Hong-Kong Phooey
Cancelled
FIFY now its perfect
Changes v GWS
- Thread starter Schulzenfest
- Start date
- Tagged users None
FIFY now its perfect
- Feb 7, 2010
- 5,008
- 5,603
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Leeds United, Portland Trailblazers
good summary, I agree with the majority.
Interesting re Redden. Not sure who owes who in that relationship, but given he has now put a full SANFL season behind him and can probably make it as an AFL ruckman, is he trade bait? I suspect there will be a few clubs asking about him.
scottjr
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 8, 2012
- 5,717
- 4,352
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Redden is the best WADA insurance we have. He's not up for trade unless we have a better option. We are buying Dixon to go forward not ruck. Gorringe we don't want. Leaves us with Redden Lobbe and a developing Frampton.
chiwigi
I’ll make tears from your Wines.
Out:
Gray
wingard
Hartlett
Schulz
White
Lobbe
In
Monfries
Ah chee
Krakoeur
butcher or Harvey
Amon
Redden
Time to test the depth or at least give them some game time.
Gray
wingard
Hartlett
Schulz
White
Lobbe
In
Monfries
Ah chee
Krakoeur
butcher or Harvey
Amon
Redden
Time to test the depth or at least give them some game time.
The Smaller Warrior
Bigger than Jesus #magic
- Mar 21, 2007
- 11,202
- 15,345
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Chelsea FC, Port Adelaide Magpies
Out: Lobbe, O'Shea, Schulz, Neade, Trengove, Colquhoun
In: Ah Chee, Butcher, Palmer, Krakouer, Monfries, Amon
Lobbe has been dreadful this year, think he is really struggling having an impact around the ground and with Ryder it's making that a lot more damaging for his game.
O'Shea has been dreadful.
Schulz hasn't been himself all year and needs to get his body ready for the next year, if that's with us or with who ever.
Neade was disastrous yesterday.
Trengove is either injured, or his head is elsewhere.
Muffins has a future here, but his disposal yesterday was dreadful.
Ah Chee should never have been dropped.
Butcher replaces Trengove down back, and though it will really expose our back line Butch deserves his final chance in this team. Give him the rest of the year. Play him down back, and if the opportunity arises I would be happy for him to swing forward at times.
Palmer looks the goods, bring him in and let's blood a few games into him.
Krakouer has been one of our best all year, need him in the squad.
Monfries has been awful this year, but is better for a little run in the SANFL.
Amon is future. Future is now.
What will happen:
Out: Lobbe, Colquhoun
In: Mitchell, Monfries
Sub: Young
In: Ah Chee, Butcher, Palmer, Krakouer, Monfries, Amon
Lobbe has been dreadful this year, think he is really struggling having an impact around the ground and with Ryder it's making that a lot more damaging for his game.
O'Shea has been dreadful.
Schulz hasn't been himself all year and needs to get his body ready for the next year, if that's with us or with who ever.
Neade was disastrous yesterday.
Trengove is either injured, or his head is elsewhere.
Muffins has a future here, but his disposal yesterday was dreadful.
Ah Chee should never have been dropped.
Butcher replaces Trengove down back, and though it will really expose our back line Butch deserves his final chance in this team. Give him the rest of the year. Play him down back, and if the opportunity arises I would be happy for him to swing forward at times.
Palmer looks the goods, bring him in and let's blood a few games into him.
Krakouer has been one of our best all year, need him in the squad.
Monfries has been awful this year, but is better for a little run in the SANFL.
Amon is future. Future is now.
What will happen:
Out: Lobbe, Colquhoun
In: Mitchell, Monfries
Sub: Young
Time to make a call for the rest of the season: Prep for next year. They can get qualified for SANFL GF.
Schultz, Lobbe, Trengrove, Oshea, Ebert out. Krak, Harvey, Butch, Amon, AhChee in.
I'd like to see our best players in the middle around the stoppages more. Ryder, Wingard especially.
Schultz, Lobbe, Trengrove, Oshea, Ebert out. Krak, Harvey, Butch, Amon, AhChee in.
I'd like to see our best players in the middle around the stoppages more. Ryder, Wingard especially.
Power Raid
We Exist To Win Premierships
I wish you did the selections
Too much cruise control and no issues here at Alberton. We need to mix things up.
26 disposals and 4 goals in the SANFL
scottjr
Norm Smith Medallist
- Sep 8, 2012
- 5,717
- 4,352
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Ken did say during the week it was too late in the season for players to do anything that would change the clubs view on them. Butch on Patton isn't going to end well, it may not be Patton but if I'm a GWS midfielder I'm going to look for the closest tall to Butch.
chiwigi
I’ll make tears from your Wines.
I wouldn't put him in defence, GOOD GOD NO! I don't care where he has played SANFL.
Power Pete
Cancelled
- Jun 11, 2008
- 3,065
- 6,265
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
- Other Teams
- PAFC MAGPIES - NRL DRAGONS
OUT: Schulz - Lobbe - Pittard - Trengove
IN: Frampton - Harvey - Amon - Krakouer
IN: Frampton - Harvey - Amon - Krakouer
Heath shaw
In hindsight Monfries should have retired 2 years ago.
How does giving him a defensive role on Heath Shaw in a meaningless game do anything for our list development? Should we bring back Tom Logan as well?
How does giving him a defensive role on Heath Shaw in a meaningless game do anything for our list development? Should we bring back Tom Logan as well?
- Jan 30, 2013
- 16,166
- 16,559
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Agreed. Or he can stay on our list - but they should halve his salary for being too soft
PepeSilvia
Norm Smith Medallist
Yeah you're right lets just bring in palmer he'll contribute so much more than monfries; allow himself to get blanketed, shaw to have 10 rebound 50's and 30 odd disposals on the way to another loss yeah that's going to be so good for his confidence and our developing list.
- Jan 30, 2013
- 16,166
- 16,559
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Yeah you're right lets just bring in palmer he'll contribute so much more than monfries; allow himself to get blanketed, shaw to have 10 rebound 50's and 30 odd disposals on the way to another loss yeah that's going to be so good for his confidence and our developing list.
being selected for AFL can hardly be detrimental to your confidence. Shaw is an excellent player and that can be expected.
If some players can't deal with losses, **** them. right now we have to see who can cope with AFL football and who can't be it physical or mental. pour it on them. make them burn and see who comes out the ashes.
In hindsight, sure. You could get anyone to do a defensive job on the opposition half back. Even Thomas and Logan played decent games in that role.
Sounds good to me.
Musical chairs
In:
Brendan Ah Chee
Angus Monfries
Nathan Krakouer
Jesse Palmer
Out:
Cam O'Shea
Matthew Lobbe
Aaron Young
Sam Colqhoun
In:
Brendan Ah Chee
Angus Monfries
Nathan Krakouer
Jesse Palmer
Out:
Cam O'Shea
Matthew Lobbe
Aaron Young
Sam Colqhoun
Robbie4PM
All Australian
- May 18, 2015
- 836
- 1,004
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
unfortunately the same players who have been in and out the team all year will continue to be rotated. Joy.
Not a change, but a wtf moment?
I'm looking forward to Palmer getting a game. I'd also like to see Sam Russell get upgraded. It would be a change to see us play with a small defender interested in defending.
Similar threads
- Locked
