Preview Changes: R21 2019 vs West Coast

Changes for West Coast?


  • Total voters
    55
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

The hope would be some combination of Jones/Galluci/Stengle in and some combination of Douglas/Gibbs/Mackay/Knight/Atkins out. Seedsman is probably preferably to some of those outs, too. In reality, well...

Hartigan was awful, and Otten being in the side remains uncomfortable, but is Keath ready to come back? And assuming Jenkins remains demoted (as the rumours suggest), the coaches'd presumably want to keep Otten as relief ruck?
 
Out: Otten, Hartigan, Atkins, Knight, Douglas
In: Keath, Butts, Gallucci, Jones, Stengle

Done
Would instantly make us a far better side...

Atkins is a complete joke.. I wish they’d delist him.. not even trade him as you wouldn’t wish him upon your worst enemy.
Knight provides nothing
Douglas is a total liability
Hartigan is horrid
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

It was clear during the Port game that Douglas should never play for us again.

It was painfully obvious again tonight. If he doesn’t go out for Jones then we really are a lost cause.
Jones and Gallucci should both be playing instead of Douglas and Knight. Midfield got smashed again and Gibbs made no difference.
 
I’m all aboard the drop Douglas train, don’t get me wrong, but the fact that he is being stationed in this ridiculous half forward role that he’s never performed well in is a joke. Then he goes back to the SANFL and plays on the ball? Why?

Each week at the moment there’s a painfully obvious player who will be dropped. Against the bombers, it was Greenwood. Against Carlton, it was Wilson. Tonight, it was Knight.

What I would do...

Out: Knight, Douglas, Mackay, Hartigan, Otten, Atkins

In: Keath, Seedsman, Jones, Greenwood, Gallucci, Sholl


B: Brown Talia Kelly
HB: Laird Keath Smith
C: Seedsman B Crouch Jones
HF: Lynch Fogarty Milera
F: Betts Walker Murphy
R: O’Brien Sloane M Crouch
Int: Gibbs, Greenwood, Sholl, Gallucci


A far more likely outcome...

Out: Knight, Otten
In: Jones (or Gallucci), Keath

How some of these other clowns are being retained is anyone’s guess.

The slow ball movement is comical.

We are going to be annihilated by West Coast. Brace yourselves.
 
Out Fog in JJ. (I hope not) Hartigan needs to go , but who will replace him against the two big forwards? (unless they brink Keith back) Andbring some players in who understand Don's Chinese checker midfield defence forward movement
 
Knight and Atkins have to go for Jones and Seedsman at a minimum!
If Keath is right to go replace him with Hartigan
Yes there are probably a few others that need to be replaced but that's were they need to start
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Changes: R21 2019 vs West Coast

Back
Top