Unofficial Preview Changes V Carlton: White omitted, Marsh injured, Moore and Goldsack in

[Maggie5]

The thing that annoys me Maggie and this may be a coaches directive is IMO he plays too high up the ground.

We have a beast at full forward and he should be at his feet because even when Cox is getting double teamed he rarely gets out marked.

Why he is a forward marking target so often confuses me.

Maybe it's my limited brain cells but why don't we have more crumbers (e.g Sidebottom) at our forwards feet?

Maybe because he has more brains and works harder by making space than our forwards do, especially White.

I really don't mind he, he always is in the plus for metres gained and he is always working hard. Not sure why some don't see what he does. Further until Broomhead or someone similar pushes him out of the team, he stays for mine.

 

[Maggie5]

You Pick Blair over Pendles,Treloar,Sidebottom and Reid?

It is an expression used when you think someone is good enough to be in the team Dave.
No I not over them but pretty high up.

 

[Maggie5]

Out: White
In: Moore or whoever plays well on Sunday.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

WunnWun, This guy got dropped last week from GOT, let's bring him in making cox look small

 

[left at home]

Out: White
In: Moore or whoever plays well on Sunday.

l think white should stay and moore should prove his shoulder in the vfl

 

[left at home]

WunnWun, This guy got dropped last week from GOT, let's bring him in making cox look small

View attachment 260417

they kill off some of the best characters

 

[CFC2010]

Maybe because he has more brains and works harder by making space than our forwards do, especially White.

I really don't mind he, he always is in the plus for metres gained and he is always working hard. Not sure why some don't see what he does. Further until Broomhead or someone similar pushes him out of the team, he stays for mine.

I don't won't him out........love his heart & effort but I think he would hit the scoreboard more often closer to goals.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

**** me dead, White could have 40 & 5 and there's still be calls to drop him.

Has been very good this year. Unfairly maligned.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

they kill off some of the best characters

That they do.

I still havnt gotten over Ygritte

 

[Saintly Viewed]

**** me dead, White could have 40 & 5 and there's still be calls to drop him.

Has been very good this year. Unfairly maligned.

Agree, he's earning his keep.
Credit to him for going out and doing it.

 

[TradeDraft]

**** me dead, White could have 40 & 5 and there's still be calls to drop him.

Has been very good this year. Unfairly maligned.

Pretty Stupid Comment. IF he won't be called for Dropping and that be close to the best Game a KPD ever had

 

[left at home]

That they do.

I still havnt gotten over Ygritte

yes very delightful she was, nearly my favourite

 

[Maggie5]

I don't won't him out........love his heart & effort but I think he would hit the scoreboard more often closer to goals.

Agree. Normally a very good kick but has been off the last three games.

 

[Maggie5]

l think white should stay and moore should prove his shoulder in the vfl

Haven't seen the replay yet but from what I did see, think it is between his ears.

 

[unplugged]

I laugh at people who say player A had just as many disposals as player B, why not drop them instead, etc.

Stats aren't the be all and end all!

Better off watching the game, maybe even twice, and basing your judgement on that.

 

[left at home]

Pretty Stupid Comment. IF he won't be called for Dropping and that be close to the best Game a KPD ever had

dave he means no matter how well he going many including your good self at times want him
dropped when white does not deserve it

 

[left at home]

Haven't seen the replay yet but from what I did see, think it is between his ears.

sorry not quite sure the meaning of your reply to mine

 

[Saintly Viewed]

yes very delightful she was, nearly my favourite

I confess she's my favourite,
I liked the waif too

 

[sloth6]

Was good but bit like Blair. Did not do much else

Varcoe was excellent Dave c'mon mate.

His chasing, tackling, closing down space was terrific.

 

[left at home]

I confess she's my favourite,
I liked the waif too

waif to cold for me, like killing to much for me

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Bring these two in, one for the blues and one for us, or is it Richmond

 

[Maggie5]

sorry not quite sure the meaning of your reply to mine

Re: White, does some very dumb things during a game, should really work harder and either be a genuine option or a decoy for Cox/Cloke/Moore.
They are too often double teamed and obviously the opposition don't see him too much of a threat. But as I said didn't see all the game last night will have a better look after I have seen a replay.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

waif to cold for me, like killing to much for me

She'd be great off a half back flank

 

[left at home]

Varcoe was excellent Dave c'mon mate.

His chasing, tackling, closing down space was terrific.

yep varcoe pressure was very good, as l thought aish did also very early

 

[left at home]

Re: White, does some very dumb things during a game, should really work harder and either be a genuine option or a decoy for Cox/Cloke/Moore.
They are too often double teamed and obviously the opposition don't see him too much of a threat. But as I said didn't see all the game last night will have a better look after I have seen a replay.

l think most of our team do some very dumb things so white is not buy himself in that regard. just like to see darcy test his shoulder in the vfl first