

Kane has a problem and it's his hospital ball kicks.

 

[Quadzilla]

i agree with rodan i think 6 i not enough but kane didnt play that bad he had 21 touches thats good enough and stewart 6 did absolutely nothing

kane - ok 21 touches - kicked sideways or hospital high floaters, stopped play (ok he wasnt the only one), got in way of Schulz lead in last - Shulz would've had a set shot from 50 - Kane kicked high to the square and nothing!!!

He once was a great tagger/accumulator but the game has passed him by ...

Rodan as a sub or nothing now

 

[BigBroMike]

i agree with rodan i think 6 i not enough but kane didnt play that bad he had 21 touches thats good enough and stewart 6 did absolutely nothing

yo statman stop looking at stats and watch the game for a change and you'll realize why kane needs to go. Even though Rodan had a quarter of the amount of possesion of Kane he still had twice as much influence on the game with the possesion he got.

 

[reCOGnise]

Kane has a problem and it's his hospital ball kicks.

Think you will find that he has many more than that. Can add, slow both leg speed and reaction time, always seems to be rushed when disposing, i mean who ****ing gets a handball smothered???!!!

 

[Shane_Mag]

Out: Kane Cornes, Daniel Stewart, Jackson Trengove(Injured)

In: Anybody who will provide something good towards the team.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Out:
Kane Cornes - Not good enough, played horribly. 21 touches of pure filth.
Brett Ebert - Useless
Jackson Trengove - Injured

In:
Steven Salopek - Been somewhat consistent at SANFL level and think he offers more than Kane.
Jacob Surjan - Stopped sleeping with Primus's wife and needs to come back.
Dean Brogan - Should be back

Rodan as sub.

 

[*PAF]

I would like to see Cassisi, Pearce + 5 other through the midfield who can run and kick the ball.
Out of the midfield everyone that has crappy kicking skills.

 

[statman87]

yo statman stop looking at stats and watch the game for a change and you'll realize why kane needs to go. Even though Rodan had a quarter of the amount of possesion of Kane he still had twice as much influence on the game with the possesion he got.

i was at the game and there was easily 10 worse than kane and road runner was unfortunately one of them

 

[statman87]

As a Glenelg supporter could anyone please let me know how Chad played today?

Roswell, he played very well and it wasnt the case about touches he did a great job on Fisher and was in every fight we had standing up for the club he loves

 

[Honeyboy Wilson]

Did as well as he could considering how smashed our midfield was. Killed Fisher, hence screwing my Supercoach score for the round.

 

[DonDraper]

Out: Stewart, Trengove (), Ebert
In: Motlop (We're playing in Darwin, he'll love it!), Broges, Surjan

Would also like Kane to be dropped but it won't happen. Chad to play and give us a bit of fight

 

[statman87]

Thanks Mate. Was really concerned he was on a bit of a hiding to nothing today. Was crossing everything that he got a decent go and could get into the game.
Hoping he gets to finish out the year with you guys. His passion, leadership and ability warrant that he gets to do so.
Thank you

i hope so too mate, i agree with everything you say, for your sake i hope the hawks do well for the rest of the year mate

 

[b0ydman]

i dont know where to start

we cant keep playing jacobs can we?
but we need to play him dont we?

broadbent surely rhats going on? are you slow, sleepy or just lazy?

ebert you've been great but sorry bud.

why bring in salopek? we know what his upside is and its no better than he's done for the past 5 years?

i just don't know.

maybe try jacobs up forward. drop htchock. i mean come on he's a squirt. we know he needs a bigger build:

stewart well that's obvious. but is it his fault if no one delivers it into the forward line because we don't even play one?

we are discussing deck chair here under captain primus.

we could have brown hall reiwolt dawes cloke and lecrasand still lose if it isn't kicked there or they are all at half back.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

i dont know where to start

we cant keep playing jacobs can we?
but we need to play him dont we?

broadbent surely rhats going on? are you slow, sleepy or just lazy?

ebert you've been great but sorry bud.

why bring in salopek? we know what his upside is and its no better than he's done for the past 5 years?

i just don't know.

maybe try jacobs up forward. drop htchock. i mean come on he's a squirt. we know he needs a bigger build:

stewart well that's obvious. but is it his fault if no one delivers it into the forward line because we don't even play one?

we are discussing deck chair here under captain primus.

we could have brown hall reiwolt dawes cloke and lecrasand still lose if it isn't kicked there or they are all at half back.

We were playing Jacobs down back for a lot of today, and at times on Goddard.

I mean, wtf is that kind of match up. Kid is going to get smashed.

Im all for playing Ben, but not sure why were are considering to play him down back.

 

[PatientMental]

Except the fact that Brown, Hall, Riewoldt/s, Cloke and LeCras know how to get the ball themselves, Stewart doesn't and hasn't showed he ever can.

 

[Schulzenfest]

What should happen:

Out: Ebert (forever), Kane, Rodan, Salter (or Trengove if injured), Stewart
In: Phillips, Moore, Motlop, Surjan, Brogan

What will happen:
Out: Ebert, Stewart, Trengove if injured
In: Motlop, Brogan, Pettigrew if Trengove injured

 

[WHOME]

Deck chairs
Titanic

 

[Wargreymon90]

A slow lazy Salopek is a million times better than broadbent. I would even say that Moore is a lot better that broadbent.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Broady was a huge spark to our team a couple of weeks ago, too many forget too quickly.

Not sure wtf has happened the past 2/3 weeks though

 

[Wargreymon90]

With the amount of game time broady has been given he should have had more than 1 good game. Big let down

 

[Waspy79]

The cupboard is bare.