Changes v Dogs

[Roos4eva]

What changes would you make against the Doggies?

IMO, I'd go in unchanged.

Possibly Josh Smith out for Warren or Ross, as it may be a little top heavy for the Dogs, but I think Smith did just enough to warrant another crack at it.

Can't see Harro coming in for anyone as Swallow and Power were very good today.

 

[gokangas]

Z might be in trouble. Laidley likes to make sure he doesnt overlaod the kids so it might be a week in (maybe two) and then two or so out. I'd give him another game.

 

[Benno_900]

If fit, maybe Ross for Smith. Changes aren't needed really.

 

[__aria__]

get ross in there he must play

 

[numchuks]

Smith out
Corey Jones in

 

[Mordecai]

Warren/Ross/Jones in for Smith.

 

[Mario the Lothario]

Z might be in trouble. Laidley likes to make sure he doesnt overlaod the kids so it might be a week in (maybe two) and then two or so out. I'd give him another game.

I think Z is the sort of hard bodied opportunist that could do something special against the Doggies.

I'd only consider dropping Josh Smith. He is a straight out hit up forward, and I thought our forward line was a little too top heavy today.

I'd actually consider bringing in Levi Greenwood for his first match.

 

[the smith show]

We need a lot more run against the dogs or we will be in trouble. Ross has to cone in.

Ross for smith.

 

[Virgil]

Smith would be the only questionable one I think, but I think it's worth getting games into him. The dogs will definitely be a good test based on the way they're playing tonight, we'll have to be on our toes.

Unchanged for mine.

 

[snrub]

Shannon Watt must be dropped. Oh wait... never mind.

 

[Tiberius]

I understood Shannon Watt was retained on the list specifically to play on Brad Johnson twice a year. He is after all the only forward in the league that Shannon is an ideal match up for. Bring him in I say!

 

[The Zebra]

We need a lot more run against the dogs or we will be in trouble. Ross has to cone in.

Ross for smith.

Yep.

 

[Carnthe]

I'll throw it out there, but Ross in for Gibbo. If we're going to play Gibbo as a mid then why not bring in someone who offers a bit more run.

 

[snapperbowler]

I believe that we didn't really have a medium marking forward today eg Jones.

I would bring in this type of player for Smith.

Not sure how long Harris will remain out.

He has to be in our best 22.

 

[Zondor]

I'd say No change and that should please Onip to no end.

Yeah and for those of yah suggesting that Josh Smith should make way for a Ross, Jones or Warren. How abouts dropping that Krusty the Clown character that looked like shit at full forward today?

And to think I picked that clown in my Dream Team. Thanks allot Zebs.

 

[True North]

I think J.Smith has to miss. We need a mid size forward so in Jones.

Lower can miss for Ross if we want more speed. Depends how badly we wan't to tag Gilbee.

This will be a massive test for our new midfield. Swallow, Firrito v Boyd, Cross. Wow.

Z can miss and I will understand.

 

[96_North_99]

I thought Smith presented quite well today and was OK overall.

Unchanged would be nice.

 

[DarwinRoo]

If Smith gets dropped Warren comes in. I don't see why Jones should unless he had a stellar game in the VFL praccy match.

 

[Roosurgence]

No point dropping Zeibell. He is only going to improve with more game time. Gibson and Lower would be in the firing line first in my book.

 

[Z_K]

Ziebell more than held his own. Lower will play on and beat Gilbee again.

 

[scottywiper]

No point dropping Zeibell. He is only going to improve with more game time. Gibson and Lower would be in the firing line first in my book.

Wash your mouth out with soap!
Ed must not be dropped. I'd be more in favour of him actually being tried on the ball.
Surely he offers more in that role than Gibbo.

 

[Roosurgence]

Wash your mouth out with soap!
Ed must not be dropped. I'd be more in favour of him actually being tried on the ball.
Surely he offers more in that role than Gibbo.

On today's performance Ed may likely be dropped. But I do agree Gibbo was utter crap today, has the awareness of a Kozshitzke. Get sick of him turning back into trouble and getting caught. He is not an onballer, so if he isn't going to play down back I can't see a spot for poor Gibbo. If Grima can hold down full back and Thompson is played as a third tall, Gibbo could be in massive trouble.

 

[Carnthe]

And to think I picked that clown in my Dream Team. Thanks allot Zebs.

If that is the case then the joke is on you Zondor.

 

[The Zebra]

Gibbo got caught out a couple of times in the midfield. But Gibbo is no where near dropping. No where near.

 

[The Zebra]

I'd say No change and that should please Onip to no end.

Yeah and for those of yah suggesting that Josh Smith should make way for a Ross, Jones or Warren. How abouts dropping that Krusty the Clown character that looked like shit at full forward today?

And to think I picked that clown in my Dream Team. Thanks allot Zebs.

Did you have Swallow? Dud.