Preview Changes for Semi Final v GWS Giants. Saturday night at MCG; Latest: No changes

[domus]

View attachment 558074

That pic is hilarious. I love the way Toby plays.

 

[domus]

Most watchers reckoned he was right to go last week. Even Liam Pickering said on SEN he was right to go last week, just got held back because of the length of the trip.
That's why I reckon we are playing funny buggers now. Suddenly Reid is ahead of him and Moore is borderline. If we make it through to next week it'll be 'it's been too long since Moore has played, can't risk him in a prelim'.

I might be reading too much into it, but I don't think the reason he isn't being selected is because he isn't ready.

Maybe. It is strange.

 

[10571z]

Kelly play? Seems no chance from
History. I think gws playing funny buggers and will be a late out

 

[Pies_10]

Kelly play? Seems no chance from
History. I think gws playing funny buggers and will be a late out

They'll name him for sure but he won't play.

 

[vicparksfinest]

Could Moore not being named Ben because the club knows he's leaving, he's traininng the house down and putting his hand up but Bucks just won't because he's put the door? Probably isn't the reason but just theory.
Only an hour half till put out of waiting misery.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Could Moore not being named Ben because the club knows he's leaving, he's traininng the house down and putting his hand up but Bucks just won't because he's put the door? Probably isn't the reason but just theory.
Only an hour half till put out of waiting misery.

He’d play if he was thought in this weeks best 22.

The leaving business is a red herring.

Mr Buckley would rather win a final than play childish games with players that will or won’t leave.

 

[ottoman]

Could Moore not being named Ben because the club knows he's leaving, he's traininng the house down and putting his hand up but Bucks just won't because he's put the door? Probably isn't the reason but just theory.
Only an hour half till put out of waiting misery.

If he is fit and not getting a game then this is the only reason I can think of that he is not getting a game.

 

[ottoman]

He’d play if he was thought in this weeks best 22.

The leaving business is a red herring.

Mr Buckley would rather win a final than play childish games with players that will or won’t leave.

Not sure about that SV. I have heard coaches openly state that they would not play a player that they knew was leaving the club.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Not sure about that SV. I have heard coaches openly state that they would not play a player that they knew was leaving the club.

Talk is cheap.

Winning finals is forever.

 

[Jafo]

That pic is hilarious. I love the way Toby plays.

I’m sure if Tobyson was headed to Pieland, we’d be lining up to build him his own Dojo of worship and he’d be personally sponsored by Dusty’s favourite place- “Mr. Myagi.”

 

[Jafo]

Not sure about that SV. I have heard coaches openly state that they would not play a player that they knew was leaving the club.

That was Roos. But i’m Sure someone heard Buddy was going and had finals, he wouldn’t be benched.

 

[MagpieBat]

Why would he bother training if that is the case?

It's about "work" on the track, and whether he has had enough "work" pumped into him to play a full game.

It's a complex calculation worked out on an abacus using Pythagorean theorem and forumlae from the Theory of Relativity...

 

[Anzacday]

That pic is hilarious. I love the way Toby plays.

There's some lame ones and some excellent ones here...
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/thre...-kung-fu-fighter.1204300/page-4#post-57879271

 

[jmac70]

Sounds like Reid is ready and Moore isn’t.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Please don't give me music advice re.
Your taste in music is atrocious.

Don't see you get any likes for your post.. seems as though everyone likes my taste in music bar you re.. Vegemite posts getting to ya no doubt re.

 

[Toecrusher]

If he is fit and not getting a game then this is the only reason I can think of that he is not getting a game.

How would we feel if he broke down halfway through Q1? Maybe the club isn't prepared to take the risk.

I want to see him play, but would be filthy if he broke down again. I'm guessing I'm not the only one like that.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Is there a definitive answer here..

Josh Kelly going to play or not?

Say it's just the slightest tear of the miniscus.. can you still play on it? Wtf is a miniscus anyhow.. wait lemme have a look.

 

[CFC2010]

Is there a definitive answer here..

Josh Kelly going to play or not?

Say it's just the slightest tear of the miniscus.. can you still play on it? Wtf is a miniscus anyhow.. wait lemme have a look.

How long does it take to recover from a torn meniscus?

Your meniscal tear will commonly take up to six or eight weeks to fully heal. As mentioned previously, some meniscal tears will require surgery. Your physiotherapist will guide you as to what is most likely for your knee injury

 

[neilk]

Is there a definitive answer here..

Josh Kelly going to play or not?

Say it's just the slightest tear of the miniscus.. can you still play on it? Wtf is a miniscus anyhow.. wait lemme have a look.

Cartilage maybe easier for you.

 

[papp0u27]

Dal Santo on SEN was saying that you need a minimum of 2 weeks off with a torn meniscus, and thats being desperate. No chance he plays and does further damage to his knee.

 

[Maggie5]

Is there a definitive answer here..

Josh Kelly going to play or not?

Say it's just the slightest tear of the miniscus.. can you still play on it? Wtf is a miniscus anyhow.. wait lemme have a look.

According to GWS board, Not.

 

[CFC2010]

Doctor Google is back...……

Recovery times differ depending on the severity of the injury: A minor, or grade 1, MCL tear can take from a few days to a week and a half to heal sufficiently for you to return to normal activities, including sports. A grade 2 tear can take from two to four weeks to heal.

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Talk is cheap.

Winning finals is forever.

Whether or not Moore is Sydney bound, he is still our player and should be selected if he is fit. It's stupid to do otherwise if the club is serious about winning finals' games. Plus a good game from Moore, even if it is his last, will only enhance his trade value. I would be really disappointed if he was overlooked because he may leave the club.

 

[BringouttheGimp]

Cartilage maybe easier for you.

No need to be smart about it re.

Didn't wanna embarrass ya re.. but I heard about your cartilage injury when the ball richocet back off a gum tree re.. nice shot re!

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Pies by 36 points. I think we will play our grand final on Saturday...Moore unfortunately won't be selected, hence l think we have seen him play his last game for the Pies against Sydney, round 20....No change to last week's team, in my opinion.