Unofficial Preview Changes V Carlton: White omitted, Marsh injured, Moore and Goldsack in

[Saintly Viewed]

Why does everyone want to get rid of Jesse White? As long as he can contribute his 2 or 3 goals a game and smash a few packs, then he stays in. Yes he can make some stupid errors, but if he's not the main man down forward, he can just chime in every now and then. And he can be played in the ruck and down back if required.

As for Varcoe, he provides class, run and tackling pressure. Definitely stays in.

Well said.
White has earned his spot, I'm a bit surprised but he's been pretty good. So kudos to him

 

[Saintly Viewed]

wtf is everyone in here smoking?
No change!

 

[Saintly Viewed]

No change.

Stability would be great for a change (pun intended)

ps Moore will have a run, half a game, whatever, in the magoos I would guess to gauge his fitness etc

 

[TradeDraft]

Just on 5 weeks out of the game by the time Saturday rolls around.

He's coming back through the seconds.

Well then Hopefully comes out and Kick 10 next week vs Northern Blues

 

[Shaneprice97]

I thought aish was decent last night, shouldnt be dropped, especially for Crocker.

 

[Maggie5]

Was good but bit like Blair. Did not do much else

Stop knocking Blair, 19 possessions, 11 contested and 7 tackles (only Greenwood 12, got more tackles). One of the first I would pick every week.

 

[Shaneprice97]

Phillips seems to have abit of ticker about him, he looks like a runs hard aswell, my second favorite debutant behind Cox this year.

 

[Shaneprice97]

Moore comes back through the VFL, hes only as good as our current forwards. Coxs averages more goals and creates plenty of opportunities, Cloke is better and played well last week and White shouldnt be dropped.

 

[Vicky Park]

Very glad to be able to say no changes this week (please).

 

[mike123]

Bring Aish in has a Good Game then Drop Him?

So IF you do that you might as well stay in the VFL and we Wasted the 2nd Rounders Picking him up

I wouldn't call the game he had good. I want him to stay in the team but I don't think we have a role for him.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

I thought aish was decent last night, shouldnt be dropped, especially for Crocker.

Aish was quite ok.
Like him to have an extended run

 

[Go Pies!!!!!]

No change

 

[doodles98]

Stop knocking Blair, 19 possessions, 11 contested and 7 tackles (only Greenwood 12, got more tackles). One of the first I would pick every week.

It's boring isn't it. Blair was one of our best and he still gets the calls to be dropped. He was at the bottom of nearly every pack and did a lot more for us than even his good stats show.

 

[Go Pies!!!!!]

Not Sure. See VFL 1st.

But at Moment Pre-VFL:

In: Moore ?

Out: White Varcoe

Surely you are taking the piss suggesting Varcoe out

 

[doodles98]

Simply Moore is Better

Don't be greedy. Moore is not always better TD. White is alright

 

[TradeDraft]

Stop knocking Blair, 19 possessions, 11 contested and 7 tackles (only Greenwood 12, got more tackles). One of the first I would pick every week.

You Pick Blair over Pendles,Treloar,Sidebottom and Reid?

 

[Go Pies!!!!!]

Stop knocking Blair, 19 possessions, 11 contested and 7 tackles (only Greenwood 12, got more tackles). One of the first I would pick every week.

Blair was very good last night

 

[Saintly Viewed]

It's boring isn't it. Blair was one of our best and he still gets the calls to be dropped. He was at the bottom of nearly every pack and did a lot more for us than even his good stats show.

He did well.
Glad he showed me

 

[Saintly Viewed]

You Pick Blair over Pendles,Treloar,Sidebottom and Reid?

Not quite sure she be saying that.
But good on her for giving Blair the kudos he deserved

 

[Finnishpie]

Stop knocking Blair, 19 possessions, 11 contested and 7 tackles (only Greenwood 12, got more tackles). One of the first I would pick every week.

I just wish he'd kick those easy goals.What's his accuracy this year?

 

[Anzacday]

Yes you could, they both did enough to deserve a game. Aish has more upside of course.

Blairs hard work in and under in the forward 50 goes unrecognised.

Not by me.
He did some great stuff last night.

 

[CFC2010]

Stop knocking Blair, 19 possessions, 11 contested and 7 tackles (only Greenwood 12, got more tackles). One of the first I would pick every week.

The thing that annoys me Maggie and this may be a coaches directive is IMO he plays too high up the ground.

We have a beast at full forward and he should be at his feet because even when Cox is getting double teamed he rarely gets out marked.

Why he is a forward marking target so often confuses me.

Maybe it's my limited brain cells but why don't we have more crumbers (e.g Sidebottom) at our forwards feet?

 

[DrDavoren]

Simply Moore is Better

Moore has more upside and skills, however White has been solid this year and is much more consistent.
No point in rushing Moore back as we need some stability at the moment and Moore will get his chance as he is definitely going to be our key forward for the next decade.

 

[mike123]

I thought aish was decent last night, shouldnt be dropped, especially for Crocker.

Need a forward to come in to allow Varcoe to play on the wing

 

[Anzacday]