Preview Changes round 18 v West Coast

[ilikepotatoes]

in: Suban, Sandilands
out: Mcpharlin (suspended?), Clarke
p.s. it is round 18

 

[Bradesmaen]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

In: Suban, Sandilands (If fit)
Out: Mzungu, Clarke

 

[DCFCFAN84]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

In: Sandilands (If fit)
Out: Clarke

No need to rush Suban let him find some form first. Also need to stop bombing the ball out of the back 50 in kick INS it hurt us today and will cost us the game against the eagles!!!

 

[Beetlebum]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

I'd say the same with Sandilands, lets make sure he is actually fit, the last thing we need is for him to come back next week and break down in the middle of the 2nd quarter..

 

[free at last]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Haven't seen the maca bump, so can't make comment.
Maca would have no carry over points ?
Barlow full game next week you would think, is the only change,without knowing of injuries.

 

[ritz]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Anyone think sandi could be a possible sub? We need top notch ruck work against w.c. We could sub johnno or Clarke or griff out?

 

[Mockcockpit]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Suban for Palmer
See how the rest pull up, Johnson looked proppy in the last.

 

[Admiral Byng]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Anyone think sandi could be a possible sub? We need top notch ruck work against w.c. We could sub johnno or Clarke or griff out?

Sub should always be a utility type or spare mid IMHO, to cover for potential injury. Too much risk having a smaller player subbed off through injury and having a tall as the sub.

 

[malpaso]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Suban for Palmer
See how the rest pull up, Johnson looked proppy in the last.

I agree. Suban for Palmer.

Depending on how Johnson pulls up, maybe Mellington comes in as well.

 

[Scham]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

The trainers carried someone off in the last - who was that?

Depending on the above and Jonno's calf there should only be one change;

Sandi in for Clarke BUT only if he's 100%. Otherwise I'd be happy to go unchanged.

There's no real need for Suban to come back against the Eagles. We'll need him the week after though to have a crack at Rioli.

 

[creamygoodness]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Clarke looked good I think, I really don't think Griffin complements Sandi at all as a backup.

 

[Seppo]

Not sure how serious they are but speaking to a few guys after the game some pulled up sore and had a limp: Roger, Johnson, Griffin.

Also Roberton had an iceberg strapped to his arm, while McPhee and Barlow said they pulled up really well and glad for the run.

 

[Mockcockpit]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Clarke looked good I think, I really don't think Griffin complements Sandi at all as a backup.

If Sandi comes back in Griffin will go out and I bet Clarke will run with Sideshow Bob.

 

[E Shed]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Clarke looked good I think, I really don't think Griffin complements Sandi at all as a backup.

Yes it's Griffen that will lose his place when Sandi resumes. Clarke is doing good things in the mobile tall utility type role that seems to have become fashionable with the sub rule.
Doubt Palmer will be omitted, he seems to be finding some touch.
Suban will play if he's fit enough.

 

[Righteo]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

I have absolutely no idea who we have that can replace McPharlin.Time for the Faulks maybe?

 

[Freodoc]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

I have absolutely no idea who we have that can replace McPharlin.Time for the Faulks maybe?

Faulks is not setting the world on fire at WAFL level.

?? JA ??


(Ducks for cover)

 

[DockerLand1]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Faulks is not setting the world on fire at WAFL level.

?? JA ??


(Ducks for cover)

It sounds like the Elvis incident is pretty bad. This may call for the.....

SIBO[/SIZE]

 

[Freodoc]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Actually, depending on camera angle, Elvis incident isn't too bad. The guy who got hit didn't stay down for long either.

But please, not Sibo!!! Would probably have Jonno on crutches first...

 

[wild side]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Harvs said in his presser that 211 was 50/50 for next week.
Therefore, I'd say no !

 

[Tweedy]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Harvs said in his presser that 211 was 50/50 for next week.
Therefore, I'd say no !

Giving him another week has the bonus of delaying the crunch decision of who to drop - Griffin or Clarke. Even if the medics sound the all clear I hope Harves plays it safe.

 

[FREO81]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

OUT: Roberton,????
IN: Suban Sandilands

 

[Freo4life]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

I think our hand may be forced if Griffin doesn't come up in time.
Can't really comment on ins until later in the week, but i would like to see Clancee and Kep in and Roberton and Johnson out.

 

[Seppo]

I really want to see Mellington in the forward line against the Eagles. not sure about brining in Keps, maybe in place of MJ if any doubt.

If at selection time Griff and Sandi are feeling 90%, I would go for Sandi. He'll win a heap of free kicks and i would love to see him run thru Cox and drop him.
Clarke did some pretty good pinch hitting today and really used his body well. Had the tank to follow the ball for most of the day.

 

[DeanS]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

The trainers carried someone off in the last - who was that?

Depending on the above and Jonno's calf there should only be one change;

Sandi in for Clarke BUT only if he's 100%. Otherwise I'd be happy to go unchanged.

There's no real need for Suban to come back against the Eagles. We'll need him the week after though to have a crack at Rioli.

I have a very bad feeling it was the Genius. If so, it strengthens the call for Suban to come in.

 

[bigpav]

Re: Changes round 17 v West Coast

Duffield OUT
Mellington IN

Suban another week in the WAFL
Sandi as two more weeks off, bring him back for th Saints in Melbourne
Barlow plays a full game, Mellington the Sub